Heavy Duty Trucking Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Commentary: When Humans and Safety Technology Collide

Safety technology isn’t always everything it’s cracked up to be – because no matter how sophisticated it is, you still have to consider how it’s going to interact with the human behind the wheel.

Deborah Lockridge
Deborah LockridgeEditor and Associate Publisher
Read Deborah's Posts
April 9, 2019
Commentary: When Humans and Safety Technology Collide

While the results from crash investigations are still pending, two recent crashes of the Boeing 737 Max may serve as examples of what happens when humans and safety technologies are not on the same page. 

3 min to read


My 16-year-old totaled my car last month. No injuries, thank goodness, but that and a few recent headlines got me thinking about safety technology.

Ad Loading...

I had to wonder, would this crash have been avoided or at least mitigated by forward collision warning and/or automatic emergency braking? It was the result of a moment of inattention, spending just a little too long looking for an unfamiliar HVAC control. Perhaps instead of adhering to the conventional wisdom of teens driving an older car so the damage is less costly when they wreck it, I should be buying my kid a new car with the latest safety technology.

But safety technology isn’t always everything it’s cracked up to be – because no matter how sophisticated it is, you still have to consider how it’s going to interact with the human behind the wheel.

Ad Loading...

That factor was evident in some recent headlines. One was a Delray Beach, Florida, crash of a Tesla Model 3, which underrode the side of a tractor-trailer making a left turn onto a divided highway, tearing off the Tesla’s roof as it passed under the trailer, killing the driver. So far reports have not indicated whether the Autopilot or automatic emergency braking systems were working at the time, but the crash was eerily like one that happened in May 2016 near Gainesville, Florida, where a Tesla on Autopilot failed to “see” a white semitrailer turning in front of it and ran under the trailer, killing the driver.

Tesla’s Autopilot is not fully autonomous technology, as the name might make some people think. It’s an advanced driver assistance system, with instructions for drivers to keep their hands on the wheel, monitor their surroundings, and be ready to take over at a moment’s notice.

If you were going to have this type of technology in a fleet vehicle, you’d want to be darn sure you had training and policies in place to make sure drivers were using it correctly.

And speaking of training and safety technology, based on one newspaper investigation, it looks like that may have been at issue with the recent highly publicized fatal crashes of the Boeing 737 Max. The U.S. and other countries grounded the planes following two fatal crashes in just six months.

The Dallas Morning News found that pilots of the Boeing 737 Max 8 voiced safety concerns to federal authorities, with one captain calling the flight manual “inadequate and almost criminally insufficient,” months before the first crash last October.

Ad Loading...

The Maneuvering Characteristics Augmentation System was included on the Max 8 as a safety mechanism that would automatically correct for a plane entering a stall pattern, The Dallas Morning News explained. If the plane loses lift under its wings during takeoff and the nose begins to point far upward, the system kicks in and automatically pushes the nose down.

We don’t know yet what caused those crashes. But you can imagine that if a pilot wasn’t expecting that, if he or she didn’t have the right training on how the system would behave in that situation, their reaction could make the problem worse instead of better.

“The pilots seemed kind of taken aback by the system taking over,” The Dallas Morning News reporter Cary Aspinwall said on the NPR program All Things Considered. “They weren’t sure what it was doing. And I think that shocked the pilots.”

So, whether the Tesla Autopilot or the Boing Max 8’s latest automated safety tech, in both cases it looks like the operators needed more training on how a system is supposed to work.

Are your drivers fully up to speed on all the latest safety technology you’ve put in their trucks?

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Safety & Compliance

Mobile tablet showing Motus screen against highway background with Motus logo
Fleet Managementby StaffSeptember 15, 2026

FMCSA Pauses Biennial-Update Enforcement Amid Motus Transition

Carriers whose updates were due on or after June 1 have more time, while FMCSA works to stabilize its new registration system and warns of phishing sites impersonating its new carrier registration system, Motus.

Read More →
Presentation slide showing ZF's North American market growth
Equipmentby Deborah LockridgeSeptember 10, 2026

ZF Expands Commercial Vehicle Push in North America

ZF is expanding its North American commercial-vehicle presence with new transmission applications, electrification, trailer technology and autonomous-driving systems.

Read More →
Illustration with driver behind the wheel, an alert sign, and a laptop
Driversby Lauren FletcherSeptember 9, 2026

Truck Drivers Need More Than Another Alert

Fleets have more visibility into truck health, safety events, and driver activity than ever. The next challenge is turning all that information into useful guidance for the person who has to decide what to do next.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Tesla Semi electric truck with interior of Tesla Cybercab superimposed on top
Equipmentby Deborah LockridgeSeptember 8, 2026

Tesla Wants a Self-Driving Semi. Are Cameras Enough?

Could Tesla’s camera-only autonomous driving technology work on an 80,000-pound Semi? In this commentary, HDT's Deborah Lockridge takes a look at Tesla, Cybercab, and how autonomous trucks see the road.

Read More →
Collage of five autonomous trucks
Safety & Complianceby Deborah LockridgeSeptember 8, 2026

What DOT’s Automated Vehicle Strategy Means for Trucking

The U.S. Department of Transportation issued a new automated-vehicle strategy that outlines plans for driverless-truck regulations, cross-state freight corridors, and federal safety standards.

Read More →
Illustration of NYC skyline with speed limit sign and the major's order in the foreground
Safety & Complianceby News/Media ReleaseSeptember 4, 2026

NYC Expands Speed, Pedestrian Safety Tech Across Fleet

New York City is expanding intelligent speed assistance and pedestrian-alert systems across its municipal fleet, moving the technologies from pilot programs into vehicle procurement and retrofit requirements.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Two men in jackets with Homeland Security indicated on the back, standing in a parking lot looking toward a building with trucks in front of it
Driversby Deborah LockridgeSeptember 1, 2026

FMCSA Removes 110 Truck Driver Training Schools from Certified ELDT List

Federal regulators also are targeting more than 160 additional training providers and launching a nationwide audit of third-party CDL skills testers as part of a broader crackdown on trucking fraud.

Read More →
Digital cover feature illustration showing truck inspector looking at trailer in background with the words "Compliance doesn't equal safety"
Safety & Complianceby Deborah LockridgeSeptember 1, 2026

Beyond DOT Compliance: What Makes a Trucking Fleet Truly Safe?

A trucking fleet can follow every rule and still make unsafe decisions. The real test comes when safety conflicts with freight, productivity, or cost.

Read More →
Illustration of tired truck driver, electronic logging device, and traffic congestion

Hours of Service Pilot Programs: FMCSA Readies for 2027 Rollout

Two pilot programs could eventually reshape hours-of-service rules, giving truck drivers options to pause their 14-hour clock or use longer split sleeper rest periods.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Dog in a special pet restraint in the passenger seat of a truck cab, with a photo of pet guide superimposed

New Guide Offers Pet Safety Tips for Truck Drivers

Hundreds of thousands of pets travel in truck cabs. A new safety guide from Volvo Trucks and the Center for Pet Safety offers practical advice for truck drivers who bring dogs and cats along for the ride.

Read More →