
After enduring a bruising first quarter that saw falling profits at many fleets, it comes as no surprise that in a second quarter survey of business conditions, responses show fleet executives are feeling a bit down.
After enduring a bruising first quarter that saw falling profits at many fleets, it comes as no surprise that in a second quarter survey of business conditions fleet executives are feeling a bit down.

The percentage of fleets' parked trucks in the first quarter of 2016 is the highest in a year, but is only one of several signs of a slowing trucking business and overall economy.

After enduring a bruising first quarter that saw falling profits at many fleets, it comes as no surprise that in a second quarter survey of business conditions, responses show fleet executives are feeling a bit down.
Multiple fleet earnings reports described the first quarter freight environment as “challenging,” with a slowdown in the overall economy getting much of the blame. The first estimate of GDP for the quarter showed the economy growing at an annual rate of just 0.5%, the slowest expansion in the nation’s gross domestic product since the first quarter of 2014.
Hearing from Chris Kemmer, president of CK Commercial Vehicle Research and publisher of the Fleet Sentiment Survey Report, there’s little doubt this has led to a softening in overall operating metrics for trucking companies.
It’s not a fall-off-the-cliff scenario, but utilization is down, parked vehicles are up, and the overall “how’s business” rating in the survey has fallen for the first time in more than a year, to 3.9 on a 5.0 scale. While better than the 3.2 seen during the throes of the Great Recession, that’s down from the 4.2 reported in the second quarters of 2015 and 2014.
Out of all the measures Kemmer presented from the survey in a webinar last month, the most interesting and the one she described as a “major concern” is a spike in the number of parked trucks, which she called “very reflective of the market.”
According to the survey, the percentage of fleets’ parked vehicles continues heading upward, now above 6.2% for power units and 5.8% for trailers. Both measures were below 2% in the second quarter of 2015.
Interestingly, in the first quarter of 2015, when there were more freight movements and rates were better, the percentage of parked trucks and trailers was even higher.
“I think the difference is last year, [fleets] had vehicles parked because they didn’t have drivers. They had freight, plenty of freight last year, but they were short on drivers,” Kemmer said. This year’s second quarter survey results reflect an attitude more of, “I don’t need the trucks that bad, so it’s okay that they are parked,” she explained.
Why is the increase in parked vehicles a concern? Equipment utilization is also softening for both power units and trailers. It’s still above 85% for trucks and higher than 80% for trailers among survey respondents, Kemmer said, which is in a “decent range but it’s not growing.” Some fleets are continuing to add capacity, but the percentage of fleets doing so is down from a year earlier.
One large truckload carrier reported it “needed more freight” to fill current capacity.
“That is likely to trickle down to smaller fleets,” Kemmer said in an interview. “And while I don’t track shipping rates, I would assume excess capacity ultimately reduces spot rates fleets can charge. Also, if freight continues to soften, or doesn’t strengthen significantly, fewer trucks and trailers will be ordered.”
All this translates into a softening trajectory for trucking, but Kemmer stressed it’s also “not doom and gloom.” However, with recent forecasts lowering expectations for overall economic growth this year, fleets may find they have to withstand some more bruises.

Speaking at the TMC Annual Meeting in Nashville, ATA President Chris Spear said trucking faces mounting pressure from rising fuel prices, geopolitical instability, and uncertainty around trade policy.
Read More →
More than 100,000 new trucking companies enter the industry each year, but regulators manage to audit only a fraction of them. That churn creates opportunities for inexperienced startups — and for “chameleon carriers” that shut down after safety violations and reappear under new identities. Read more from Deborah Lockridge in this commentary.
Read More →
HDTX is an intimate event that connects heavy-duty trucking fleet managers with industry suppliers through small-group discussions, educational sessions, and structured one-on-one meetings.
Read More →
New DAT One feature shows top-paying loads directly on an iPhone’s home screen, helping carriers react faster to spot-market opportunities.
Read More →
Optimal Dynamics says its new Scale platform uses AI agents and optimization to help carriers find and secure freight that improves network balance and profitability.
Read More →
DAT Freight & Analytics data shows tightening flatbed capacity, easing produce markets, and softening van and reefer rates.
Read More →
NACFE's Run on Less - Messy Middle project demonstrates the power of data in helping to guide the future of alternative fuels and powertrains for heavy-duty trucks.
Read More →
A federal court ruling allows New York City’s congestion pricing program to continue, leaving truck tolls in place for fleets delivering into Manhattan.
Read More →
Fontaine Modification has introduced a new customer portal designed to give fleets real-time visibility into the truck modification process, addressing one of the most common questions fleet managers face: “Where’s my truck?”
Read More →
Strong freight rates, rising volumes and tighter capacity push trucking conditions higher, though diesel prices could temper gains in the near term, FTR cautions.
Read More →