If you want to test drive some new tires before you buy — and who wouldn’t — be prepared to invest significant time and energy in the project.
You need patience to produce a successful tire evaluation. Diligent record keeping and careful observation will help, but it can take two years or more to get an accurate picture of how tires will perform in a specific application.
It takes time and miles for tread rubber to scrub away and for any irregular wear problems to appear. All the while, the test tires will be at the mercy of the mechanical condition of the truck, road hazards, ambivalent or unknowing technicians, and the habits of the drivers piloting the test trucks. That’s a lot of variables from which to draw hard conclusions about tire performance.
Peggy Fisher, president of Tire Stamp Inc. and expert-at-large on the ATA’s Technology & Maintenance Council’s S.2 Tire and Wheel Task Force, orchestrated many such tire evaluations during her days as a fleet tire manager with Roadway Express back in the ’80s. She managed nearly 200,000 tires on 30,000 pieces of equipment — and tested many thousands of tires.
“Because tire testing for tread wear and durability can take years, the biggest issue in running these tests is keeping maintenance personnel aware that the test is still ongoing,” she says. “This becomes harder to do the larger the fleet and the more people touching the test tires.”
Fisher points to TMC recommended practice 230B as the ideal template for tire durability and tread wear evaluation. One of the TMC’s longer RP documents at 20 pages, it’s very comprehensive and includes tools for recording data and making evaluations.
Among the recommendations is to use the same make, model and year of truck to ensure consistency at the mechanical level, and of course, to align the truck and inspect the running gear to ensure the truck itself won’t compromise the test.
“That is why we specify in RP 230B that fleets use the same model trucks if possible for tire tests,” Fisher says. “Factors such as camber, caster and Ackermann [steering geometry] can be different, and that will affect tire wear.”
Randy McGregor, fleet manager at Transway Inc., a 100-truck general commodities carrier based in Holland, Michigan, and serving the Midwest, always has four types of tires in tests on eight power units. He tries to keep the trucks on similar routes with similar loads, and his tests generally run eight months to a year, or 80,000-90,000 miles.
“We begin the process by selecting a few tires to test,” he says. “We look to our tire suppliers for likely candidates for our needs. And we also try to find out if the tires in question will be available for at least a few more years. There’s no point in testing a tire that’s about to undergo a design change or be discontinued.”
McGregor says if he’s testing steer tires he’ll align the truck first, but for drive tires he just checks axle parallelism and the condition of the shocks and suspension bushings to minimize wear from mechanical issues. He monitors tread depth and tire condition every 10,000 miles or so, and will switch the tires to different trucks with different drivers at about 50,000 miles.
“We have a pretty good idea how tires will perform by 50,000 miles, but wear rates can change as the tread thins out,” he notes. “Past test results have shown that conclusions we can draw at 50,000 miles usually hold for the remainder of the tread life, but we don’t stop there. A lot can still happen after that.”
He also draws on his drivers’ opinions about the tires in terms of ride and handling, traction, etc. “They are the ones who have to live with them.”
There will be tires that start to show wear more quickly than others, so McGregor tries to find out why. Sometimes it’s the truck and sometimes it’s the tire, he says. “We investigate the problem before assuming it’s the tires by comparing the wear on the test tires to the previous tires that came off the truck,” he explains. “If the previous tire and the test tire show the same wear, the truck is likely the source of wear. On the other hand, if two tires show the same wear rates and patterns at the same mileage, we usually assume it’s the tires and contact the dealer.”
The important thing is that McGregor says his tire test program does yield meaningful results and has proven reliable over the fullness of time. He’s not testing a thousand tires at a time, just a few dozen. He figures the results even on his small sample size are accurate enough to help him plan future tire purchases.