The SCR Inducement Battle Wages On
"Inducement" is a word that is getting much play in the Selective Catalytic Reduction debate right now.
"Inducement" is a word that is getting much play in the Selective Catalytic Reduction debate right now.
What are inducements?
Let's step back and consider the SCR process. The diesel engine produces various combustion byproducts that include the nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulate matter (PM) that have been the focus of EPA emissions regulation over the last 20 years. In the last go-around for 2010, most truck engine manufacturers decided that the final step in the reduction of NOx could best be achieved using SCR technology that chemically washes out the NOx in the exhaust stream after it has left the engine.
Injecting ammonia (NH3) into the hot exhaust reduces the NOx over a catalyst (hence "catalytic reduction" in the name). The result is the nasty NOx is reduced to nitrogen, which constitutes 80 percent of the air we breathe, and water, another very common constituent of our atmosphere. And a jolly good thing, too.
So the process is elegant. And it works. The technology has been used for decades in stationary power generation, and has been applied to heavy diesels over in Europe for more than three years to allow manufacturers there to reach compliance with the Euro V regulations.
But SCR is an aftertreatment process. The engine doesn't care whether it is functioning or not. And less than scrupulous truck operators could care less also, since the ammonia-containing fluid -- Ad Blue in Europe and Diesel Exhaust Fluid here in North America -- costs money.
In the European experience it was found that trucks were running with water in their DEF tanks as there was no anti-cheating strategy - or inducement -- to keep the DEF tank filled. Running without fluid defeated the NOx removal and meant engines were running at orders of magnitude above the NOx limits.
EPA was well aware of this shortcoming and as part of the guidelines to allowing SCR technology to meet EPA2010, the agency required SCR proponents to have strategies to induce operators to keep DEF on board and the aftertreatment systems functional.
As it has shaken out with the cooperation between the SCR proponents and the agency, there are inducements to the driver to fill the DEF tank when its level drops to around the 10 percent level. Then a light comes on or a message on the driver information display lets the driver know that DEF needs attention. At the 5 percent level, warning chimes and lights add to the general clamor and by this time a driver should be pestered enough to add DEF.
If this still doesn't do it, a further inducement is introduced. Here again, different truck manufacturers have their individual ways to get drivers to respond. In some cases, a derate is applied to the engine. It may be an across the board 25 percent reduction in torque, it may be a gradually increasing derate over miles up to 25 percent. For others, notably Detroit Diesel, the strategy is to keep full torque but to limit the truck's road speed to 55 mph.
If even that fails to get the driver's attention, there's a "hard" inducement that effectively stops the truck. Everyone agrees this is 5 mph so that the truck has some mobility. But the trigger has been chosen so as not to endanger the general motoring public with a truck stranded on the highway.
This trigger is at fuel fill, so that a driver could limp in at a 75 percent of torque to a fueling point where there will be available DEF. If more diesel fuel than 5 percent of the tank capacity is added but still without DEF, the truck will start, but will be limited to 5 mph.
The theory is that even the most unscrupulous DEF-dodger would be discouraged by this inducement since it would mean stopping about every hundred miles or so to add fuel, something that just wouldn't happen in the real world.
EPA and the California Air Resources Board are currently reviewing these inducements to see if they are stringent enough. The SCR proponents say 'Yay.' Navistar, the only proponent of in-cylinder Advanced Exhaust-Gas Recirculation, which doesn't use DEF, says 'Nay.'
So we haven't heard the last of this yet.
More Equipment

Mack Makes Comparing Truck Configurations Easier
Mack's new MyGarage online tool lets customers explore different truck configurations on their own schedule, before visiting a dealer.
Read More →
Bendix Upgrades Trailer ABS With Smarter Diagnostics
The new iTABS X system replaces Bendix's TABS-6 Standard trailer ABS, adding faster diagnostics and connectivity that could help fleets identify brake-system problems before they lead to downtime.
Read More →
Paper Transport Puts RNG to Work for Shipper
Eight renewable natural gas trucks are hauling freight for Graphic Packaging, part of Paper Transport’s growing mix of alternative-fuel transportation options that also includes a Tesla Semi pilot.
Read More →
What Trucking Events are Happening in 2027?
Looking for trucking-related conventions, expos, and other events? Heavy Duty Trucking has developed this list of national and larger regional trucking shows and events.
Read More →
EPA 2027 Uncertainty Slows Truck Orders
Improving freight rates may have many trucking fleets ready to buy new trucks, but they're struggling to figure out what those trucks will cost — or even when they'll be available.
Read More →
Kodiak Lines Up Fleets for Driverless Trucking
An agreement for 75 trucks, a new Texas freight lane, and progress on safety validation move Kodiak closer to its planned driverless highway launch.
Read More →
How GP Transco Builds Fuel Savings a Fraction at a Time
Aerodynamic specs, solar panels, and driver incentives help GP Transco turn small efficiency gains into savings it can reinvest in its people.
Read More →
More Trailer Data Through the Same Seven-Way [Video]
Can trucking’s standard seven-way connector handle more cameras and trailer data? Grote’s Adam Slade shows HDT how the company is using new technology with its 4See trailer system, not only to add a new backup camera but also to expand other capabilities — without adding another connection.
Read More →
Grote: More Cameras, Same Seven-Way Connector
The next-generation 4See rear-view backup camera from Grote uses the standard seven-way connector and supports additional cameras and other trailer data.
Read More →
Trucks at ATA's 2026 MC&E in Charlotte, North Carolina [Photos]
From rigs decked out in patriotic America's 250 paint schemes to autonomous trucks and more, check out these photos from ATA's 2026 Management Conference & Exhibition.
Read More →
