Heavy Duty Trucking Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Study Explores Maintenance and Equipment Buying at Fleets

When it comes to maintenance practices and equipment replacement cycles, there are some fairly significant differences between large fleets and small fleets, according to a recent study undertaken by FTR and CK Commercial Vehicle Research.

Deborah Lockridge
Deborah LockridgeEditor and Associate Publisher
Read Deborah's Posts
November 11, 2016
Study Explores Maintenance and Equipment Buying at Fleets

 

4 min to read


When it comes to maintenance practices and equipment replacement cycles, there are some fairly significant differences between large fleets and small fleets, according to a recent study undertaken by FTR and CK Commercial Vehicle Research.

Ad Loading...

The study took survey information gathered from fleets canvassed by CKCVR, and overlaid it with FTR data and analysis. That combination makes this report unique, according to the authors.

“Most of the information you see in this area doesn’t get down to the fleet level, to asking the fleets exactly what they’re doing,” explained Don Ake with FTR.

Ad Loading...

The 30-page report gives a close look at the activity that drives equipment replacement and parts purchases, such as vehicle age, typical trade cycles, miles driven per year, and preventive maintenance intervals.

One of the significant findings, although not necessarily surprising, was that the average Class 8 vehicle age differs significantly between small, medium and large fleets. For small fleets (fewer than 100 trucks), the average age of Class 8 vehicles was 5 years, while large fleets (1,000 trucks or more) reported an average of 2.7 years.

“The one thing I saw was how long some of the small fleets run their equipment,” Ake said in response to a question about anything in the survey that was a surprise. “They run it for a long time, and that’s consistent with some of the trends we’ve seen lately. In this economic recovery, because it hasn’t been robust, small fleets [aren’t] making a lot of money. They’re profitable but not making the amount of money they want, so they will tend to put off new expenditures, or even replacing their equipment with used equipment. They will run their equipment a very long time and use the money they have to repair it rather than replace it, and over time that leads to more maintenance expense in total.”

The survey found that for most fleets, when Class 8 trucks pass the 6-year old mark, average annual part cost can increase by as much as 50%.

However, a lot of small fleets can’t really afford to avoid those increased costs through shorter trade cycles, “the price of new equipment is prohibitive to a fleet who’s making money but not making a lot of money,” Ake explained.

Ad Loading...

Chris Kemmer with CKCVR explained that a lot the really large fleets heavily invested in new equipment over the last couple of years, “because there was plenty of freight to haul and a lot of nice new equipment offering them more productivity. Plus they were trying to attract new drivers. All those issues created an environment where large fleets were really accelerating their replacement cycle. They really have found some good productivity in these new vehicles. The price has gone up but there have been a lot of benefits to those new vehicles as well.”

Fleet size also was a factor in different maintenance practices. Typical PM schedules for all fleets reporting is 2.3 months for trucks and 2.7 months for trailers.

“A larger fleet, their maintenance capabilities are bigger and better, they have more resources,” Ake said. “They tend to standardize things more, they tend to have more rigid or more structured scheduling and better procedures, they can track stuff better so they’re a little more consistent and careful in their maintenance.”

When asked what fleets might take away from this report, Ake called it “an excellent benchmarking tool.”

Kemmer explained, “knowing what an average PM schedule is, knowing average part costs per year based on the age of vehicle, would be very helpful, both for truck and trailer, because that’s broken down by parts on the truck, parts on the trailer, types of trailers, age of vehicle, and we do the same thing with tire costs. Especially if I’m a small fleet and I don’t have a lot of sources to know where I fit and I look at my average cost is X, and I look at this and see the average is much less than, then I know that I’ve got a problem.”

Ad Loading...

For more information about the report and how to order a copy, go to ftrintel.com/2016study or contact dake@ftrintel.com or chris@ckcvr.com

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Maintenance

Maintenance•by Staff•November 16, 2026

Daimler, Paccar Recall Trucks Over Driveline Defect

Nearly 4,900 Freightliner, Western Star, and Kenworth trucks are being recalled because a missing snap ring could allow the driveline to separate from the truck.

Read More →
Maintenance technician holding tablet in shop environment with truck in background
Maintenance•November 16, 2026

What to Look for in Fleet Maintenance Software

Choosing the right maintenance technology starts with identifying the problems you need to solve. Here's what trucking fleets should look for — and what to ask potential providers.

Read More →
Bendix iTABS X trailer antilock braking system module shown in the foreground, with a tractor-trailer traveling on a highway in the background.
Equipment•by News/Media Release•November 11, 2026

Bendix Upgrades Trailer ABS With Smarter Diagnostics

The new iTABS X system replaces Bendix's TABS-6 Standard trailer ABS, adding faster diagnostics and connectivity that could help fleets identify brake-system problems before they lead to downtime.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
 Commercial vehicle inspector looking closely at truck engine
Safety & Compliance•by Staff•November 11, 2026

CVSA Sets 2027 International Roadcheck Dates

The annual 72-hour truck inspection blitz will take place May 11–13 across North America. Here's what fleets can expect and what inspectors found during the 2026 event.

Read More →
Fleet Management•by Staff•November 10, 2026

What Trucking Events are Happening in 2027?

Looking for trucking-related conventions, expos, and other events? Heavy Duty Trucking has developed this list of national and larger regional trucking shows and events.

Read More →
CVSA inspector looking at brakes underneath truck
Maintenance•by Staff•November 9, 2026

Brake Problems Sideline 15% of Inspected Trucks

During CVSA's 2026 Brake Safety Week, inspectors placed nearly 2,400 commercial vehicles out of service for brake violations, including problems with defective brakes, hoses, drums and rotors.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A row of black bottles with red, yellow, blue, and green labels
Sponsored•November 6, 2026

Unlocking the performance advantages of PC-12

2027 will mark the arrival of a new generation of heavy-duty engine oils. PC-12 reflects how far engine design has advanced and the demands that progress places on heavy-duty lubricants. Here’s what the transition means to your fleet.

Read More →
A man working on a truck engine, holding a wrench
Sponsored•November 3, 2026

6 Tips for Troubleshooting Cold-Weather Truck Problem: Don't Guess, Diagnose it

Cold weather can expose hidden truck problems. Discover six practical troubleshooting tips to pinpoint the cause, avoid unnecessary repairs and keep trucks on the road.

Read More →
A GP Transco tractor-trailer crosses a bridge over a river, with trailer side skirts visible beneath the white trailer.
Fuel Smarts•by Deborah Lockridge•October 27, 2026

How GP Transco Builds Fuel Savings a Fraction at a Time

Aerodynamic specs, solar panels, and driver incentives help GP Transco turn small efficiency gains into savings it can reinvest in its people.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Maintenance•by Deborah Lockridge•October 23, 2026

Oil Crisis Squeezes Trucking Lubricant Supplies

Fleets report higher lubricant costs as Middle East disruptions tighten supplies of ingredients used in synthetic engine oils and some driveline lubricants.

Read More →