Heavy Duty Trucking Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Justices Pose Close Questions in LA Port Case

The long and tumultuous matter of the Port of Los Angeles’ Clean Truck Program came to a head in the Supreme Court Tuesday, with Justices conducting a spirited discussion with opposing attorneys.

Oliver Patton
Oliver PattonFormer Washington Editor
April 16, 2013
Justices Pose Close Questions in LA Port Case

 

4 min to read


The long and tumultuous matter of the Port of Los Angeles’ Clean Truck Program came to a head in the Supreme Court Tuesday, with Justices conducting a spirited discussion with opposing attorneys.

At issue are two provisions of the port’s 2008 Clean Trucks Program under which drayage carriers must join a concession agreement in order to provide service.

Ad Loading...

American Trucking Associations has pursued through the lower courts the argument that the port does not have authority to require the provisions.

ATA contends that the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act exempts carriers from the off-street parking and placard provisions of the agreement.

Those provisions require carriers to submit an off-street parking plan, and to mount placards with a phone number so the public can report concerns about safety or the environment.

Ad Loading...

ATA also says that under a 1954 Supreme Court decision, Castle v. Hayes Freight Lines, the port may not suspend or revoke a carrier’s access.

The issues come down to the division of power between states and the federal government, a question the Justices pursued in a number of ways.

By restricting entry and imposing criminal penalties for violations of the agreement, the port is limiting access to a key channel of interstate commerce, argued ATA’s attorney, Daniel Lerman of the Washington, D.C., law firm of Robbins Russell.

“The port is invoking the full coercive power of the state to impose conditions on motor carriers, and that is exactly what Congress sought to prevent,” he said.

The port contends that it can impose these restrictions because it is a participant in the market, rather than just a state regulator, and as such is exempt from the Federal Aviation Act.

Ad Loading...

Justice Sonia Sotomayor asked Lerman if the court needs to address the market participant question, given that it can decide that the agreement either has the force of law or is a private contract.

“It either has the force and effect of law or it doesn’t,” Lerman replied. If it does have that force, then the court does not need to address market participation, he said.

Justice Stephen Breyer said it seemed clear to him that the port should be able to impose parking requirements under the authority of the states to impose highway route controls.

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg asked how the federal government, which is supporting ATA in this matter, thinks the port should deal with the underlying problem of complaints from the people who live near the port.

 “Here is a port that’s getting lots of complaints from the neighborhood people,” she said.

Ad Loading...

“It wants to expand the port, it’s being thwarted by environmental suits, so it wants to go green and it wants to do something about the pollution and the traffic and the hazards from the truck. You’re saying that it can’t do that?”

The attorney for the U.S., Assistant Solicitor General John Bash, replied he was not saying that the port has no recourse.

He cited the port’s approach to getting cleaner trucks into the drayage business, which involved creating a subsidy and incentive program to replace old trucks with new ones, as a way to achieve its goals without imposing criminal penalties.

On another point, Justice Breyer questioned the attorney for the port, Steven Rosenthal of the Washington, D.C., firm Kaye Scholer, about the issue of how the port may control its land.

“The owner of land has to have some control of the type which ATA and the government says we can’t have control over,” Rosenthal said.

Ad Loading...

Breyer said, “You’re saying it falls outside the definition of ‘routes.’ Well, that argument is not in front of us. I thought we were conceding here (that the concession agreement) falls within the definition of routes or rates or services.”

Rosenthal replied that that is not the case. “Our position is that even it is its rates, routes and services, what the port is doing is regulatory.

“If we are prescribing it, it’s inherent within our ability to access our particular land.”

In a statement released after the argument, ATA said it is concerned about the precedent that will be set if the LA port’s approach is upheld.

“If these rules are allowed to stand, it would clear the way for a patchwork of regulations that would lead to unreasonable burdens on the movement of goods,” said ATA Deputy Chief Counsel Richard Pianka in a statement.

Ad Loading...

Other groups supporting ATA in the matter are the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, Airlines for America, the Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association, National Federation of Independent Businesses and the Harbor Trucking Association.

The court is expected to hand down its decision in July.

More Drivers

Illustration of truck owner operator and magnifying glass with the word "regulations"
Drivers•by Deborah Lockridge•November 19, 2026

New Independent Contractor Rule Gives Trucking More Clarity

The Labor Department is once again changing how it determines who's an independent contractor. This time, the rule includes specific examples addressing trucking safety requirements, CDLs, and lease-purchase agreements.

A truck driver in his cap, rubbing his eyes in exhaustion.
Sponsored•November 18, 2026

Catching Driver Fatigue is One Thing. What You Do Next Matters Just as Much

Fleets are getting better at detecting driver drowsiness. Few have figured out what should happen next, and that gap is where the real risk still lives.

Illustration with background of driver using ELD, with DOT logo and photo of FMCSA official in truck with driver
Safety & Compliance•by Deborah Lockridge•November 13, 2026

133 ELDs Revoked as ATA Pushes Certification Reform

FMCSA just removed a record number of electronic logging devices from its registry. ATA says it's time to rethink how ELDs get approved in the first place.

Ad Loading...
 Commercial vehicle inspector looking closely at truck engine
Safety & Compliance•by Staff•November 11, 2026

CVSA Sets 2027 International Roadcheck Dates

The annual 72-hour truck inspection blitz will take place May 11–13 across North America. Here's what fleets can expect and what inspectors found during the 2026 event.

Photo illustration combining laboratory sample tubes, marijuana, pills, white powder, and a syringe above a highway with tractor-trailers.
Safety & Compliance•by Deborah Lockridge•November 2, 2026

FDA Eases Path for Oral-Fluid Testing

Federal actions could advance oral-fluid drug testing for truck drivers, but lab certification delays and marijuana rescheduling questions remain.

Truck driver in a blue-tinted cab beside a hand holding cash, with the headline “Competing for Drivers.”
Drivers•by Deborah Lockridge•October 29, 2026

Why Hiring Truck Drivers Is Getting Harder

Higher recruiting costs, a shrinking driver pool, and renewed pay competition are raising the stakes for fleets heading into 2027.

Ad Loading...
Two red heavy-duty Class 8 trucks with Roehl branding
Drivers•by News/Media Release•October 27, 2026

Roehl Offers Truck Drivers $10,000 Retention Incentive

Payments begin after the first load and continue in mileage-based installments for eligible experienced drivers joining the fleet.

PS Coach tablet interface showing a driver’s coaching inbox, safety event video and coaching advice for a harsh-braking event.
Fleet Management•by News/Media Release•October 21, 2026

Platform Science Adds Dispatch and Safety Tools

Four additions to PS Fleet help fleets monitor loads, manage driver coaching, share truck locations and adjust video system settings.

Man with police badge on his arm by an open commercial truck door examining paperwork
Safety & Compliance•October 15, 2026

When Language Stops the Truck: The Return of ELP Out-of-Service Orders

English language proficiency rules for commercial drivers aren’t new, but renewed out-of-service enforcement has raised the stakes. Here’s what carriers need to know before a driver reaches a roadside inspection.

Ad Loading...
Illustration of silver robot waving his hand and a Samsara AI prompt on screen to call drivers
Fleet Management•by Staff•October 13, 2026

Samsara Launches Custom AI Agent Builder

Agent Studio lets fleets create AI tools for hours-of-service monitoring, reporting and driver support, including agents that communicate by phone.