Heavy Duty Trucking Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

3 Former Pilot Flying J Execs Sentenced in Fuel Rebate Fraud

A ‘hypercompetitive’ culture at Pilot Flying J contributed to a fuel-tax-fraud scheme, said one of three more former executives who have been sentenced to jail for their part.

November 8, 2018
3 Former Pilot Flying J Execs Sentenced in Fuel Rebate Fraud

Fleets targeted in the scam expected larger diesel fuel rebates from Pilot Flying J than they actually received.

HDT file photo

2 min to read


Three more former Pilot Flying J executives will spend time behind bars over their roles in in a fraud scheme that cheated trucking companies out of millions of dollars of promised fuel rebates.

"Our culture at the very top was to be hyper-competitive," former executive John "Stick" Freeman told the federal judge, according to a report on Knoxnews.com, admitting that he let it go too far.

Ad Loading...

Freeman and Brian Mosher were sentenced to two-and-a-half years in prison, while Vicki Borden received a two-year sentence. Freeman and Mosher must each pay a $100,000 fine, and Borden a $75,000 fine. The judge said he was lenient because the three pleaded guilty early in the case and handed over evidence to prosecutors.

Former Pilot president Mark Hazelwood will spend 12-and-a-half years in prison for overseeing the scheme. A federal jury convicted Hazelwood in February of wire fraud, witness tampering and conspiracy to commit wire fraud.

Mosher, a former regional sales director, testified at Hazelwood’s trial, and got the lightest sentence in exchange.

Ad Loading...

As Knoxnews reports:

Freeman, Pilot's former vice president of sales, began defrauding trucking companies as early as 2007. He bragged shamelessly about the fraud to bosses, employees and trainees, court records show - including at meetings recorded by an undercover FBI informant.

The fraud case dates back to 2012, when the FBI discovered that Pilot Flying J sales employees were operating a fuel-rebate scam that victimized trucking companies. The trucking companies were promised certain amounts back in rebates, but sales staff would reduce the amount at a later date to increase profits. Because of the complexities of the fuel buying market, most did not realize they were being shorted the promised rebates.

The FBI found that over the course of several years, Pilot Flying J defrauded as many as 5,500 customers of more than $56 million in owed rebates that were not paid.

Nineteen executives and staffers of the truck stop giant have either admitted or been convicted by a jury of participating in the fraud scheme. Fourteen pleaded guilty, three were convicted, and two were granted immunity.

Ad Loading...

Pilot Flying J’s board of directors has admitted criminal responsibility and paid a settlement for the fraud. Pilot CEO Jimmy Haslam has denied knowledge of the scheme and has never been charged.

More Fuel Smarts

NACFE Run on Less 2026 findings.
Fuel Smartsby Jack RobertsMay 1, 2026

NACFE: Fleets Need to Recalibrate TCO Strategies as Electric Trucks Gain a Long-Term Edge

NACFE’s Run on Less data has found that recent setbacks aside, electric truck powertrains are trending toward market leadership by 2025.

Read More →
Gray Volvo tractor pulling trailer on open highway
Fuel Smartsby Deborah LockridgeMay 1, 2026

New High-Horsepower Natural Gas Engine Could Expand Fleet Options

Westport and Volvo are demonstrating a 500-hp truck with diesel-like efficiency — one that also offers what Westport says is a better pathway to using hydrogen fuel in trucks.

Read More →
Illustration with oil wells silhouetted against red and gold sky
Fuel Smartsby Deborah LockridgeMay 1, 2026

Why Fuel Diversification Matters for Trucking Fleets

Relying on diesel alone exposes fleets to fuel price volatility. Here’s why diversification with electric, natural gas, and renewable fuels can reduce risk.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Range Energy eTrailer.
Fuel Smartsby News/Media ReleaseApril 17, 2026

Range Energy Confirms eTrailer Performance in Winter Testing as Commercial Rollout Nears

Range Energy said its production-ready eTrailer system proved it can boost stability, safety, and efficiency in sub-zero winter conditions as the company moves toward scaled deployment.

Read More →
Circles with trucks demonstrating sustainable features and Top Green Fleets logo
Fuel Smartsby Deborah LockridgeApril 16, 2026

Top Green Fleets of 2026: Nomination Deadline Extended

Is your company a leader in sustainability efforts among trucking fleets? If so, Heavy Duty Trucking's editors want to hear from you.

Read More →
Youtube thumbnail featuring man in Big-Lebowski-inspired sweater
Fuel Smartsby Deborah LockridgeApril 13, 2026

New Lightweight Wheel Cover Targets Simpler Aero Gains [Watch]

Watch to learn how Deflecktor's new wheel cover design is taking a simpler approach to aerodynamics, with an eye toward making it more practical for both trucks and trailers.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Dual truck tires with black aerodynamic wheel cover and a man bending down getting ready to take one off
Fuel Smartsby Deborah LockridgeApril 10, 2026

Deflecktor: Hubbub Aerodynamic Wheel Cover Cost-Effective Even for Trailers

Aerodynamic wheel covers can deliver small but meaningful fuel-economy gains for fleets, and Deflecktor says its latest design aims to make the technology easier and more affordable to deploy.

Read More →
Podcast thumbnail saying "How to Save on Fuel Costs" with diesel pump in the background and photo of the woman guest
Fuel SmartsApril 9, 2026

Cutting Fleet Fuel Costs in a Volatile Market [Listen]

When diesel prices are as volatile as they've been in 2026, it makes it tough for trucking fleets to plan and control costs. Breakthrough Fuel's Jenny Vander Zanden has insights on near-term savings strategies.

Read More →
YouTube thumbnail saying "How to Save on Fuel Costs" with woman's photo and a photo of a diesel price pump
Fuel Smartsby Deborah LockridgeApril 9, 2026

Diesel Price Swings Aren’t Over. What Can Your Fleet Do?

Practical steps fleets can take to manage fuel costs, from purchasing strategies to driver behavior.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Illustration with oil wells, dollar bills, and a diesel fuel pump
Fuel Smartsby Deborah LockridgeApril 7, 2026

Diesel Prices Surge Toward Record Highs as Oil Price Volatility Intensifies

Prices jumped another 24 cents in a week, with California topping $7.50 and new data showing fleet fuel costs may already be at record levels.

Read More →