Heavy Duty Trucking Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Is a CDL worth someone's life?

In December, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration took the unusual action of declaring a driver, not a company, an “imminent hazard” and ordered him to cease operating.

Deborah Lockridge
Deborah LockridgeEditor and Associate Publisher
Read Deborah's Posts
February 26, 2013
3 min to read


In December, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration took the unusual action of declaring a driver, not a company, an “imminent hazard” and ordered him to cease operating.

Georgia-licensed truck driver Johnny Felton Jr. admitted to losing consciousness before hitting and killing an Illinois state trooper, Kyle Deatherage, in late November.

Ad Loading...

Investigators discovered that Felton failed to disclose to a medical examiner his disqualifying medical conditions or the medications he was taking to treat them.

Felton drove for DOT Transportation Inc. in Mt. Sterling, Ill. Now Deatherage's family is suing the company.

We don't know what Felton's medical conditions were. The FMCSA redacted that information in the out-of-service order released to the public.

Whatever it was, it didn't keep Felton from getting his medical certification, and it should have. It can't be easy for a doctor to take away a patient's livelihood with the stroke of a pen, but this case shows what can happen if they don't.

Sadly, Felton is not an isolated case.

Ad Loading...

Last November, the Government Accountability Office released a report on cases of commercial drivers with potentially disqualifying medical problems. It matched CDL holders with Social Security Administration disability files and found more than 200 commercial drivers who were on the road as recently as 2011 despite having the disqualifying medical condition of epilepsy.

Thirty-one of those drivers were involved in accidents.

One of the examples identified was a Mississippi driver who was approved for SSA disability benefits in 2007. Although he informed Social Security that he couldn't drive because of his condition, he renewed his CDL the next year. In 2009, medical professionals told him he should not be driving, but he again renewed his CDL in 2010 and was involved in a crash in a commercial vehicle the same year.

Doctor-shopping by drivers is hardly a new problem. If one doctor won't approve them for a med card, they'll keep trying until they find one who will. Some unscrupulous fleets have even been known to refer drivers to physicians who are willing to overlook disqualifying medical problems.

Woe be to any trucking company in DOT Transportation's circumstances if the attorneys for the victim's family are able to prove that.

Ad Loading...

Often, however, the problem is simply that the medical professional performing the exam isn't really familiar with the regulations on what disqualifies a driver. And if a driver lies or withholds information, it makes it that much harder. The DOT is working to address the problem. It is now requiring CDL holders to provide a copy of their medical certificates to state driver licensing agencies. And a new rule requires those who perform medical exams for drivers to be trained, tested and certified to a national standard. They're being listed in a new online registry, and by May 21, 2014, drivers must use a certified examiner to get their med card.

It's been a long time coming. Regulators have been working on this problem since 2005, when the agency began public discussions on how to put a registry together. The proposed rule came out in 2008 and the final rule was issued only last year.

There's no way to know for sure if the new rule would have kept Felton off the road, Deatherage alive and Felton's employer out of court, but it's about time the FMCSA did something to address the shortcomings in the system.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Blog Posts

TMC 2025 Takeaway 2: Buy... or Subscribe?

TaaS. Does that mean trucks as a service, trailers as a service, or tires as a service? HDT's Deborah Lockridge has another takeaway from the Technology & Maintenance Council meeting in her blog.

Read More →
Red Cummins X15 powertrain display at TMC

TMC 2025 Takeaway: The Journey Toward Vertical Integration

HDT's Deborah Lockridge on how the trucking industry has moved toward "vertical integration" over the past 25 years.

Read More →
Girl Scouts at Touch a Truck event

Trucks Are For Girls!

HDT Editor and Associate Publisher Deborah Lockridge is a longtime Girl Scout leader and loves to connect her passion for inspiring girls with her love of the trucking industry.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
All That's Truckingby Deborah LockridgeOctober 29, 2024

Trucking Advocacy: Impact Beyond the 2024 Elections

No matter who wins the election, trucking continues to work to educate the people who pass the laws and make the rules that affect the industry. HDT's Deborah Lockridge shares insights from two major trucking associations in her All That's Trucking blog.

Read More →
View of Gulf of Mexico from under beach umbrella
All That's Truckingby Deborah LockridgeAugust 22, 2024

Recharge Your Brain for Better Business

Skimping on vacation may be the worst thing you can do for your business, your career, and your mental health. In her All That's Trucking blog, Deborah Lockridge writes about the importance of giving your brain what it needs to be innovative.

Read More →
kitten caught between two truck tire wheels

Trucker Pre-Trip Leads to Mission 'Im-paw-sible'

See what happened when a truck driver found an unexpected stowaway during his pre-trip inspection.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
All That's Truckingby Deborah LockridgeDecember 28, 2023

HDT Editor: 2023's Most Important Trucking Topics

Read Deborah Lockridge's picks for the most significant stories we covered at HDT in 2023: freight recession, zero-emission trucks, drivers and marijuana, and more.

Read More →
All That's Truckingby Deborah LockridgeOctober 31, 2023

3 Takeaways from ATA's 2023 Management Conference

HDT's Deborah Lockridge talks about key themes that emerged during sessions, conversations, and on the show floor during the American Trucking Associations' annual management conference.

Read More →
All That's Truckingby Deborah LockridgeSeptember 22, 2023

An Update on Spencer Patton's Battle with FedEx Ground

In her All That's Trucking blog, Deborah Lockridge shares a follow-up to last year's story about a FedEx Ground contractor who was very publicly challenging the company about alleged unfair treatment of its contractors.

Read More →
Ad Loading...

Girl Scouts Rock the Supply Chain

Curiosity about how Girl Scout cookies get from the factory to the customer drove the development of a supply patch program. HDT's Deborah Lockridge, a Girl Scout herself, writes about it in her All That's Trucking blog.

Read More →