Article

How Simulators Can Help Save Fuel

Driving simulators aren't just for new drivers or safety training.

November 2014, TruckingInfo.com - Department

by Deborah Lockridge, Editor-in-Chief - Also by this author

SHARING TOOLS        | Print Subscribe
In this Eco-Drive challenge program, you can see the driver accelerating gradually while the non-fuel-saving-truck on the left has raced ahead to the next light. Look at the red arrow below the truck graphic on the left that indicates the energy being wasted in hard braking.
In this Eco-Drive challenge program, you can see the driver accelerating gradually while the non-fuel-saving-truck on the left has raced ahead to the next light. Look at the red arrow below the truck graphic on the left that indicates the energy being wasted in hard braking.

When the City of Waterloo in Ontario conducted a four-month trial of a fuel-efficient driver training program, it was able to improve the score among the 20 test vehicles by 17%. A simulator program from Virage Simulation taught drivers to reduce harsh acceleration and harsh braking.

During the initial phase of the project, which set a baseline via a telematics system, vehicle operators exhibited hard accelerating events 8% of the time they accelerated and hard braking events 15% of the time they stopped. After their eco-driver training experience, these metrics improved to only 5% and 9%, respectively.

According to the Environmental Protection Agency’s SmartWay Transport Partnership, a driver training program that improves fuel economy by 5% could save over $3,000 in fuel costs and eliminate 8 metric tons of greenhouse gas emissions per truck each year.

But you may not have the extra capacity to be able to offer on-the-road training. And while classroom training is valuable, driving simulators offer another, more interactive level of training.

Training that targets fuel efficiency can help drivers recognize and change driving habits that waste fuel. For example, driving 65 mph instead of 55 mph can use up to 20% more fuel, and driving with the engine rpm too high can waste several gallons of fuel each hour. Other common habits that reduce fuel economy are frequent or improper shifting, too-rapid acceleration, too-frequent stops and starts from failing to anticipate traffic flow, and taking circuitous routes.

“Fuel-efficient shifting techniques are best taught with a simulator,” says Greg Collins, contracts/marketing manager for Doron Precision Systems. “You won’t waste any fuel or grind up any clutches in a simulation lab!”

Simulators help drivers learn proper shifting techniques without the fear of damaging equipment, points out Mike Speers, manager of business development for DriveWise Canada. “Proper shifting and acceleration can lead to greater fuel efficiency. We also have an interface that provides a graphic representation of a driver’s fuel consumption and correlates it to his/her driving habits. For example, improper use of eye lead time results in hard braking, and rapid acceleration is often the follow on reaction. Our interface shows the correlation of these behaviors and fuel consumption.”

In addition to being able to teach fuel-efficient driving techniques in the simulator, doing simulator training saves fuel in and of itself compared to using the real truck, Collins points out.

“One can train up to four drivers at the same time in a simulation system, which is impossible on the road. That’s a serious cut in fuel consumption.”

Virage says research using its Eco-Drive Pro program found that it can improve driver fuel efficiency between 4-24% after training.

“The program is designed for drivers with years, even decades, of experience behind the wheel,” explains Virage President Remi Quimper. “We don’t tell the drivers what to do, but help them understand the physics behind fuel consumption. Instead of telling you what to do, we make you aware of what your fuel consumption is, and why is your truck or vehicle consuming fuel.

“The simulator is the only way we can see these forces in real time and how they interact with each other.”

Virage’s chief software architect, Danny Grenier, demonstrated the Eco-Drive simulation at the American Trucking Associations’ recent Management Conference and Exhibition. He emphasizes that it is “based on the physics of the vehicle, and not someone’s opinion of how we save fuel,” he said.

The simulation graphically illustrates the forces acting upon the vehicle that affect its fuel use — gravity, acceleration, aerodynamics, the engine, braking, and rolling resistance.

In a challenge mode in a city driving situation, the trainee competes against a computer-generated typical driver who jackrabbits off from stoplights and races ahead to the next, wasting fuel all the way. Grenier, however, accelerates and brakes gently and gradually, and tries to maintain his speed in a way as to avoid having to stop at the next light. 

“You adapt your speed to the traffic around you, the lights in front of you,” he explains.

By the end of the short test route, he’s achieved 5.4 mpg compared to the other driver’s 2.4 mpg — using nearly 57% less fuel. A summary readout highlights how much fuel was consumed by the various physical factors mentioned. Acceleration, braking and engine performance were all significantly better.

When training a driver, the simulator program starts with a pre-evaluation of the driver’s eco-driving skills. After training, a final evaluation will measure the improvement in fuel consumption.

“Say a driver can use these techniques at 10% of stoplights,” Grenier says. “At the end of the day that adds up to significant fuel savings for a fleet.” 

Comments

  1. 1. João Simões [ November 14, 2014 @ 09:37AM ]

    The conclusions do not differ from what I reach in 1984 during the devepment of CARRIS (Portugal-Lisbon Bus Company) program to reduce fuel consumption; the bst result was less 25%. The drivers say that a not-in-service situation is very diferente fron on-service and so they explain why that tarjet in not accomplished. Some years later we eqquiped two buses to make the same line running one after the other; in the second a Monitor was presente given the driver some tips; the diffference was 14%. My conclusion is that the vehicles should be eqquiped with devices that register all the data that is necessary to show the drives what they should do better. Of course the use of simulators is very importnt for other reasons.

  2. 2. João Simões [ November 14, 2014 @ 09:45AM ]

    To complete my previous comment I must say that it is not only the driver that has something to do about reducing fuel consumption: the way Operators specify the vehicles - in a chassi we can find 2 engins, 2 geraboxes and 5 rear axle relations, so 20 diferente vehicles - the way they plan and do the maintenance work and the way they manage the fleet upon the services - choose the vehicle to do each servisse, having in consideration the load factor, choose the roads to use, having in mind average speed. The Managers also have a big influenv«ce on fuel consumption and it should not be put in a second row.

 

Comment On This Story

Name:  
Email:  
Comment: (Maximum 2000 characters)  
Leave this field empty:
* Please note that every comment is moderated.

Newsletter

We offer e-newsletters that deliver targeted news and information for the entire fleet industry.

GotQuestions?
sponsored by
sponsor logo

ELDs and Telematics

Scott Sutarik from Geotab will answer your questions and challenges

View All
GotQuestions?

Sleeper Cab Power

Steve Carlson from Xantrex will answer your questions and challenges

View All