Lease vs. Own: Re-thinking Truck Ownership As Technology Changes
Several years ago, many fleets thought owning their own trucks made the most financial sense

By leasing trucks, Mims Meat could update its fleet immediately without straining the corporate credit line. Dan Mims says buying 16 trucks would have been tough financially.
Several years ago, many fleets thought owning their own trucks made the most financial sense.
But numerous changes, including the increasing complexity of both heavy- and medium-duty trucks and tractors; stricter government regulations; and the need for financial flexibility have brought full-service leasing to the forefront.
Today, the profile of the leasing customer is evolving beyond manufacturers and distributors, says Bob Southern, president of Paccar Leasing Company (PacLease). "In the past, customers were typically small- to medium-sized private fleets," he says. "But today, all types of fleets are discovering the benefits of full-service leasing.
"More and more companies are considering leasing as a way to allow them to focus on their core competencies, not focusing on trucks and maintenance," says Southern. "Operating a fleet of leased trucks helps companies get their product to market in a timely, reliable and cost-effective way, while leaving the maintenance of the vehicles to trusted experts."
More Complex Trucks to Maintain
The trend to full-service leasing is expected to accelerate even faster in the next few years as the complexity of trucks continues to evolve. With hybrid diesel-electric trucks now more widely available and new models with 2010 engines about to enter the market, new technology is going to make maintenance and technician training an even higher priority. "With those influencers, more and more fleets will enter into a full-service leasing agreement," predicts Southern. "If you're running fewer than 50 trucks, it's going to be increasingly difficult to justify your own shop.
"Bottom line, with new technology in trucks, full-service leasing allows you to off-load maintenance to a trusted partner. It's the leasing company's job to make sure equipment is well maintained and running properly," Southern says. "You insulate yourself from unpredictable or erratic maintenance costs. That burden is shouldered by the leasing company."
Preservation of Capital
Given the turbulence in the capital markets and a shifting economy many firms have determined that they must preserve capital to fund other parts of their business that offer a better return, as opposed to sinking capital into rolling stock, he says. There are countless other companies taking a strong cash position so they can take advantage of acquisition and expansion opportunities in the market. "Bottom line, using a leasing company to fund trucks makes good financial sense when you are trying to preserve capital for other projects," Southern adds.
Avoiding Downtime
In the world of just-in-time deliveries, few fleets can afford to have a truck sitting on the side of the road for an extended period of time, particularly if it is loaded. Leasing helps eliminate this risk by increasing uptime. Many leasing contracts have a substitute vehicle feature that provides a replacement vehicle when it's needed.
"At PacLease, for example, if there is a down vehicle, we determine the nature of the problem and prescribe the best course of action to maximize uptime," says Southern. "Typically, the quickest solution is having the truck repaired at the roadside or taken to one of our more than 50,000 service points.
"When it comes down to it, leasing is not only about providing a truck -- it's about providing an efficient method for deliveries. Our customers are looking for a solution that assures an exceptional level of transportation service. PacLease focuses on preventive maintenance to avoid unplanned downtime and leases only the highest-quality, award-winning Kenworth and Peterbilt trucks."
Coping with Regulations
The work of technicians is more critical today than ever, but just as important is their understanding and training in dealing with government-mandated environmental regulations. And with every passing year, these regulations continue to grow in size, scope and complexity.
Today's truck fleet manager is faced with numerous compliance activities that can easily command several hours a day. "This is time that could be better used elsewhere," says Southern. "The outsourcing of maintenance, fuel tax reporting and other activities frees a manager's time for his or her primary business.
"And, don't forget the time involved in working with regulators," Southern says. "Are you sure that you're up to date on the criteria for each of the states in which you operate? Are you confident that the practices in your shop are in compliance with federal, state and local regulations? More and more companies are concluding that shifting these responsibilities to a third party may be a sound business decision for their company."
Avoiding 'Stranded Assets'
One last thing to consider: the crystal ball. Owning trucks is a bit like timing the stock market. Hit it right when it comes time to sell, and you'll reap high residual values. If your timing is wrong, the value of your equipment may be too low to make a much-needed move to new trucks.
"Leasing is an ideal way to remove the uncertainty of the used truck market from the equation," Southern says. "Plus, a leased truck has a greater chance of holding its value because of its maintenance record."
Given these changing times, you must evaluate all aspects of your business including transportation. A lease/ownership analysis helps determine the best fleet strategy for your specific needs. "From our perspective, there has never been a better time to lease vehicles," concludes Southern. "We take the risk out of operating a fleet of trucks and that's a comforting notion for our customers."
From a September 2009 PacLease White Paper.
More Fleet Management

Long-Awaited Canadian Border Bridge to Open in Detroit
For trucking, the bridge opening should offer immediate improvements in efficiency and reliability, with new customs facilities, expanded inspection capacity, and direct freeway-to-freeway connections.
Read More →
Aurora Rolls Out Next Generation of Driverless Trucks for Commercial Freight
Aurora's latest autonomous trucks it's rolling out with International feature lower-cost hardware designed for a million miles as the company expands commercial driverless freight operations across the U.S. Sun Belt.
Read More →
Freight Tonnage Down, Rates up, as Lower Capacity Powers Trucking Recovery
The recovery from the freight recession continues to be driven by reduction in capacity rather than by increased demand.
Read More →
Think Your Trucking Fleet Isn't Using Much AI? Think Again
Shadow AI — the use of unauthorized artificial intelligence tools at work — is becoming increasingly common, putting sensitive company data at risk. Learn how trucking fleets can protect sensitive data while embracing AI.
Read More →
ArcBest Consolidates Brands, Cuts Workforce
The company will bring three business units under the ArcBest brand, eliminate about 2% of positions, and expects the changes to generate $40 million in annual savings.
Read More →
Trucking Fleets Faced Record Operating Costs During Third Year of Freight Recession
ATRI's annual operational cost report shows carriers trimmed fleets, delayed equipment purchases, and ran older trucks as expenses continued to outpace freight rates.
Read More →
Michelin Adds AI Assistant to MyConnectedFleet Platform
Michelin’s new generative AI tool delivers instant fleet insights, helping managers analyze fuel use, tire maintenance, vehicle status, and operational performance without manually creating reports.
Read More →
LytxOne Platform Now Features AI, Compliance, and Asset Tracking Tools
New enhancements add AI-powered insights, asset tracking, compliance automation, and configurable privacy controls to Lytx's all-in-one fleet management platform.
Read More →
July Imports Poised to Set Container Record
The National Retail Federation projects July container imports will surpass the pandemic-era record as shippers frontload freight ahead of expected August tariff increases.
Read More →
HDT Announces 2026 Truck Fleet Innovator Finalists
From AI and fleet electrification to safety, operations, and leadership, these HDT Truck Fleet Innovator finalists are changing how trucking gets done.
Read More →

