Related: How Fleets Can Address Nuclear Verdicts and High Insurance Costs
Record 'Nuclear Verdict' Thrown Out on Appeal
An appeals court has ordered a new trial in a 2018 “nuclear verdict” case that was believed to be the largest trucking verdict in the country’s history, saying the award was excessive.

A record-setting trucking verdict has been thrown out on appeal.
Photo: Brian Turner via Creative Commons
An appeals court has ordered a new trial in a 2018 “nuclear verdict” case that was believed to be the largest trucking verdict in the country’s history, saying the award was excessive.
In 2013, a tractor-trailer owned by oil-services fleet FTS international rear-ended a pickup truck on U.S. Highway 259 near Ore City, Texas. The pickup driver, Joshua Patterson, walked away from the accident, saying he was fine, but later had extensive chiropractic treatments and back surgery that he claimed were caused by the accident.
Patterson sued FTS for negligent hiring, because the truck driver was hired despite having three traffic violations within 36 months before he was hired, despite a company policy against it. It also turned out that the driver had not completed some training required by the company, despite signing paperwork indicating he had done so. Post-collision drug testing revealed that Acker had marijuana and methamphetamines in his system at the time of the accident.
In July 2018, the jury awarded $101 million – $75 million for punitive damages.
According to Law360, the stunning verdict was later cut to $31.6 million ($26.3 million in compensatory damages and $5.3 million in punitive damages), thanks to a Texas cap on such damages.
On Aug. 26, a three-judge Court of Appeals panel for the Twelfth District reversed that final judgment. The jury's $2.3 million in economic damages for medical expenses and lost earnings was supported by the evidence, the appeals panel said, but the $24 million award for noneconomic damages such as pain and suffering was based on “sparse and highly contested” evidence, according to the opinion, reports Law360.
The appeals court wrote that the award was "based upon the jury's disapproval of FTS rather than adequate and reasonable compensation for Patterson's actual injuries."
More Safety & Compliance

Truck Snow Removal: Fines Aren't the Only Risk
Delaware and Maryland are the latest states to add requirements and fines for snow and ice removal on commercial trucks. But a flying-ice accident could cost a fleet more than a citation.

How ATA Wants to Fix ELD Certification
ATA's new roadmap calls for independent ELD certification, better fraud detection and closer oversight of providers. Here's how the proposed system would work.

Daimler, Paccar Recall Trucks Over Driveline Defect
Nearly 4,900 Freightliner, Western Star, and Kenworth trucks are being recalled because a missing snap ring could allow the driveline to separate from the truck.

133 ELDs Revoked as ATA Pushes Certification Reform
FMCSA just removed a record number of electronic logging devices from its registry. ATA says it's time to rethink how ELDs get approved in the first place.

CVSA Sets 2027 International Roadcheck Dates
The annual 72-hour truck inspection blitz will take place May 11–13 across North America. Here's what fleets can expect and what inspectors found during the 2026 event.

FMCSA’s New Complaint Platform Makes It Easier to Report Trucking Safety Concerns
The FMCSA Complaint Center features expanded complaint categories and a name change away from the word "consumer."

FDA Eases Path for Oral-Fluid Testing
Federal actions could advance oral-fluid drug testing for truck drivers, but lab certification delays and marijuana rescheduling questions remain.

Kodiak Lines Up Fleets for Driverless Trucking
An agreement for 75 trucks, a new Texas freight lane, and progress on safety validation move Kodiak closer to its planned driverless highway launch.

More Trailer Data Through the Same Seven-Way [Video]
Can trucking’s standard seven-way connector handle more cameras and trailer data? Grote’s Adam Slade shows HDT how the company is using new technology with its 4See trailer system, not only to add a new backup camera but also to expand other capabilities — without adding another connection.

PrePass Intelligence Mines Fleet Bypass, Toll and Safety Data
PrePass Intelligence helps fleets measure bypass savings, flag potential toll overcharges, and spot suspicious transactions by combining data from separate systems.

