Those can all work fine - until the numbers posted on a white board are accidentally erased, or yellow notes are mistakenly discarded. And a while a spreadsheet organizes things, it takes a lot of time to assemble reports from it.
It takes a big board or multiple sheets of paper or many columns in a spreadsheet to manage warranties. "Unit" warranties, which cover entire trucks, are fairly easy to track. It might not be too bad with extended unit warranties, with various coverages and time periods. Things start getting complicated in large fleets with multiple groups of tractors or trucks acquired over a number of years, but a good filing system and sharp people can keep a handle on it.
But it takes a really good filing system and very sharp people to note the installation date of a new battery, wheel seal or what-have-you on a road tractor that might or might not still be in its basic or extended warranty periods. And neither a filing or posting system will alert a clerk that a just-failed part is under warranty, and its maker should be billed for the amount of money represented by the warranty's unused time.
Add in the complexities of repairs and preventive maintenance visits by a fleet's power units and trailers, and it's easy to see why many fleet managers employ special computer-based programs to keep track of maintenance and recover warranty money from truck builders and component makers. That more don't is perplexing to Dave Reed, the guy who gave the above guesstimate. He's a fleet management consultant at Arsenault Associates, maker of the Dossier program, and he steered us to some customers who do.
One is Houston-based Silver Eagle Distributing, which operates 310 tractors and 357 trailers to transport Budweiser, Corona and Sam Adams beer and nearly 150 other beverages to 10,000 retail outlets in southeast Texas, says Ed Pritchard, senior vice president of fleet management. It also has 278 vans, 30 pickups and 61 cars driven by members of the sales and marketing departments. It has seven facilities for distribution, five with maintenance shops.
To manage those 1,245 pieces of equipment, the company started using Dossier in 1995 and added Pocket Dossier in 2006.
Pocket Dossier links wirelessly to software running on the company server. Technicians using handheld terminals have instant access to data on any vehicle. Handheld access has eliminated the need for technicians to walk to a desktop computer. Technicians check repair orders and access performance reports and vehicle histories from their work stations or when they go out to the yard to look at trucks. Silver Eagle has 28 handhelds that run Pocket Dossier, and each is assigned to a single technician.
Increased labor productivity has been obvious, mostly as a result of reduced paperwork for the technicians, according to Carrie Skinner, director of fleet administration, and maintenance assistant Dinorah Delgadillo. For example, templates reduce the time it takes for technicians to fill out repair orders and parts requisitions.
Dinorah has set up templates for Pocket Dossier so when they're reporting on routine jobs, they only need to press one button and all the information is right there at their fingertips.
Silver Eagle has templates for coverage of new trucks and repair parts. "Unit" warranties involve a complete truck, while coverage for each part is a "parts failure" warranty. Skinner and Delgadillo give them descriptive names, like "Ford bumper-to-bumper."
"Once you have set up the warranty templates and assigned them to vehicles, each time you enter a repair order the program will automatically check to see if that repair falls within a possible warranty term," Skinner explains. "If it does, it will notify you of such, and will automatically document it on a Warranty Claim Report."
The program automatically recognizes potential unit warranty claims based on the initial setup of unit warranty as compared to repairs orders charged against the unit. All repair reasons are included on the reports. You can check on the date range and warranty type.
The system saves time in the shop and in the office. "Before Pocket Dossier, mechanics would manually hand-write all the various aspects of maintenance and inspections they performed on a vehicle," Skinner recalls. "Dinorah and I would have to type it, and of course we would make errors because we didn't always understand some of the technical terms used by the technicians. Or we would have to get up from our desk, go into the shop and ask the technicians specifically, 'What did you mean here?'"
Not every manager feels technicians should work directly with a computer. Greg Walsh, director of maintenance at New World Van Lines in Chicago, has been using Dossier at least since 1988.
He still has managers and mechanics write out repair orders and reports, then forward them to his office for inputting to the Dossier system. "That way we know what's being done and where it's being done, and it adds to control," he explains.
Trying to get mechanics at New World's main shops in Chicago and Houston, plus 14 smaller facilities, to use the same terminology would be difficult, whether they put it on paper or into a laptop computer. But clerks at his Chicago office can interpret what mechanics have written out and input everything in a common format that includes key words. Then he and others can read the information and use it to run the fleet.
Warranty recovery is also done pretty much the old-fashioned way, by phone, email and paperwork, and sending in failed parts where it's required and makes sense. But Dossier advises headquarters when a part is still under warranty and credit is due.
Dossier isn't the only maintenance management program that can help fleets handle warranty recovery more efficiently. For instance, TMT Fleet Maintenance software from TMW Systems has a warranty management module that tracks the unit, system, or component under warranty by automatically creating the warranty master records. It also provides daily warranty reports, failed parts analysis, warranty claims preparation and claims analysis. You can do this for OEM, extended-warranty and aftermarket parts, with features that prepare warranty claims and credit warranty recoveries to units for accurate cost capture.
Collective Data is another example. Its Exception Reporting module can send automatic e-mailed reports for upcoming warranties that are about to expire. Or it can be set to continuously update an upcoming warranty expiration report that personnel can view through a network.
Some progressive fleets also handle warranty claims via electronic data interchange, or EDI. This saves time by eliminating paperwork and speeds delivery of information between fleets and suppliers. It also quickens payments or awarding of cash or credit to customers.
Without these types of programs, someone would have to comb files or maybe look on that big white board or pages of notes to see if anything is relevant. Chances are things are rushed and it just wouldn't get done. And warranty funds, whether in cash, credit or new parts, would remain unclaimed.
From the February 2011 issue of Heavy Duty Trucking magazine.