Heavy Duty Trucking Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

At Least 15 Lawsuits vs. Cat on ACERT Diesels Include Trucks, Buses

Multiple lawsuits against Caterpillar for chronic failures of its 2007-2010 ACERT diesels go beyond heavy trucks, and include school buses and motor coaches as well as at least one marine engine, according to news reports, while a wide variety of problems have been chronicled in discussion groups on the Internet.

by Staff
July 21, 2014
At Least 15 Lawsuits vs. Cat on ACERT Diesels Include Trucks, Buses

 

3 min to read


Multiple lawsuits against Caterpillar for chronic failures of its 2007-2010 ACERT diesels go beyond heavy trucks, and include school buses and motor coaches as well as at least one marine engine, according to news reports, while a wide variety of problems have been chronicled in discussion groups on the Internet.

At least 15 suits are now pending over Cat C13 and C15 engines, reports say, and some have been consolidated by a federal court to make them more manageable. Some suits are in state courts.

Ad Loading...

Law firms have filed suits on behalf of trucking and bus companies and at least one owner-operator, news reports say. A common complaint is that the engines are unreliable and repeatedly break down, leaving trucks, drivers and loads stranded while mechanics at truck dealers and Cat’s own distributors struggled to repair them.

Some fleets claim they lost hundreds of thousands of dollars in repairs and lost revenue; many disposed of their Cat-powered trucks early and bought vehicles with other engines. A boat fire in Florida prompted one suit, while a motor coach owner in California sued there.

Stories in the Wall Street Journal and the Journal Star of Peoria, Ill., Cat’s corporate home, said some suits have been settled with judgments ranging into the millions of dollars.

Ad Loading...

A school district in San Antonio, Tex., won $900,000 over engine failures and fires that destroyed at least two buses, reports said. Those presumably involved midrange C7 diesels, which used pollution-control equipment similar to those on the larger C13 and C15 engines.

Complaints on internet chat sites include vibrations, fuel starvation, injectors, cooling systems, diesel particulate filters, and the “seventh fuel injector” that provides heat for burning soot out of the DPFs. Some complaints date prior to the implementation of ACERT equipment.

ACERT, which stands for Advanced Combustion Emiussions Reduction Technology, was a key feature was the piping of filtered exhaust gas to combustion chambers instead of using unfiltered gas, as competitors did. This, too, was troublesome, users have claimed.

Effects on Cat’s financial performance are not known, but the huge, multi-national corporation earns billions of dollars a year and is probably in no danger. Cat’s main businesses are manufacturing machinery and engines for construction, mining, electric power generation, ships and boats, and railroad locomotives.

However, “The suits are a potential embarrassment for a company that regularly says the reliability of its products justifies premium prices,” noted the WSJ.

Ad Loading...

As is common in lawsuits brought against corporations, Cat has not commented on specific filings and complaints. In a statement last month, the company said, “Caterpillar Inc. is addressing various claims relating to alleged performance issues with emissions technology in some of its 2007 EPA-compliant C13 and C15 ACERT on-highway engines.

“Caterpillar has worked diligently to deliver operating cost improvements and other value-added features in its engines to enable our customers to benefit from this technology,” the statement said. “Our customers have utilized and had success with the performance of these engines in trucks, buses and RVs across millions of miles in North America.

“Caterpillar looks forward to addressing these allegations now that they have been consolidated in one forum.”

Cat left the truck- and bus-engine business at the end of 2009 when ever-tighter federal emissions limits made compliance increasingly expensive. Meanwhile, the market for vendor-supplied diesels was shrinking as truck builders used more of their own engines. Cummins is now the only independent engine supplier to commercial truck makers.

More Fuel Smarts

Fuel Smartsby StaffAugust 31, 2026

California Bill Could Shed Light on Electric Truck Prices

Why do battery-electric Class 8 trucks remain so expensive? A California bill headed to Gov. Gavin Newsom would give fleets and state agencies more visibility into what manufacturers charge.

Read More →
Illustration of Freightliner Cascadia on highway with engine cutaway
Equipmentby Deborah LockridgeAugust 27, 2026

Detroit Opens Orders for EPA 2027 Engines

Detroit isn’t starting from scratch to meet EPA 2027 diesel emissions standards. Its Gen 6 DD13 and DD15 engines keep much of today’s platform while updating the fuel and aftertreatment systems.

Read More →
Group of people and zero-emission trucks during ceremony announcing a West Coast ZEV corridor.
Fuel Smartsby News/Media ReleaseAugust 26, 2026

Zero-Emission Truck Corridor Planned for West Coast

California, Oregon, Washington, British Columbia and Baja California are coordinating plans for truck charging and hydrogen fueling from Canada to Mexico.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
YouTube thumbnail showing Kenworth T880e electric truck and KW marketing director Kyle Kimball.
Equipmentby Deborah LockridgeAugust 25, 2026

A Closer Look at Kenworth’s Electric T880E Vocational Truck [Video]

Learn more about Kenworth's T880E battery-electric vocational truck at the Paccar Technical Center, including its range, applications, upfitting considerations, and PTO options, in this HDT Spotlight video.

Read More →
White heavy-duty Kenworth T880e battery-powered straight truck with flatbed
Equipmentby Deborah LockridgeAugust 25, 2026

Kenworth T880E Brings EV Power to Vocational Trucks

A closer look at the Kenworth T880E’s range, charging, powertrain and upfit options — and where fleets are showing the most interest.

Read More →
Woman with red hair superimposed on background showing a King Fio electric Volvo truck at the port, plus the HDT Truck Fleet Innovators 2026 logo
Fuel Smartsby Deborah LockridgeAugust 14, 2026

Jennie Abarca Is Proving Electric Trucks Can Do the Job

HDT Truck Fleet Innovator Jennie Abarca is building confidence in fleet electrification one load at a time while openly sharing the challenges she encounters along the way as a small-fleet owner.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
EquipmentJuly 23, 2026

Cummins Adjusts 2027 Engine Rollout After EPA Proposal

The engine maker will gradually introduce its new Model Year 2027 diesel engines while continuing to offer current models during the transition, citing the EPA's proposed emissions rule changes.

Read More →
Four men in suits on the National Mall with giant video screen showing capitol building in the background
Equipmentby Deborah LockridgeJuly 10, 2026

EPA Proposal Could Ease 2027 Truck Costs and Buying Uncertainty

The proposal doesn't change the tougher NOx standard, but it would revise key implementation requirements that manufacturers say have driven up costs and complicated fleet purchasing decisions.

Read More →
Illustration showing Paccar MX engine with sketch illustration of DEF fill tank in background
Equipmentby Deborah LockridgeJuly 7, 2026

Cummins, Paccar Ease DEF Derates After EPA Guidance

Updated diesel engine software gives truck operators more time to address emissions-system issues while staying compliant with EPA emissions standards.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Illustration with wrenches in background with "Maintenance in the Messy Middle: Biodiesel" text and NACFE Run on Less logo
Maintenanceby Jack RobertsJuly 2, 2026

Maintenance in the Messy Middle Part 3: Biodiesel

Biodiesel can reduce emissions, improve fuel-system lubricity and use existing diesel infrastructure. But NACFE’s Messy Middle maintenance report says fleets must actively manage storage, cold-weather operation, filters and oil drain intervals to avoid problems.

Read More →