Heavy Duty Trucking Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Commentary: The E-Commerce Road has its Ups and Downs

Peak e-commerce season is stretching the limits of the nation's freight and package handling capabilities. Commentary by Editor in Chief Deborah Lockridge.

Deborah Lockridge
Deborah LockridgeEditor and Associate Publisher
Read Deborah's Posts
January 12, 2018
Commentary: The E-Commerce Road has its Ups and Downs

Deborah Lockridge

3 min to read


Deborah Lockridge

My personal experience with e-commerce this year was frustrating — and it started even before Black Friday.

Ad Loading...

In mid-November, an order from a clothing store never arrived at our house; apparently it was delivered to the wrong address, somehow “refused” and sent back to the shipper.

In December, I got a postcard from UPS notifying me that they were holding an item someone had sent to my P.O. box. Luckily, I called rather than traipsing over to the UPS facility — they had returned it to the sender only two days after the date on the postcard because they didn’t have enough room.

Ad Loading...

Numerous gifts we ordered through Amazon Prime were late. One apparently was lost in limbo between UPS and the Post Office, so we re-ordered it — only to get a notice that it, too, was delayed.

So I wasn’t surprised to read, a week before Christmas, that UPS was experiencing shipping delays due to the surge in online shopping.

UPS drivers aren’t happy about the workload, with the Teamsters complaining that this is the third year in a row UPS has underestimated demand. I’ve seen postal drivers operating unsafely, obviously in a hurry to get those deliveries done.

In short, “the peak e-commerce season is stretching the limits of the nation’s freight and package handling capabilities,” as the transportation analysts at Stifel put it.

FedEx, on the other hand, reportedly is handling the surge better. In reporting an 11% gain in net profit for the quarter ending Nov. 30, Chairman and CEO Fred Smith said the company handled this year’s peak season because of its close work with shippers to project demand.

Ad Loading...

Nevertheless, as Bloomberg notes, “deliveries to homes are more costly and complicated than taking goods to business sites.” UPS and FedEx are looking for solutions, from charging more for customers to schedule packages to offering pickup via lockers at drugstores, grocery stores and other locations.

E-tail giant Amazon is looking for solutions, as well, and some believe it is setting itself up as a competitor to UPS and FedEx.

Stifel analysts spent a couple weeks on the road in early December talking to motor carriers. Amazon, they said, wasn’t making many friends with those carriers, mostly due to an unwillingness or inability to meet the consistent volume commitments and lane assignments coveted by asset-heavy truckload carriers.

Between that problem and the volume overload and delays seen by UPS and other parcel carriers, “Amazon may be inclined to rethink its transportation network, going forward,” the analysts said in a report to investors.

One alternative would be to bring more transportation operations in-house, and some analysts do expect the e-commerce giant to eventually become a full-fledged parcel carrier. Of course, the challenges of building out the type of infrastructure that UPS and FedEx have been building for decades is no small feat.

Ad Loading...

Another approach, Stifel said, would be to implement more of a core carrier program, “fully engaging with the nation’s largest carriers, in order to ensure capacity for its base load volume.”

So far, Amazon seems to be focusing on smaller companies, recruiting owner-operators and small fleets to pull its branded trailers, as well as local delivery providers with vans and delivery trucks. The Stifel analysts were less than enthusiastic about that approach. “We are not sure that the power-only deals Amazon has been executing with small carriers is a sustainable program, over the long term, given Amazon’s growth trajectory.”

My experience tells me there’s no simple answer to the challenges posed by skyrocketing e-commerce. It also makes me wonder if more people will turn back to brick-and-mortar shopping when they don’t get their Christmas presents on time. If not, there are those Amazon patent filings for things like a drone warehouse hub in the sky…

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Fleet Management

Illustration of a chalkboard with a hand drawing an arrow curving away from a partially erased straight arrow with the words "Embracing Change," the Heavy Duty Trucking Logo and the "cover feature" graphic.
Fleet Managementby Deborah LockridgeAugust 1, 2026

How Innovative Trucking Leaders Turn Change Into an Advantage

As the pace of change accelerates in trucking, the fleets that adapt best have more than the latest technology. They have cultures that embrace improvement.

Read More →
Illustration of past due invoices with red X on top with background of a truck at a loading dock
Fleet ManagementJuly 27, 2026

Freight Broker Bonds Just Got Harder to Get. Here's What That Means for Your Fleet.

When it gets harder for a freight broker to prove they are financially sound, the ones who cannot clear that bar get pushed out of the market. And those are exactly the brokers who used to leave motor carriers holding the bag.

Read More →
Photo of cable bridge crossing Detroit River
Fleet Managementby Deborah LockridgeJuly 23, 2026

Long-Awaited Canadian Border Bridge to Open in Detroit

For trucking, the bridge opening should offer immediate improvements in efficiency and reliability, with new customs facilities, expanded inspection capacity, and direct freeway-to-freeway connections.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Blue International heavy-duty truck with Aurora driverless truck software coming head-on on an interstate highway
Equipmentby Deborah LockridgeJuly 22, 2026

Aurora Rolls Out Next Generation of Driverless Trucks for Commercial Freight

Aurora's latest autonomous trucks it's rolling out with International feature lower-cost hardware designed for a million miles as the company expands commercial driverless freight operations across the U.S. Sun Belt.

Read More →
American Trucking Associations for-hire tonnage graph
Fleet Managementby Deborah LockridgeJuly 21, 2026

Freight Tonnage Down, Rates up, as Lower Capacity Powers Trucking Recovery

The recovery from the freight recession continues to be driven by reduction in capacity rather than by increased demand.

Read More →
Cyberstop column header depicting images of ChatGPT prompt on a smartphone and shadowy hooded figure
Fleet Managementby Ben WilkensJuly 17, 2026

Think Your Trucking Fleet Isn't Using Much AI? Think Again

Shadow AI — the use of unauthorized artificial intelligence tools at work — is becoming increasingly common, putting sensitive company data at risk. Learn how trucking fleets can protect sensitive data while embracing AI.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Photo of semi trucks with Panther, ArcBest, and ABF trailers backed up to docks, with ArcBest logo superimposed on top
Fleet Managementby Deborah LockridgeJuly 17, 2026

ArcBest Consolidates Brands, Cuts Workforce

The company will bring three business units under the ArcBest brand, eliminate about 2% of positions, and expects the changes to generate $40 million in annual savings.

Read More →
Cover of ATRI operational costs study with graph clip art and photo of trucks on highway in the background
Fleet Managementby Deborah LockridgeJuly 15, 2026

Trucking Fleets Faced Record Operating Costs During Third Year of Freight Recession

ATRI's annual operational cost report shows carriers trimmed fleets, delayed equipment purchases, and ran older trucks as expenses continued to outpace freight rates.

Read More →
Micheline AI Assistant.

Michelin Adds AI Assistant to MyConnectedFleet Platform

Michelin’s new generative AI tool delivers instant fleet insights, helping managers analyze fuel use, tire maintenance, vehicle status, and operational performance without manually creating reports.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
LytxOne Platform.

LytxOne Platform Now Features AI, Compliance, and Asset Tracking Tools

New enhancements add AI-powered insights, asset tracking, compliance automation, and configurable privacy controls to Lytx's all-in-one fleet management platform.

Read More →