Heavy Duty Trucking Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Three Things to Consider When Comparing Insurers

When shopping for commercial auto insurance, it’s important to consider a number of factors, not just cost.

by Bill Caudill
December 9, 2014
Three Things to Consider When Comparing Insurers

 

3 min to read


When shopping for commercial auto insurance, it’s important to consider a number of factors, not just cost. Compare offerings and find out which insurer will best fit your business needs. Here a few things to keep in mind that will help you make the most informed decision.

Ad Loading...

Claims

Find out if they have specialized claims reps. If you do have an accident, it’s important to find a company that has dedicated commercial auto claims representatives, not general reps who work for a third-party. Specialized claims reps will help get you back on the road quicker. Ask if they have dedicated repair shops. Similar to specialized claims representatives, finding an insurer with a network of shops is important. In addition to speeding up the repair of your vehicles, many of these shops will offer guarantees on their work for long periods of time. That offers you peace of mind when you pick your truck up and put it back in commission.

Ad Loading...

Service and Coverage

Make sure their coverages fit your needs. Every business is different, which means business owners have different coverage needs. Ask about the things you and your business need to be covered, and be specific. For example, if your truck is paramount to getting supplies to your customers, check if your insurer offers rental vehicle coverage. It provides you with a temporary vehicle if yours is out of service.

Look for experience in your trade. Ask around and do your research to see if the insurer has a history of handling trucking claims. A proven track record with your trade is a good indicator of how well an insurer will handle your claim if you ever need to file one. If you can’t find the information you’re looking for, don’t be afraid to ask about their experience.

Ask if they’re available 24/7. Chances are you don’t work a typical 9-5 schedule, so look for an insurer that can work around your timeline. You never know when you’ll need your insurance company to be there for you. Find a company that works around your schedule, not vice-versa. And 24/7 doesn’t just apply to call centers and claims representatives – check if your insurer has coverages like Rental Reimbursement with Downtime, which will compensate you for lost time and help find you a replacement vehicle while your rig is being fixed.

Pricing

Ad Loading...

Value doesn’t always mean price. Make side-by-side comparisons and see who’s giving you the most for your money. Consider other factors like bundling packages, customer service and special offers. Then, once you’re comfortable with what your insurer is covering, ask about discounts.Look at the discounts. After you’ve taken the time to compare the value of what you’re getting, check what discounts you’re eligible to receive. There are many kinds of discounts, including discounts for having at least three years of business experience, paying your policy in full and having a valid commercial driver’s license. You might even be able to get a discount for something as simple as showing proof of prior insurance coverage. Ask your insurer or independent agent plenty of questions to ensure you’re getting the most for your money.  

Bill Caudill is a commercial auto product manager at Progressive.

This article was authored under the guidance and editorial standards of HDT's editors to provide useful information to our readers.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Fleet Management

Phillips Connect extends Nussbaum trailer life.

How Phillips Connect Helped Nussbaum Transportation Double its Trailer Life

Seven years into deploying Phillips Connect’s smart trailer platform, Nussbaum Transportation has extended trailer life from 10 to 15 years.

Read More →
Lance Evans, Director of Safety at K&B Transportation.

Inside Modern Fleet Safety: AI, Cameras & Speed Control at K&B Transportation

How a former commercial vehicle enforcement officer turned director of safety at K&B Transportation is embracing real-world safety technology.

Read More →
TEN disaster prep.
Fleet ManagementMay 1, 2026

How Fleets Can Avoid Equipment Blind Spots in Disaster Response

When the unexpected happens, how you react to, and deal with operational blind spots is critical. Here’s how to keep you recovery on track, when nothing is normal.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Illustration of cybersecurity images with "The Cyber Stop" text
Fleet Managementby Ben WilkensApril 30, 2026

AI Security Risks for Trucking Fleets: What to Know About Deepfakes and Agentic AI

As fleets adopt artificial intelligence for routing, maintenance, and load matching, new security risks are emerging. Learn where the vulnerabilities are and how to put the right controls in place.

Read More →
Mobile tablet showing Motus screen against highway background with Motus logo

FMCSA’s Motus System Is Coming. What Fleets Need to Know Now

The long-awaited registration system promises a single portal — and tighter fraud controls.

Read More →
CargoNet 2026 Qi report.
Fleet Managementby News/Media ReleaseApril 24, 2026

Cargo Theft Incidents Fall in Q1, but Organized Crime and Impersonation Drive New Risks

CargoNet reports fewer supply chain crime events to start 2026. But losses hold steady as organized crime shifts tactics toward impersonation schemes and high-value goods.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Graphic with light bulbs, HDT Truck Fleet Innovators logo, and the word Nominations
Fleet ManagementApril 24, 2026

Nominations Open for HDT Truck Fleet Innovators 2026

Heavy Duty Trucking is searching for forward-looking leaders at trucking fleets as nominations for HDT’s Truck Fleet Innovators 2026. Deadline is May 15.

Read More →
Illustration with trojan horse and lock with inside of cargo container in background
Fleet Managementby News/Media ReleaseApril 23, 2026

New Trojan Driver Cargo Theft Scam Bypasses Carrier Vetting Systems

Cargo theft rings plant operatives as drivers inside legitimate, fully vetted carriers, then execute coordinated thefts that look like a traditional straight theft from the outside.

Read More →
ATA Truck Tonnage Index March 2026.
Fleet Managementby News/Media ReleaseApril 22, 2026

March Truck Tonnage Posts Strongest Annual Gain Since 2022

A modest sequential increase capped the strongest quarterly performance in years, signaling continued freight momentum in early 2026.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Toll road.
Fleet Managementby Jack RobertsApril 22, 2026

Ohio Turnpike Targets $5.2 Million in Unpaid Tolls from Trucking Firms

More than 300 carriers across 26 states have been sent to collections as the Ohio Turnpike cracks down on toll evasion and delinquent payments.

Read More →