From the HDT Archives: Are You on Top of Your Fuel-Buying Program?
3 Former Pilot Flying J Execs Sentenced in Fuel Rebate Fraud
A ‘hypercompetitive’ culture at Pilot Flying J contributed to a fuel-tax-fraud scheme, said one of three more former executives who have been sentenced to jail for their part.

Fleets targeted in the scam expected larger diesel fuel rebates from Pilot Flying J than they actually received.
HDT file photo
Three more former Pilot Flying J executives will spend time behind bars over their roles in in a fraud scheme that cheated trucking companies out of millions of dollars of promised fuel rebates.
"Our culture at the very top was to be hyper-competitive," former executive John "Stick" Freeman told the federal judge, according to a report on Knoxnews.com, admitting that he let it go too far.
Freeman and Brian Mosher were sentenced to two-and-a-half years in prison, while Vicki Borden received a two-year sentence. Freeman and Mosher must each pay a $100,000 fine, and Borden a $75,000 fine. The judge said he was lenient because the three pleaded guilty early in the case and handed over evidence to prosecutors.
Former Pilot president Mark Hazelwood will spend 12-and-a-half years in prison for overseeing the scheme. A federal jury convicted Hazelwood in February of wire fraud, witness tampering and conspiracy to commit wire fraud.
Mosher, a former regional sales director, testified at Hazelwood’s trial, and got the lightest sentence in exchange.
As Knoxnews reports:
Freeman, Pilot's former vice president of sales, began defrauding trucking companies as early as 2007. He bragged shamelessly about the fraud to bosses, employees and trainees, court records show - including at meetings recorded by an undercover FBI informant.
The fraud case dates back to 2012, when the FBI discovered that Pilot Flying J sales employees were operating a fuel-rebate scam that victimized trucking companies. The trucking companies were promised certain amounts back in rebates, but sales staff would reduce the amount at a later date to increase profits. Because of the complexities of the fuel buying market, most did not realize they were being shorted the promised rebates.
The FBI found that over the course of several years, Pilot Flying J defrauded as many as 5,500 customers of more than $56 million in owed rebates that were not paid.
Nineteen executives and staffers of the truck stop giant have either admitted or been convicted by a jury of participating in the fraud scheme. Fourteen pleaded guilty, three were convicted, and two were granted immunity.
Pilot Flying J’s board of directors has admitted criminal responsibility and paid a settlement for the fraud. Pilot CEO Jimmy Haslam has denied knowledge of the scheme and has never been charged.
More Fuel Smarts

Trucking’s Diesel Squeeze Isn’t Letting Up
With diesel topping $6 a gallon nationally, ATA's Bob Costello explains why fleets should prepare for continued pressure at the pump.
Read More →
FlowBelow Redesigns Trailer AeroSlider to Cut Fuel Use
The lighter trailer aerodynamic system installs in less than 45 minutes, according to the company, with potential payback in under a year depending on fuel prices and trailer mileage.
Read More →
Why Diesel Price Relief Efforts May Fall Short
Diesel prices have eased from September’s record high, but doubts about additional Russian supply and limits on dyed-diesel tax relief mean trucking fleets still face expensive fuel. And prices could go higher.
Read More →Why Small Fuel Savings Matter in Trucking
Can better fuel economy help pay for driver raises? In this podcast, GP Transco explains how small efficiency gains create room to reinvest in its people.
Read More →How GP Transco Cuts Trucking Fuel Costs, a Tenth of a Gallon at a Time
What’s another tenth of a mile per gallon worth? GP Transco shares how equipment upgrades and driver coaching turn small gains into meaningful fuel savings.
Read More →
Electric Yard Tractors Move Beyond Pilots
Operating-cost savings have overtaken sustainability goals as the leading reason surveyed fleets are adopting battery-electric terminal tractors, according to new NACFE research.
Read More →
Geotab Links Fleet Card to Vehicle Data
The new card combines fuel discounts with telematics-based purchase controls. Geotab’s analysis also points to potential savings from choosing lower-priced fuel stops.
Read More →
Fleet Economics Shape Electric Truck Outlook
ACT Research expects costs, charging infrastructure, and technology improvements to drive zero-emission commercial vehicle adoption as federal regulations and incentives retreat.
Read More →
Wex Adds Cardless Fuel Payments for Over-the-Road Customers
A new fuel card feature for Wex customers offers convenience and security.
Read More →
New California Law Could Shed Light on Electric Truck Prices
Why do battery-electric Class 8 trucks remain so expensive? A California bill signed by Gov. Gavin Newsom would give fleets and state agencies more visibility into what manufacturers charge.
Read More →
