Heavy Duty Trucking Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Commentary: Mr. Spock Goes to Washington

Instead of doing the logical thing and raising the fuel tax, politicians have come up with just about every cockamamie scheme you can imagine.

Deborah Lockridge
Deborah LockridgeEditor and Associate Publisher
Read Deborah's Posts
February 18, 2015
Commentary: Mr. Spock Goes to Washington

Deborah Lockridge, Editor in Chief

3 min to read


Deborah Lockridge, Editor in Chief

If Mr. Spock, the oh-so-logical Vulcan of “Star Trek” fame, were to find himself on Capitol Hill right now, his head would explode.

The new session of Congress is facing a federal highway program that runs out of money in May. The Highway Trust Fund has been insolvent since 2008, limping along on transfers from the Treasury while Congress keeps kicking the can down the road. It did it again last summer, when it passed a 10-month highway bill, the one that expires in just a few months.

Meanwhile, a worldwide glut of crude oil has pushed gas and diesel prices to their lowest prices in years, and the economy continues to improve.

Quite logically, some in Congress have proposed raising the fuel tax to help eliminate the massive shortfalls in the Trust Fund.

First passed in 1956 to pay for the more than 40,000 miles of road in the Interstate Highway System, the gas tax has been stuck at 18.4 cents a gallon since 1993 — the longest it’s ever gone without an increase.

Meanwhile, the cost of roadbuilding has gone up, while more fuel-efficient vehicles mean less revenue.

Right now, to channel Spock, is a logical time to raise the fuel tax.

Instead of doing the logical thing and raising the fuel tax — and indexing it to inflation so we don’t just end up in this same spot a decade or two from now — politicians have come up with just about every cockamamie scheme you can imagine. Soak the rich. Get corporations to quit parking their profits overseas. Turn highways over to private companies and create more toll roads. Get the federal government out of road-building altogether and let the states worry about it.

Some politicians, such as Sens. John Thune, Orrin Hatch and Jim Inhofe, have left the door open — or perhaps cracked is a better description. They carefully call it a “user fee” to deal with the people who hear the word “tax” and automatically stick their fingers in their ears and start shouting “la la la la la” like a 5-year-old.

Instead of doing the logical thing and raising the fuel tax, politicians have come up with just about every cockamamie scheme you can imagine. 

Even more logical would be a vehicle-miles traveled tax — excuse me, user fee — to address issues such as the fact that more fuel efficient vehicles aren’t paying their fair share. But if we can’t get a bipartisan support to simply increase an existing and well-understood tax, forget trying to get Congress to agree on a more complex VMT system that would rely on technology and raise privacy concerns.

In the meantime, no matter what you call it, the seemingly logical solution of raising the per-gallon user fee, aka fuel tax, remains a tough sell on Capitol Hill, despite the current low fuel prices.

There are many roadblocks to what should be a no-brainer, including opposition from swing-state GOP senators up for reelection in 2016, and a well-financed offensive from groups backed by the conservative Koch brothers’ political muscle.

Then there’s the skepticism, to put it mildly, of GOP leaders in both chambers.

Even most Democrats are lukewarm on the idea at best. President Obama has opposed raising fuel taxes in the past, citing the negative impact on consumers in tough economic times. That might have been understandable during the biggest economic downturn the country had seen since the Great Depression. But with the economy unquestionably on the rebound and fuel prices at the lowest seen in years, that negative impact would be far less today.

Yet the White House has refused to endorse calls to bring fuel taxes in line with today’s costs for road and bridge construction and upkeep, sticking with its original plan to finance new infrastructure spending with revenue supposedly gained by closing tax loopholes that favor the wealthy.

It may have made sense during the recession to avoid putting extra financial stress on struggling citizens, but the situation has changed. Refusing to acknowledge that and support a simple user-fee option is, as Spock would say, “highly illogical.”

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Fleet Management

Illustration of map with GPS markers overlaid with Geotab fleet card and a fuel pump nozzle
Fuel Smarts•by Staff•October 2, 2026

Geotab Links Fleet Card to Vehicle Data

The new card combines fuel discounts with telematics-based purchase controls. Geotab’s analysis also points to potential savings from choosing lower-priced fuel stops.

Read More →
Cyberstop column illustration showing multi factor authorization
Fleet Management•September 29, 2026

How MFA Helps Protect Trucking Fleets

Multi-factor authentication adds protection when passwords are stolen. Here’s how it works and where fleets should start.

Read More →
Three generic semi-trucks break through a fractured wall against a dark blue digital background, symbolizing trucking technology overcoming data silos.
Fleet Management•September 28, 2026

How Better Freight Data Helps Trucking Teams Get Ahead of Disruption

Trucking and logistics teams have plenty of data. The problem is getting the right information in front of the right people soon enough to act. Better-connected data can help teams spot trouble earlier and make smarter decisions before small problems become big ones.

Read More →
Photo of man in collared buttoned shirt speaking on stage in front of a backdrop that says Trimble
Fleet Management•by Deborah Lockridge•September 28, 2026

Trimble: Taking Artificial Intelligence in Trucking Beyond Faster Tasks

At Insight 2026, Trimble executives argued that fleets may need to redesign workflows to get more from AI as it introduced new products and enhancements. AI’s value will depend on how fleets combine automation with their people's knowledge.

Read More →
Geotab Whitepaper Data Tells the Story.  Why ELD Dash Cam belong together
Sponsored•September 28, 2026

Build a bulletproof fleet: Uniting ELDs and dash cams for total compliance

An ELD can prove compliance, but it cannot always prove what happened on the road. Discover how uniting accurate ELD data with AI-powered dash cam video can help your fleet strengthen compliance, defend against liability, protect drivers and reduce operational costs.

Read More →
Illustration showing ladders against a blue background with Heavy Duty Trucking Emerging Leaders logo and the words "2026 nominations now open"
Fleet Management•by Staff•September 21, 2026

Nominations Open for HDT Emerging Leaders

Heavy Duty Trucking is looking for accomplished trucking fleet professionals under 40 who are making an impact and helping lead the industry forward.

Read More →
Illustration of Penske day cab backed into loading dock with graphic of generic charts and graphs and a penske logo.
Fleet Management•by Deborah Lockridge•September 17, 2026

Why Private Fleets Are Taking More Freight

Private fleets are putting their own trucks on demanding customers and high-cost lanes as companies seek greater control over service, costs, and capacity.

Read More →
A woman holding a tablet with a screen showing rectangles of various colors
Sponsored•September 16, 2026

Color Match Smarter: Tools That Restore & Perform

For fleet managers and collision repair professionals keeping heavy-duty trucks on the road, getting the color right the first time isn't just about appearance — it's about efficiency, turnaround time, and bottom-line results. Discover how today's digital color tools are transforming the repair process from guesswork to precision.

Read More →
Mobile tablet showing Motus screen against highway background with Motus logo
Fleet Management•by Staff•September 15, 2026

FMCSA Pauses Biennial-Update Enforcement Amid Motus Transition

Carriers whose updates were due on or after June 1 have more time, while FMCSA works to stabilize its new registration system and warns of phishing sites impersonating its new carrier registration system, Motus.

Read More →
Geotab Whitepaper Cargo Theft Cover
Sponsored•September 14, 2026

2026 Blueprint for Countering Smarter Supply Chain Theft

Cargo theft is no longer just the cost of doing business. It's a multi-billion-dollar criminal enterprise exploiting vulnerabilities across your fleet, drivers, and supply chain.

Read More →