Heavy Duty Trucking Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Bashing Truck Safety

Is the New York Times this prejudicial, or is it just naïve?

by Deborah Whistler, Editor
January 1, 2007
Bashing Truck Safety

 

3 min to read


A strategically timed front page feature in the Dec. 3 edition of the New York Times pointed a finger at the trucking industry, the Bush administration and the Republican-controlled Congress for causing unnecessary deaths on our highways. 

Ad Loading...

To say this piece is slanted would be an understatement. It could have been ghost-written by Joan Claybrook, head of Public Citizen. Both, as most people know, are harsh critics of the industry. 

The story followed the standard truck-bashing formula: Start with a tragic truck-at-fault crash (this one involved the death of a 62-year-old woman and a rookie truck driver). Bring in the contention that it might not have happened if safety regulations were stronger. Then blame someone (guess who?) for not making them stronger. 

Ad Loading...

In this case, the reporter said regulators have rejected stricter truck driver hours rules "after intense lobbying" by trucking, that the Bush administration has loosened safety standards, and that its actions have gone unchecked by Congress.

The reporter described trucking as "America's most treacherous industry, as measured by overall deaths and injuries from truck accidents." But he failed to present supporting data. 

Adding insult to injury, the Times followed up a few days later with an editorial attacking trucks entitled "Making the Highways Less Safe." 

Several trucking groups and individuals wrote the Times in rebuttal. American Trucking Associations President Bill Graves said: "The Times' fundamental premise that trucking rules have been 'eased' is wrong. The safety rules governing trucking were toughened and strengthened under the Bush administration, as they have been under Republicans and Democrats alike since economic deregulation in 1980." 

ATA officials supplied the Times reporter, Stephen Labaton, with its safety agenda and goals, but none of them appeared in the story. Instead, Labaton wrote of ATA's power in the White House, insinuating that it has a chokehold on safety progress. 

Ad Loading...

The paper also drew the ire of the Department of Transportation. "In their frenzy to find fault, the New York Times has cherry-picked data, rewritten history, and incorrectly reported the most basic facts," wrote Brian Turmail, DOT director of communications. "The New York Times needs to admit its errors and set the record straight." 

We agree, but as of this writing, it hasn't. Don't hold your breath. 

The story and editorial ran just as the courts were due to review truck driver hours of service rules. Considering that timing, and the writer's generous use of materials and claims from the anti-truck crowd, we wonder if this has become an agenda for the esteemed Times. Or maybe it was just a lousy job by a naïve reporter. 

We truly hope it was the latter. The Times should be above publishing diatribes that facts don't support. 

Item of interest: Late last month, Canada introduced its new hours of service rules. They are nearly identical to ours, and in the few instances where different, are less restrictive. 

Ad Loading...

Do you suppose the Times will blame Bush, ATA and Republicans everywhere for that, too.

E-mail Deb Whistler at dwhistler@truckinginfo.com

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Fleet Management

Illustration of truck owner operator and magnifying glass with the word "regulations"
Drivers•by Deborah Lockridge•November 19, 2026

New Independent Contractor Rule Gives Trucking More Clarity

The Labor Department is once again changing how it determines who's an independent contractor. This time, the rule includes specific examples addressing trucking safety requirements, CDLs, and lease-purchase agreements.

Heavy trucks backed up in highway traffic, with an inset photo of congestion and a chart showing trucking industry congestion costs rising from $84.6 billion in 2016 to $128.2 billion in 2024, according to ATRI.
Fleet Management•by Deborah Lockridge•November 18, 2026

Trucking's Annual Congestion Costs Reach $128.2 Billion

That's the average cost, according to new ATRI research. And the wasted time and diesel are staggering.

HDT Talks Trucking thumbnail saying: Replace Your TMS? Not so Fast, with headshots of host Deborah Lockridge and guest Bill Cain of TMW/Trimble
Fleet Management•November 13, 2026

How to Modernize Your TMS Without Replacing It [Podcast]

Before investing in a new transportation management system, take a closer look at what you've already got. AI, cloud technology and better integrations may offer ways to improve your trucking operations without starting over.

Ad Loading...
Driver on tablet using ELD with digital data concept graphics
Fleet Management•November 11, 2026

Could Your Truck's Connected Devices Be a Cybersecurity Risk?

ELDs, telematics systems and driver tablets help fleets operate more efficiently. But every connected device needs protection against cyberattacks.

Tractor-trailers on a highway with a TRAFFIX market data graphic showing spot truckload rates up 48% year over year, tender rejections at 12.9%, and freight volumes up 4.7% over two weeks.
Fleet Management•by Deborah Lockridge•November 10, 2026

Holiday Freight Meets a Tight Trucking Market

There's no freight boom, but truckload carriers are finding themselves in a stronger position to negotiate rates. And holiday shipping demand could tighten the market further.

Fleet Management•by Staff•November 10, 2026

What Trucking Events are Happening in 2027?

Looking for trucking-related conventions, expos, and other events? Heavy Duty Trucking has developed this list of national and larger regional trucking shows and events.

Ad Loading...
Illustration of a dispatcher viewing load schedules and a route map, with connected icons representing dispatch, trailer tracking, maintenance, documents, and billing.
Fleet Management•by Deborah Lockridge•November 9, 2026

Does Your Trucking Fleet Need a New TMS?

Artificial intelligence and better integrations promise less busywork and more useful data. Can your TMS help your company solve problems? Do you need additional vendors or an upgrade? Or is it time to look for a new platform?

Erik Neandross, President of Clean Transportation Solutions at TRC.
Fleet Management•by Staff•November 8, 2026

Fleet Costs Shape ACT Expo 2027 Agenda

With diesel prices high and operating expenses under pressure, ACT Expo's 2027 agenda emphasizes fuel efficiency, AI, safety and the return on fleet technology investments.

HDT Talks Trucking YouTube thumbnail with host Deborah Lockridge and guest Bill Cain of TMW
Fleet Management•by Deborah Lockridge•November 5, 2026

Does Your Trucking Fleet Need a New TMS? [Video]

Cloud technology, AI and new integrations are changing what transportation management systems can do. But does taking advantage of those advances mean replacing your existing TMS?

Ad Loading...
Saegic TrackRR Gateway solar-powered trailer telematics device shown alongside screenshots of the Saegic Cloud Platform displaying trailer location, tire monitoring, and equipment status.
Fleet Management•November 4, 2026

Road Ready Becomes Saegic, Launches New Trailer Telematics Gateway

Clarience Technologies is rolling out new hardware and expanding its plans for connecting trailer telematics, maintenance data, and video.