Judge Rules Against Maritime Commission in Port Dispute
A District Court judge has denied the Federal Maritime Commission's request for an injunction of certain elements of the Ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach's Clean Truck Program

Trucks entering the Port of Los Angeles.
A District Court judge has denied the Federal Maritime Commission's request for an injunction of certain elements of the Ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach's Clean Truck Program.
The commission argued that the Port of Los Angeles employee mandate to phase out independent contractors and both Ports' container fee exceptions and subsidy programs violated the Federal Shipping Act because they were likely to unreasonably reduce competition at the Ports and lead to unreasonable increases in transportation costs.
The judge found that although it was likely that those provisions would force some owner-operators and motor carriers out of the drayage market, the drayage market would remain competitive enough to meet the Shipping Act's standards. The judge said the Maritime Commission had not demonstrated that transportation costs would be unreasonably increased.
The FMC has the ability to take action against agreements in the ocean shipping industry that it believes are likely, by a reduction in competition, to unreasonably raise rates and decrease services.
The Ports "are implementing ambitious, multi-faceted programs to reduce high levels of air pollution while also striving to improve the Ports' safety and security and to enable future development," noted Judge Richard J. Leon. "Given the protracted and public deliberative process that led to the development of the CTPs and the responsibility the [Ports] have for improving the area's public health and managing the Ports' efficient operations, the Court finds that the public interest, at this point, favors denying the FMC's motion" for a preliminary injunction."
The American Trucking Associations emphasizes that the legal requirements associated with the Shipping Act are completely different from those at issue in the separate ATA challenge to the Ports' Concession Plans.
The ATA lawsuit involves the federal rates, routes, and services pre-emption provision, which prohibits states and political subdivisions from imposing any law that affects a motor carrier's operations in those areas.
As the Ninth Circuit found in the ATA case, it "can hardly be doubted" that the Ports' Concession Plans (one element of the Clean Trucks Program) have such a prohibited effect. The Ninth Circuit ruling rests upon the basis that the reshaping/re-regulation of the market is itself a violation of the rates, routes, and services preemption provision -- regardless of whether some level of competition remains in the re-regulated market.
ATA did not participate in the FMC court challenge and formally communicated to the agency its support of the Ports being allowed to collect and distribute the container fees to motor carriers in furtherance of the Ports' Clean Truck Program. ATA officials say that because of the differing legal standards applicable in the ATA and FMC cases, the FMC ruling has no relevance to the legal issues in the ATA challenge. (See "U.S. Court of Appeals Rules in Favor of ATA in Lawsuit Against Ports," 3/23/09.)
More Fleet Management

How to Modernize Your TMS Without Replacing It [Podcast]
Before investing in a new transportation management system, take a closer look at what you've already got. AI, cloud technology and better integrations may offer ways to improve your trucking operations without starting over.
Read More →
Could Your Truck's Connected Devices Be a Cybersecurity Risk?
ELDs, telematics systems and driver tablets help fleets operate more efficiently. But every connected device needs protection against cyberattacks.
Read More →
Holiday Freight Meets a Tight Trucking Market
There's no freight boom, but truckload carriers are finding themselves in a stronger position to negotiate rates. And holiday shipping demand could tighten the market further.
Read More →
What Trucking Events are Happening in 2027?
Looking for trucking-related conventions, expos, and other events? Heavy Duty Trucking has developed this list of national and larger regional trucking shows and events.
Read More →
Does Your Trucking Fleet Need a New TMS?
Artificial intelligence and better integrations promise less busywork and more useful data. Can your TMS help your company solve problems? Do you need additional vendors or an upgrade? Or is it time to look for a new platform?
Read More →
Fleet Costs Shape ACT Expo 2027 Agenda
With diesel prices high and operating expenses under pressure, ACT Expo's 2027 agenda emphasizes fuel efficiency, AI, safety and the return on fleet technology investments.
Read More →
Does Your Trucking Fleet Need a New TMS? [Video]
Cloud technology, AI and new integrations are changing what transportation management systems can do. But does taking advantage of those advances mean replacing your existing TMS?
Read More →
Road Ready Becomes Saegic, Launches New Trailer Telematics Gateway
Clarience Technologies is rolling out new hardware and expanding its plans for connecting trailer telematics, maintenance data, and video.
Read More →
Give Your Trucking Fleet a Cybersecurity Walkaround
Your fleet's cybersecurity policies may look good on paper. These seven checks can help you find out whether they’re working.
Read More →
Kodiak Lines Up Fleets for Driverless Trucking
An agreement for 75 trucks, a new Texas freight lane, and progress on safety validation move Kodiak closer to its planned driverless highway launch.
Read More →
