Heavy Duty Trucking Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

'Welcome to Washington...'

Are we on a highway to nowhere? In his Passing Zone blog, Executive Editor David Cullen delves into what President Trump's budget proposal has to say about fixing and building America's roads and bridges.

David Cullen
David Cullen[Former] Business/Washington Contributing Editor
Read David's Posts
May 25, 2017
'Welcome to Washington...'

President Trump's 2018 Budget Photo: White House Office of Management and Budget

4 min to read


President Trump's 2018 Budget Photo: White House Office of Management and Budget

Anyone hoping they’ll learn lots more about that trillion-dollar infrastructure investment plan President Trump first dangled before the nation back on the day after the election has to be sorely disappointed if they read the foundational document on his federal budget proposal just put out by the White House.

Grandly titled “A New Foundation for American Greatness,” the Fiscal Year 2018 budget document runs over 50 pages.

Ad Loading...

But less than a single printed page is devoted to “an Infrastructure Plan to support $1 trillion in private/public infrastructure investment.”

What’s more, or less as the case is here, the discussion about infrastructure is presented in the most general of terms.

The only mention tying in highways comes in a laundry list of what the plan aims to fix: “surface transportation, airports, waterways, ports, drinking and waste water, broadband and key Federal facilities.”

Rather than seeking substantial increases in federal spending on infrastructure from Congress, the message is loud and clear that Trump sees the private sector riding to the rescue of America's failing infrastructure.  

The administration’s goal is “to seek long-term reforms on how infrastructure projects are regulated, funded, delivered, and maintained. Simply providing more Federal funding for infrastructure is not the solution. Rather, we will work to fix underlying incentives, procedures, and policies to spur better, and more efficient, infrastructure decisions and outcomes.”

Ad Loading...

The document claims that the president’s target of $1 trillion in investments will be “met with a combination of new Federal funding, incentivized non-Federal funding, and expedited projects that would not have happened but for the administration’s involvement (for example, the Keystone XL Pipeline).”

The budget calls for $200 billion in federal outlays “related to the infrastructure initiative,” which appears intended to work as seed money for public-private partnerships (P3) projects, such as tolled highways.

That’s suggested by this sentence: “The impact of this investment will be amplified with other administrative and regulatory actions the administration plans to pursue.”

The infrastructure passage closes with the assertion that the administration also “will eliminate or significantly revise regulations that create unnecessary barriers to infrastructure investment by all levels of government and the private sector.”

That’s all fine and good. But nowhere does it say even from where that $200 billion in federal funding for P3s to leverage will be coming.

Ad Loading...

There is certainly no mention of the funding mechanism for pumping up the Highway Trust Fund that is most favored by the trucking industry: Raising federal fuel taxes.

That’s a major concern of David Congdon, CEO of Old Dominion Freight Line and co-chair of the infrastructure task force made up of top carrier executives that the American Trucking Associations formed right after the election.  

David Congdon Photo: Old Dominion Freight Line

When I asked Congdon the other day how ATA’s effort to draw attention to the need for vastly increasing highway funding was coming along, he replied, “Welcome to Washington, where it’s not as easy to get things done as you’d like.”  

He explained that ATA set up the task force “to get ahead of the power curve to offer our assessments [on infrastructure] to President Trump and to Secretary Chao.”

The group got to meet with Chao in January, but as it was her third day on the job “she wasn’t prepared to discuss details.”  

Ad Loading...

Then the ATA leaders got the president’s ear during a well-publicized meeting at the White House. But timing is everything and as it happened, both the president and Vice President Pence were more interested in buttonholing truckers on the highly controversial healthcare bill that was before the House that March day.  

“Since then,” Congdon told me, “ATA has been doing a pretty good job behind the scenes working with Secretary Chao and her team— we’re continuing to plant the seeds on what our greatest needs are.”  

And topping that list, he said is “increasing the fuel tax. It could be collected at the fuel rack so it just becomes part of the cost. It’s the most efficient way to collect money [to fund roads]. Every penny a gallon raised generates $1.5 billion a year.

"We’re still advocating increasing the fuel tax because it would contribute immediately and substantially to highway funding," Congdon continued. It should be indexed to inflation and maybe also to the rising rate of fuel economy.”  

Congdon concedes he “doesn’t know which way” this idea will go this time around, “but President Trump has heard about it from us. We feel if he takes the lead on this, he may be able to get everyone on board. Anyway, we are trying to move it along.”  

Ad Loading...

That’s all anyone can hope to do inside the Beltway— no matter who is calling the shots in the Oval Office.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Blogposts

Passing Zoneby David CullenSeptember 20, 2021

Congress Dancing on the Ceiling. Again.

It’s time once more on Capitol Hill to battle over the debt ceiling, rather than conduct the nation’s urgent business, says HDT Business/Washington Contributing Editor David Cullen.

Read More →
Passing Zoneby David CullenJune 18, 2021

Infrastructure on Capitol Hill: On Two Tracks to Somewhere

It’s likely an infrastructure bill will pass. But how big it will be, and who will pay for it, rides on lots of politicking.

Read More →
Passing Zoneby David CullenApril 23, 2021

Gaming Out The Biden Infrastructure Proposal on Capitol Hill

The Biden Administration's American Jobs Act, the core of which is infrastructure funding, is on a long road to becoming law – replete with more twists and turns than a mountain highway.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Passing Zoneby Deborah LockridgeFebruary 17, 2021

4 Ways Washington May Change Trucking Laws and Regulations

As the balance of power in Washington has shifted, trucking likely will see changes in laws and regulations. But how that happens isn't just like the Schoolhouse Rock version of "I'm Just a Bill."

Read More →
Passing Zoneby David CullenJanuary 11, 2020

Regulatory Outlook 2020: Keep an Eye on Hours of Service

What's in store for trucking from the regulators in Washington, D.C., this year? Executive Editor David Cullen says the government wheels move slowly, but hours-of-service is among those to watch in 2020.

Read More →
Passing Zoneby David CullenOctober 2, 2019

Logistics Ain't What it Used to Be

You can no longer expect to run a motor carrier of any size without at least a glancing appreciation for the impact logistics— in one way or another-- has on every link in the supply chain.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Passing Zoneby David CullenSeptember 23, 2019

Will Dustup over Cleanup of Car Emissions Gut Truck GHG Rules?

What does Trump's revocation of California's vehicle emission waiver mean for the federal Phase 2 GHG emission rules already in place for commercial vehicles? Commentary by Executive Editor David Cullen.

Read More →
Passing Zoneby David CullenAugust 22, 2019

Some Sober Advice on the Drug & Alcohol Clearinghouse

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration's prep work for the Drug & Alcohol Clearinghouse includes amassing an impressive amount of informational guidance online that can be accessed at a dedicated website. Commentary by Executive Editor David Cullen.

Read More →
Passing Zoneby David CullenMay 3, 2019

Here's to Our Winners

The managers, executives, and owners of truck operations who are honored each year by Heavy Duty Trucking with our Truck Fleet Innovator awards so often seem to be moving at a fast clip in how they think about things. Blog Commentary by Executive Editor David Cullen.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Passing Zoneby David CullenApril 4, 2019

ATA Takes Madison Avenue to Pitch Highway Funding on Capitol Hill

A new advertising and grassroots campaign by ATA might just sell Congress on fixing our roads. Commentary by David Cullen, Executive Editor.

Read More →