Over the past week or two, Truckinginfo.com has been talking to a lot of people about their initial reaction to the hours of service proposal. Those interviews have included not only those in the trucking industry, but the safety groups that influence the government's actions as well.
Jerry Donaldson, senior director of research at the Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety, is the group's truck expert and is very articulate on this issue. He even seems to have some understanding of real-world trucking issues.
"I have found a number of basic drawbacks to this rule which I am personally astounded have ever passed muster and made it into the Federal Register," Donaldson said. "The proposal does almost nothing to promote or increase safety of professional drivers or the drivers who share the roads with them. It has dismayed all sectors of the trucking industry, so as far as I can see the safety community is strongly opposed to this rule as well."
While Donaldson says his group is happy that the U.S. Department of Transportation "has finally admitted fatigue is a major cause of crashes," he says the proposal doesn't abide by prevailing research on fatigue. "It in fact openly distorts well known research findings to serve the convenience of claiming that the rule has adequate scientific foundation."
The cost-benefit analysis, which has come under attack by the American Trucking Assns. and other trucking groups, also falls under Donaldson's ax. He says it is "based on extremely tenuous and speculative assumptions, and … 50% of the benefits are paperwork reduction benefits, not safety benefits … The fact is that there are key assumptions that if they were changed, you would have a negative benefit cost ratio."
Donaldson says the proposal demonstrates how the DOT fails to understand how the trucking industry operates. The proposal treats regional drivers and long-haul drivers the same, he says, yet regional drivers more often drive at night in order to make morning deliveries, he says.
Many critics have pointed out that the proposal doesn't really address the issue of truck drivers having to do non-paid activities, such as loading and unloading. "This proposal not only makes not distinction between driving and on duty not driving, it has no provision for rivers showing how they spent time out of cab when they're not driving," Donaldson says. "Just-in-time deliveries will have to be made by maximizing available driving time, so drivers will drive up to the last available minute, and when they are importuned as they are now to perform other tasks, such as loading and unloading, they will do it during their off duty time and they will lie about it."
For more on how industry and safety groups have reacted to the hours of service proposal, see the June issue of RoadStar or Heavy Duty Trucking magazine.
HOS: One Safety Advocate's View
Over the past week or two, Truckinginfo.com has been talking to a lot of people about their initial reaction to the hours of service proposal. Those interviews have included not only those in the trucking industry,
More Drivers

FMCSA Extends Paper Medical Card Exemption … Again
Five states still aren't ready to accept commercial driver medical exam information directly from the medical examiner's registry.
Read More →
Mack Launches Digital Driver Guide for Chassis-Specific Truck Info
Mack’s new, virtual owner’s manual delivers VIN-based, on-demand guidance for vehicle systems via web, app, and soon in-cab displays.
Read More →
Western Star Showcases Truckers' Pride and Skill
Western Star is expanding its Star Nation Experience in 2026, adding new competitions and dealer participation to highlight operator skills and promote careers in trucking.
Read More →
Best Fleets to Drive For: Two Carriers Earn Overall Award for First Time
CarriersEdge announced the 2026 Best Fleets to Drive For overall winners, with Crawford Trucking, Fortigo Freight Services, and FTC Transportation receiving top awards.
Read More →
Federal Proposal Would Allow Pell Grants for Shorter-Term Job Training
The Department of Labor plans to expand Pell Grant eligibility to some shorter workforce training programs, a move the American Trucking Associations said will help strengthen commercial driver training schools and diesel technician training programs.
Read More →
Owner-Operator Model Gets Boost as DOL Proposes 2024 Independent Contractor Definition Reversal
For an industry that has watched this issue go back and forth for years, the independent contractor proposal marks the latest swing in the regulatory pendulum.
Read More →
FMCSA Reinstates Field Warrior ELD to Registered Device List
One electronic logging device has been reinstated to the FMCSA's list of registered ELDs.
Read More →
How One Company is Using Smart Suspension Technology to Reduce Driver Injuries and Improve Retention
America’s Service Line adopted Link’s SmartValve and ROI Cabmate systems to address whole-body vibration, repetitive strain, and driver turnover. The trucking fleet is already seeing measurable results.
Read More →
CarriersEdge Announces 2026 Best Fleets to Drive For
The 18th annual contest recognizing the best workplaces for truck drivers sees changes to Top 20, Hall of Fame
Read More →
FMCSA Targets 550+ ‘Sham’ CDL Schools in Nationwide Sting Operation
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration issued more than 550 notices of proposed removal to commercial driver training providers following a five-day nationwide enforcement sweep. Investigators cited unqualified instructors, improper training vehicles, and failure to meet federal and state requirements.
Read More →
