Winter Brings More Roadside Failures, Study Finds
A new report from the TMC/FleetNet America Vertical Benchmarking Program showed roadside failures rose 22% in first quarter of 2019 compared with the fourth quarter of 2018.

A new report, from the TMC/FleetNet America Vertical Benchmarking Program, found that roadside failures are more likely to hit fleets in harsh winter months.
Photo: Jim Park
There’s never a good time for a truck to go down. But a new survey conducted by the Technology & Maintenance Council of the American Trucking Associations found that when a truck does go down, it's more likely to be in the winter months than in other seasons.
On June 26 during its Fleet Data Management & Cybersecurity Conference, TMC released the results of the council’s first-quarter benchmarking survey with FleetNet America, an ArcBest company, showing a significant increase in roadside failures during the winter.
The report, from the TMC/FleetNet America Vertical Benchmarking Program, showed roadside failures rose 22% in first quarter of 2019 when compared with the fourth quarter of 2018, matching the quarterly rise from the previous two years. The increase in roadside failures was most pronounced in select systems, including exhaust and lighting systems.
“Fleets that use this data to guide their maintenance practices are going to be in a better position to reduce roadside repairs when next winter comes around,” said Jim Buell, executive vice president of sales and marketing for FleetNet America. “Knowing which systems are most vulnerable to cold weather and snow can guide maintenance practices next October and November.”
In addition, roadside mechanical repair costs increased for a third straight quarter, the report found. The average cost of a mechanical roadside repair reached $344 in the first quarter of 2019, 3% higher than the average mechanical repair in the fourth quarter of 2018, and 15% higher than the average cost in the third quarter of 2018.
“Completing repairs on the side of the road is already more expensive than completing the same repair in a shop,” said TMC Executive Director Robert Braswell. “TMC is committed to helping our members control these and all maintenance costs. We believe that the vertical benchmarking program is a tool that fleets can use to reduce unscheduled roadside repairs.”
The Vertical Benchmarking Program, announced during TMC's 2018 annual meeting, is a benefit for TMC fleet members and a partnership with FleetNet America. In addition to the executive summary, which is available to TMC fleet members, carriers that participate by sharing their data are provided an analytic tool that allows them to drill into their data, comparing it to the industry average.
The program is a strategic collaboration between TMC/ATA and FleetNet America and is open to TMC fleet executive level members and FleetNet America customers. The analytics provided via the program will be cumulative and non-fleet specific. For information, visit http://benchmarkit.fleetnetamerica.com.
More Maintenance

New Agentic Predictive Maintenance Report Demonstrates How Degraded Aftertreatment Systems Waste Fuel
Questar analyzed a large mixed-class fleet and discovered it was wasting as much as $30 in fuel per vehicle, per day, because of mechanically degraded aftertreatment systems.
Read More →
Mack, Volvo Issue ‘Do Not Drive’ Recall on Possible Wheel-Offs
Owners will be sent advance notice not to operate their affected vehicles until the remedy is performed.
Read More →
Why Fleet Data Matters More Than Ever at Waste Connections [Watch]
Waste Connections' Chuck Palmer explains how telematics, predictive maintenance, safety analytics, and AI help keep vehicles on the road and drivers safe in this episode of HDT Talks Trucking.
Read More →
How to Prevent Summer Truck Cooling System Failures
Summer heat puts heavy-duty truck cooling systems under intense strain. Learn how preventive maintenance and accurate repair information can help reduce downtime.
Read More →
Deadline Extended for HDT Truck Fleet Innovators Nominations
Heavy Duty Trucking has extended the deadline for nominations for its Truck Fleet Innovators awards. The deadline has been extended to May 22.
Read More →
Why VMRS Is the Natural Link Between AI, Predictive Analytics, and Vehicle Repairs [Commentary]
Jon White was a leading figure in the development of VMRS. Now, after five decades of service, White says VMRS is becoming essential to the AI-driven future of truck maintenance.
Read More →
Mack Trucks Revamps PartsASIST Platform with Faster Performance, Improved Navigation
Mack Trucks has launched a redesigned version of its PartsASIST online ordering platform, adding faster search, real-time inventory visibility and enhanced order tracking.
Read More →
International Debuts ‘My International’ Connected Platform to Centralize Fleet Data, Service, and Dealer Communication
International’s New digital ecosystem unifies telematics, maintenance, and dealer interaction into a single interface, aiming to reduce downtime and deliver predictive fleet insights.
Read More →
Saving Fuel at the Wheel End
Wheel ends are often overlooked in the quest for better fuel economy. But Joshua Kucera, product manager, Stemco, warns that neglecting wheel ends can reduce fuel economy and increase maintenance headaches.
Read More →
Beyond Predictive: Questar Adds AI-Driven Repair Recommendations to Fleet Maintenance
Questar’s latest maintenance platform uses AI to flag potential failures, recommend repairs, and estimate the cost of waiting, helping fleets prioritize maintenance and save money and downtime.
Read More →

