Heavy Duty Trucking Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

The Top 10 KPIs Every Fleet Manager Should Track

ELDs will increase the amount of useful data that fleets can use to improve safety, efficiency and compliance. While KPIs will differ by fleet size and vertical, here are the most common – the ones every fleet should be tracking.

by Pete Allen, Mix Telematics
December 20, 2017
The Top 10 KPIs Every Fleet Manager Should Track

Driver safety scorecards help drivers understand where they rank in terms of safety. Fleet managers can reward the best drivers with incentives.  

Source: MiX Telematics

5 min to read


Source: MiX Telematics

One big benefit of the move to electronic logging devices (ELDs) is the ease with which fleet managers can now collect data to help improve operations. The data can be overwhelming, however, and we’re fielding a lot of questions from fleet managers on what’s most important, and how to leverage the data they are now collecting.

We think about data across three broad categories: safety, efficiency and compliance. In an ELD world, the data typically comes from an on-board computer on each vehicle that tracks metrics such as speed, idling, fuel usage, driver behavior, GPS location and more. The data flows to fleet management software installed on the OBC and is then delivered to fleet managers via wifi, cellular network or satellite, in some cases in real time.

Ad Loading...

While KPIs will differ by fleet size and vertical, here are the most common – the ones we believe every fleet should be tracking.

Safety KPIs

Driver behavior is the biggest category within safety – fleets that monitor driver behavior and use the data they collect for driver coaching are best poised to improve their overall safety profile.

The top KPIs for safety are all related to driver behavior, and include:

  • Speeding incidents

  • Harsh acceleration and braking incidents

  • Corner handling incidents

  • Crashes

Ideally, this data should be conveyed to fleet managers in real time – especially crashes.

Ad Loading...

In addition to collecting this data, fleet managers should also publish weekly driver scorecards – exception-based reports that include data on the frequency of these events, per driver.

Driver safety scorecards help drivers understand where they rank in terms of safety. Fleet managers can reward the best drivers with incentives. Source: MiX Telematics

These scorecards should be posted in driver break rooms and other common areas to create completion among drivers (often fleets will give their best drivers rewards such as cash gifts or extra paid time off). Some fleets are creating safety competitions, leveraging gamification app features in their fleet management solutions.

Of course, more detailed scorecards should also be shared with individual drivers, for educational and coaching purposes. Some fleets call these RAG (Red, Amber, Green) reports, for the colors used to indicate each driver’s risk profile. Whatever you call them, they are essential element for driver coaching and improving driver behavior.

Fleets that have added in-cab video to their ELD solution can configure their systems to automatically append video to the record of each triggered event – so fleet managers and drivers can see what was happening inside and outside the cab when an event (such as a crash) occurred.

Efficiency KPIs

When it comes to efficiency, we recommend that fleets track:

Ad Loading...
  • Fuel economy per vehicle, including idling time

  • Empty miles

  • Fleet asset utilization

Most fleets we work with review reports on fuel economy and maintenance weekly, and empty miles and fleet asset utilization either monthly or quarterly.

Fuel economy and maintenance data can help managers identify gas-guzzling behaviors such as speeding and excessive idling, so that drivers can be trained to avoid them. Reducing those behaviors in turn reduces wear and tear on vehicles, decreasing maintenance requirements. Most importantly, all of this leads to safer driving and fewer crashes.

Obtaining a clear view of empty miles and how assets are used on a day-to-day basis can help fleets optimize asset utilization and, in some cases, allow companies to reduce the number of vehicles in their fleet – further reducing costs such as fuel, maintenance and insurance.

Compliance KPIs

For compliance, we believe fleets need to track:

Ad Loading...
  • Available Hours of Service (HOS)

  • HOS violations

  • Unassigned mileage by vehicle

Hours of service is most important, and is the main objective of the ELD mandate. Dispatchers should be looking at HOS at least daily. Best practice is to look at this data live, in real time as they dispatch, since HOS can change during a day.

We recommend a weekly review of violations – virtually all fleets will have them, not due to failures in their processes, but often because drivers simply don’t obey the rules. For example: if a driver is going to run out of hours in 30 minutes, but he’s 45 minutes from home, he’s going to keep going.  Fleets don’t have to report these violations – but they do need to track them, in case there is a DOT audit.

Unassigned mileage by vehicle is another key provision of the ELD Mandate. The FMCSA wants ALL driving time captured. If your fleet has exceptions, you need to be aware of them (and ideally get that mileage assigned to a driver before your next audit).

Most importantly, be sure to use the data your ELDs collect

Ad Loading...

In certain sectors, there are other important KPIs. For instance, in food delivery, fleets should track on-time arrivals and monitor reefer temperature. But generally, everything you want to track will fall under safety, efficiency or compliance.

The ability to set up alerts within your chosen ELD platform will assist greatly – especially alerts for safety issues and impending HOS violations. Having insight into those events will help ensure fleets can reduce or prevent them.

Reporting is also crucial. All of these top KPIs can probably be automatically collected by your ELD solution. Pre-configured reports can make the reporting process simple and automated. Some systems offer the ability to craft your own custom report templates – especially useful for larger fleets or power users of analytics.

The ELD era will bring about a data deluge, which has a ton of potential to help fleets improve safety and operations. But if fleets don’t harness and use the data, it’s just noise.

Pete Allen is the chief client officer for Mix Telematics, a global provider of fleet and mobile asset management solutions.This article was authored and edited according to the standards of HDT’s editors to provide useful information to our readers.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Fleet Management

American Class 8 tractor-trailers.
Fleet Managementby News/Media ReleaseFebruary 24, 2026

ATRI Seeks Carrier Data for 2026 Operational Costs Report

The annual benchmarking study from ATRI adds year-over-year comparisons for repeat participants as fleets navigate shifting market conditions.

Read More →
Fleetworthy fleet management.
Fleet Managementby News/Media ReleaseFebruary 23, 2026

Fleetworthy Unifies Brands Under Single Banner to Streamline Fleet Readiness

Company consolidates Bestpass, Drivewyze and CPSuite into one platform aimed at reducing vendor complexity and controlling fleet costs

Read More →
Podcast thumbnail saying "Cargo Theft: Is Your Load Next?"
Fleet ManagementFebruary 23, 2026

Double Brokering, Phishing, and the Rise of Strategic Cargo Theft

Cargo theft has evolved from parking-lot break-ins to cyber-enabled strategic fraud. Here’s what fleets need to know.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
YouTube thumbnail with Scott Cornell, HDT Talks Trucking Logo, and the words, "Is Your Load Next?"
Safety & Complianceby Deborah LockridgeFebruary 20, 2026

The New Cargo Theft Playbook — And How Fleets Can Fight Back

Cargo theft has shifted from parking-lot break-ins to organized international schemes using double brokering, phishing, and even spoofing tracking signals. In this HDT Talks Trucking video podcast episode, cargo-theft investigator Scott Cornell explains what’s changed and what fleets need to do now.

Read More →
Daimler Truck North America Vice President David Carson
Fleet Managementby Jack RobertsFebruary 19, 2026

Capacity Overhang Begins to Clear, But Fleets Aren’t Ready to Spend 

Daimler Truck’s David Carson sees early signs of tightening capacity — yet buyers remain wary, extending trade cycles and resisting a pre-2027 emissions surge. 

Read More →
Map showing which states have bad freight bottlenecks
Fleet Managementby News/Media ReleaseFebruary 17, 2026

Chicago Interchange Overtakes Longstanding New Jersey Intersection as Worst Freight Bottleneck

The American Transportation Research Institute's annual analysis of truck speeds through congested interchanges yielded a new worst bottleneck this year.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
HDT Top 20 Products Award Logo
Fleet Managementby Deborah LockridgeFebruary 13, 2026

HDT Top 20 Products 2026: The New Tools, Technologies, and Ideas Shaping Trucking

From pricing intelligence and compliance tools to charging infrastructure, diagnostics, tires, and AI, HDT’s 2026 Top 20 Products recognize the new tools, technologies, and ideas heavy-duty trucking fleets are using to run their businesses.

Read More →
Geotab's Neil Cawse on stage during keynote at Geotab Connect 2026
Fleet Managementby Deborah LockridgeFebruary 12, 2026

Adapt or Die: Geotab’s Neil Cawse on AI’s Rapid Reinvention of Fleet Management

Artificial intelligence is evolving faster than fleets can keep up, and telematics must evolve with it, Cawse said during Geotab Connect. The future? A single AI coordinating every system — and leaders who know how to guide it.

Read More →
Illustration with question mark and graph illustrating uncertainty
Fleet Managementby StaffFebruary 12, 2026

After Three Years of Pressure, Motor Carriers and Brokers See Early Signs of a Turn

Survey data show carriers and brokers expect improving demand in 2026, even as rates lag and capital investment remains on hold.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Photo of GO Focus Pro dashcam
Fleet Managementby News/Media ReleaseFebruary 11, 2026

Geotab Launches AI-Powered GO Focus Pro Dash Cam With 360-Degree Visibility

Geotab launches GO Focus Pro, an AI-powered 360-degree dash cam designed to reduce collisions, prevent fraud, and protect fleets from nuclear verdict risk.

Read More →