Heavy Duty Trucking Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

How a For-Hire Truckload Carrier Successfully Assesses Drivers

Paper Transport purposefully narrowed its driver applicant pool, but somehow that has led to reduced turnover and exponential growth. How did they do it?

April 3, 2023
How a For-Hire Truckload Carrier Successfully Assesses Drivers

Paper Transport has grown from 250 drivers to 950 drivers, with an annual growth rate of about 17%.

Photo: Paper Transport

3 min to read


In the freight cycle of 2018, the tremendous pressure on carriers to add drivers forced a for-hire truckload fleet based in Wisconsin to think critically about how it would find not just qualified applicants, but drivers who fit into the carrier’s culture.

Ad Loading...

“The driver market was extremely rough at that point in time,” says Ben Schill, CEO of Paper Transport. “We were kind of in … the rat race of hiring drivers, and then losing drivers early in tenure. It was all about recruiting.”

Since 2010, Schill says the company has been in growth mode. The carrier has grown from 250 drivers to 950, with an annual growth rate of about 17%. With that kind of rapid growth, the struggle to recruit and then on-board drivers was snowballing into a greater challenge.

Ad Loading...

“Orientation classes went from a couple of drivers a week to 15 drivers a week,” Schill says.

Fleet Snapshot

Who: Paper Transport

Where: De Pere, Wisconsin

Fleet: 980 Class 8 trucks, 3,800 trailers

Operations: For-hire truckload carrier offering regional, dedicated, intermodal and logistics services

Fun Fact: PTI's inexpereienced hires reported 23% lower "dirty" inspections per driver

Challenge: Driver turnover

Paper Transport was investing heavily in new hires, so it wanted to make sure they were investing in the drivers who would uphold the fleet's values of safety and stick around for the long haul. Paper Transport couldn’t find anything in their own fleet data that pointed to any change in particular the fleet could make to improve retention.

Paper Transport: Potential Drivers Must Take a Driver Assessment

The answer Paper Transport landed on was to implement a driver assessment to weed out applicants who don’t fit the mold.

Paper Transport requires all potential drivers (both fresh to the industry and experienced drivers) to take an assessment by JOBehaviors. The 100-question survey takes about 15 minutes and asks drivers to answer questions that give the fleet an idea of the kind of driver they are.

The result is a score between one and five stars. Drivers who score above three stars are in the top 50% of what the fleet considers the “right” driver for the company. The "right" driver for Paper Transport is an individual who has a desire to be a part of something bigger than themselves, has a focus on safety, maintains professionalism, and has the right attitude with customers and office staff.

Ad Loading...

“It's not saying that these other drivers are bad drivers,” Schill explains of those who score below three stars. “But what it is saying is these are the drivers that possess the behaviors and values that you want at Paper Transport, and that this is going to be your better shot in terms of who you should pursue.”

The assessment has nothing to do with driving skills. In fact, the process can weed out applicants who have years of experience. About 50% of all applicants don’t move forward in the process. This in turn has narrowed the application pool significantly. But Schill says it has only helped build a workforce of drivers who stick around.

There is also a 20% non-participation rate of applicants who simply don’t take the survey.

“At first that was looked at as a major hurdle, but my perspective was that if you’re serious about the company you want to work for, but you’re not going to take a 15-minute survey on the front end… Well, then you’re probably not the driver who will take a 15-minute pre-trip or post-trip inspection of the equipment, or take the extra time that’s needed to do your job professionally." So he was OK with losing a chance to hire those otherwise qualified drivers.

The "right" driver for Paper Transport is an individual who has the desire to be a part of something bigger than themselves and a focus on safety.

Photo: Paper Transport

The assessment continues to be at the front of the application process. It allows Paper Transport hiring staff to “cut through the noise” and focus on applicants who are not only qualified but also are a fit for the operations.

Ad Loading...

“It was really a leap of faith,” Schill says. “I think most people try to tiptoe into it. I didn’t feel like we would actually be able to see any benefits if we didn’t jump in full force and give it a try.”  

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Fleet Management

HDT Talks Trucking thumbnail saying: Replace Your TMS? Not so Fast, with headshots of host Deborah Lockridge and guest Bill Cain of TMW/Trimble
Fleet Management•November 13, 2026

How to Modernize Your TMS Without Replacing It [Podcast]

Before investing in a new transportation management system, take a closer look at what you've already got. AI, cloud technology and better integrations may offer ways to improve your trucking operations without starting over.

Read More →
Driver on tablet using ELD with digital data concept graphics
Fleet Management•November 11, 2026

Could Your Truck's Connected Devices Be a Cybersecurity Risk?

ELDs, telematics systems and driver tablets help fleets operate more efficiently. But every connected device needs protection against cyberattacks.

Read More →
Tractor-trailers on a highway with a TRAFFIX market data graphic showing spot truckload rates up 48% year over year, tender rejections at 12.9%, and freight volumes up 4.7% over two weeks.
Fleet Management•by Deborah Lockridge•November 10, 2026

Holiday Freight Meets a Tight Trucking Market

There's no freight boom, but truckload carriers are finding themselves in a stronger position to negotiate rates. And holiday shipping demand could tighten the market further.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Fleet Management•by Staff•November 10, 2026

What Trucking Events are Happening in 2027?

Looking for trucking-related conventions, expos, and other events? Heavy Duty Trucking has developed this list of national and larger regional trucking shows and events.

Read More →
Illustration of a dispatcher viewing load schedules and a route map, with connected icons representing dispatch, trailer tracking, maintenance, documents, and billing.
Fleet Management•by Deborah Lockridge•November 9, 2026

Does Your Trucking Fleet Need a New TMS?

Artificial intelligence and better integrations promise less busywork and more useful data. Can your TMS help your company solve problems? Do you need additional vendors or an upgrade? Or is it time to look for a new platform?

Read More →
Erik Neandross, President of Clean Transportation Solutions at TRC.
Fleet Management•by Staff•November 8, 2026

Fleet Costs Shape ACT Expo 2027 Agenda

With diesel prices high and operating expenses under pressure, ACT Expo's 2027 agenda emphasizes fuel efficiency, AI, safety and the return on fleet technology investments.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
HDT Talks Trucking YouTube thumbnail with host Deborah Lockridge and guest Bill Cain of TMW
Fleet Management•by Deborah Lockridge•November 5, 2026

Does Your Trucking Fleet Need a New TMS? [Video]

Cloud technology, AI and new integrations are changing what transportation management systems can do. But does taking advantage of those advances mean replacing your existing TMS?

Read More →
Saegic TrackRR Gateway solar-powered trailer telematics device shown alongside screenshots of the Saegic Cloud Platform displaying trailer location, tire monitoring, and equipment status.
Fleet Management•November 4, 2026

Road Ready Becomes Saegic, Launches New Trailer Telematics Gateway

Clarience Technologies is rolling out new hardware and expanding its plans for connecting trailer telematics, maintenance data, and video.

Read More →
HDT Cyber Stop graphic pairing a laptop displaying binary code with a person using a clipboard to inspect a truck chassis, against a background of padlock icons.
Fleet Management•November 2, 2026

Give Your Trucking Fleet a Cybersecurity Walkaround

Your fleet's cybersecurity policies may look good on paper. These seven checks can help you find out whether they’re working.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Western Star pulling double trailers in the Permian Basic for Atlas Energy Solutions
Fleet Management•by Deborah Lockridge•October 30, 2026

Kodiak Lines Up Fleets for Driverless Trucking

An agreement for 75 trucks, a new Texas freight lane, and progress on safety validation move Kodiak closer to its planned driverless highway launch.

Read More →