3 Things to be Ready for in a Coercion Complaint Investigation
While following up on driver coercion complaints, DOT auditors may not be finding the coercion claimed, but they are finding other issues that are causing conditional ratings and fines.
by Don Jerrell, HNI
September 13, 2016
Photo by Jim Park
4 min to read
Photo by Jim Park
The driver coercion rule that went into effect earlier this year has changed the focus for the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration: It has caused them to move complaints from the bottom of their list to the top. While following up on these complaints, they may not be finding the coercion claimed, but they are finding issues that are causing conditional ratings and fines.
Ad Loading...
So just because your CSA scores are good doesn't mean you can let your guard down. Fleets need to remain focused on having the processes and procedures in place to ensure they are compliant.
Ad Loading...
Generally, the hours of service tend to be the greatest focus of these coercion complaint follow-ups, just as they are in compliance and focused reviews). You need to make sure that you are paying close attention to supporting documents with respect to time and date.
Another area where fleets often get dinged -- fuel reports vs. fuel receipts. Banking laws require that the time of transaction be recorded for fuel purchases. If your report does not have the time recorded, you need to contact your supplier and make sure your reports have this information (otherwise FMCSA will certainly do it for you when they come in.) Information from your GPS systems will be used to cross reference with driver log information. If you're on e-logs it's still an issue – you may have settings that allow trucks to move without showing driving time on your devices, but the GPS shows the truck is moving.
Now is the time to start preparing for a potential CSA visit. Here are three "hot" items that you will want to make sure you are prepared to address:
1. Check your e-log settings
Set your AOBRDs (automatic onboard recording devices, the official designation for pre-ELD-rule e-logs) to the same settings as those for the new federal standard for electronic logging devices. We are seeing carriers get hit for violations when the GPS shows the truck moving, but the log generated by the AOBRD does not show it. Many AOBRDs allow for a speed and distance setting before the system starts counting drive time, but some carriers have settings as much as 20 mph or 1 mile. Simply put, ELDs will be set at 5 mph with no distance setting. You may be thinking, I am at a facility that is a mile long and didn’t want to burn driving time. Remember that if a facility is not gated, guarded, or posted, then it is not considered a yard, it is dubbed highway and you cannot use "yard time" at these facilities.
2. Pay attention to DVIRs
This is an area that historically has not garnered much attention. Previously, it was difficult to make a case and also took a lot of time and effort for every driver to fill out a driver vehicle inspection report each day of operation. This has changed in the last year when the FMCSA decided to only require a DVIR to be filled out when something was amiss.
Ad Loading...
Now that non-violation DVIRs are no longer included, it is much easier to find a greater than 10% violation. For example, if during the last 90 days you had 30 DVIRs listed with violations, the auditor only needs to find four occurrences of non-compliance in the last 90 days to make a case against a carrier.
Some items you will want to make sure you are monitoring and enforcing:
Cross reference roadside inspections (that have maintenance items listed) against the driver’s DVIR. Remember the regulation requires the driver to list anything they had discovered or "had been notified" on their DVIR (a roadside inspection report listing an issue would certainly qualify as notified). You can be sure that the auditor will have inspections when they visit.
Train your shop to notify safety whenever they see or work on something the driver should have been aware of. Also, make sure you cross reference with the driver's DVIR. The maintenance records are not used as much as the roadsides, but can certainly be used if the auditor were to choose so.
If your internal system has "breakdown" reports or anything along those lines, make sure you cross reference those with the driver's DVIR.
3. Miles without hours and editing reports
You need to have a process to ensure that these are held to a minimum and to ensure that people within your organization are not misusing or abusing the system.
Simply having a good CSA score does not mean you are off the hook. Make sure your AOBRDs and ELDs line up to ensure you remain compliant.
Ad Loading...
Adapted from the "Steal These Ideas" blog by HNI, a non-traditional insurance and business advisory firm. Used with permission.
Aperia Technologies introduced a new automatic tire inflation system for steer axles and a partnership with Fontaine Fifth Wheel to integrate coupling status into its Halo Connect platform.
Fleetworthy and HAAS Alert expanded their partnership to deliver real-time digital alerts that warn motorists when commercial trucks are stopped roadside and notify truck drivers when approaching emergency responders.
More than 100,000 new trucking companies enter the industry each year, but regulators manage to audit only a fraction of them. That churn creates opportunities for inexperienced startups — and for “chameleon carriers” that shut down after safety violations and reappear under new identities. Read more from Deborah Lockridge in this commentary.
Mack Trucks has expanded its proprietary Mack Protect collision mitigation platform to the Mack MD Series, bringing heavy-duty safety technology to medium-duty trucks operating in urban and regional environments.
In today’s cost-conscious market, fleets are finding new ways to get more value from every truck on the road. See how smarter maintenance strategies can boost uptime, control costs and drive stronger long-term returns.
Two Canadian fleets earned the Grand Prize in the Truckload Carriers Association’s 2025 Fleet Safety Awards, recognizing the industry’s top safety performance based on accident frequency and safety programs.
New guidance for commercial vehicle inspectors distinguishes between more traditional logbook violations and tampered ELD data that can result in mandatory 10-hour out-of-service orders.
Daimler’s new factory-installed system integrates side and forward-facing cameras with in-cab touchscreen to improve jobsite visibility and reduce upfit complexity.
Kodiak has integrated HAAS Alert’s Safety Cloud platform into its autonomous vehicle control system to send real-time digital hazard alerts to nearby motorists.