Survey Shows Large Carriers Have An Edge Over Smaller Carriers

In its inaugural trucking industry benchmarking survey, Katz, Sapper & Miller and McLeod Software released key findings about large, medium and small truckload carriers.

by Staff

September 15, 2014

Survey Shows Large Carriers Have An Edge Over Smaller Carriers — *Photo via International.*

2 min to read

In its inaugural trucking industry benchmarking survey, Katz, Sapper & Miller and McLeod Software released key findings about large, medium and small truckload carriers.

The survey found that large carriers posted better operating ratio, higher average fuel mileage, and lower fuel cost per mile than small and medium carriers

Large carriers posted an operating ratio of 92 compared with 94 for medium carriers and 95 for small carriers. Large carriers also reported a slightly better average fuel economy of 6 mpg compared with 5.9 mpg for medium carriers and 5.7 mpg for small carriers.

Small carriers reported the highest fuel cost per mile at $0.64, while large and medium carriers averaged $0.59 per mile.

Large carriers were also found to have more diverse revenue streams, with 49% of revenue coming from the top 20 customers, while small and medium carriers reported 75% of revenue from the top 20 customers.

“This survey breaks new ground by giving truckload carriers the opportunity to measure the real performance of their operations against their peers,” said Tim Almack, partner-in-charge of KSM’s transportation services group.

The survey collected about 130 data elements from 2013. The carriers included in the survey ran a total of 16,000 trucks combined. Of the 16,000 trucks, 83% were company assets and 17% were owner-operator. Combined, these companies hauled 3 million loads, ran over 1.6 billion miles, and generated close to $3.9 billion in total revenue.

“The number of carriers who are electing to participate in this ongoing benchmark program is expected to increase substantially in future years, as more carriers recognize the benefits that benchmarking data can bring to their internal improvement efforts,” said Mark Cubine, vice president for McLeod.

KSM is a major CPA firm with experience with over 100 trucking and logistics clients throughout North America. McLeod Software is a provider of transportation dispatch, accounting, operations and brokerage management software and document management systems designed for the trucking industry.

Topics:Operating Costs Survey McLeod Software Small Fleets Large Fleets Fleet Management

More Fleet Management

Fleet Management•by Jack Roberts•April 2, 2026

Volvo Sees Market ‘Tipping Point’ as New VNL Orders Surge

Soft freight conditions persist, but aging fleets, strong order intake, and new-product momentum signal a more optimistic second half of 2026, Volvo Trucks North America says.

Illustration of a semi-trailer with a sports playbook diagram on chalkboard

Fleet Management•by Deborah Lockridge•April 1, 2026

Cargo Theft’s New Playbook: Strategic Fraud, Double Brokering, and Cybercrime Hit Trucking

Cargo theft is evolving from regional smash-and-grab operations to sophisticated fraud schemes. Strategic theft now accounts for roughly a third of cargo crime, with incidents rising sharply in recent years. Here’s how the schemes work — and what fleets can do to protect themselves.

Collage of Top 20 Product award ceremonies

Equipment•March 31, 2026

HDT Honors the Best New Products of 2025 at TMC [Photos]

Heavy Duty Trucking's Top 20 Products awards recognize the best new products and technologies. Check out the award presentations at the 2026 Technology & Maintenance Council annual meeting.

Detroit Engines: Trusted Performance, Built for What's Next

The Detroit® Gen 6 engine platform proves that real progress doesn’t require a complete redesign. Built on 20 years of trusted technology, these engines are designed for efficiency, stronger performance, and greater reliability than before. And they do it all while complying with 2027 EPA standards on every mile.