CVSA Cites FMCSA for Burdensome Exemptions

February 24, 2016

By David Cullen

SHARING TOOLS        | Print Subscribe
Photo: U.S. Department of Transportation
Photo: U.S. Department of Transportation

The Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance has taken to task the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration for unduly burdening roadside inspectors by issuing carriers and drivers too many safety-rule exemptions. 

“Recently, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration has issued notices of final disposition that hinder the roadside inspector while conducting inspections,” stated Collin Mooney, CVSA executive director, in a Feb. 18 letter to Scott Darling, FMCSA’s acting administrator. 

He went on to point out that in the past year, over 20 exemption applications or renewal requests were granted.

These included final rules exempting vehicle equipment, such as mounting of video devices to windshields and the transportation of metal coils, along with several affecting drivers, including records of duty status exemptions and exempting certain drivers from having to obtain a CDL. 

“Due to the amount of exemptions allowed by FMCSA in the past year,” Mooney continued, “an excessive burden is being placed on inspectors to ensure all active exemptions are being followed properly. Furthermore, this puts an undue training burden on agencies that must be diligent in informing all inspectors of the new exemptions and ensuring they understand and apply the exemptions properly.” 

Mooney contended that allowing “such a large number of exemptions” puts in jeopardy “the likelihood of achieving a level of safety equivalent to, or greater than, the level that is expected by the current regulation.”

He wrote that with so many exemptions, beyond those within the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations, “it is possible that roadside inspectors will no longer accurately enforce the regulations, or may stop enforcing certain regulations all together.”

Mooney added that inspectors “must be able to perform their duties without the apprehension that one of these exemptions will be overlooked, and a driver or vehicle placed out of service notwithstanding an obscure exemption, or an exemption being given to a driver or vehicle that is not in the exemption group. 

CVSA does not object to the exemptions on an individual basis, he pointed out, but holds that “exemptions complicate the enforcement process, causing confusion and inconsistency…  which undermines the very foundation of the federal commercial motor vehicle enforcement program— uniformity. The regulations are only effective if they are clear and enforceable.” 

Mooney said the alliance also wants to “further encourage” FMCSA to “invite to the table” state and local inspection/enforcement partners when working on new or updated regulations and/or exemptions. 

FMCSA Spokesman Duane DeBruyne told HDT that CVSA’s letter was under review by the agency.


  1. 1. Scot Fletcher [ February 25, 2016 @ 04:46AM ]

    Those poor little inspectors. Tell me they are not over burden by regulations making it more difficult to do their job. Sounds like drivers and inspectors have something in common.The focus should be on safety overall and proper training of inspectors. Drivers have little to no recourse against violations or so called violations on an inspection imposed by over zealous inspectors on a power trip. My 2 cents for the day. Have a safe day and Blessed day.

  2. 2. Ronny Prewitt [ February 25, 2016 @ 05:18PM ]

    I have to agree with you Scot. For years the drivers have been loaded with more and more regulations. It's never gone well for a driver that said, there's just too many rules officer, I overlooked the fact I was supposed to put that little dot on there to make it an i. It's always been, well driver, it's your responsibility to know the rules. Ignorance is no excuse they'd say.

  3. 3. MC [ March 02, 2016 @ 08:39AM ]

    The issue isn't the rules, it's the special exemptions that a few people/companies get that complicate the rules and make enforcing the rules difficult.
    Here's a thought FMCSA, how about making anyone that has an exemption have to carry exemption documentation at all times when the exemption is applicable? That way, the inspectors can inspect everything the same way unless such documentation is presented at the time of inspection. Put the burden on those that are bribing Congressman for these special exemptions rather than on the people that are actually working and have to deal with dozens of drivers and/or companies every day trying to skirt the rules. The inspectors' jobs are stressful enough as it is having to deal with angry drivers on a daily basis that think they're the devil, and many more that can't even speak English.

  4. 4. Chuck [ March 27, 2016 @ 06:15PM ]

    If you have the $$$$$$ to pay off the gov't.....bam you get an exemption. This is across the board what's wrong with this Damn country !!!
    Freaking corruption !!!


Comment On This Story

Comment: (Maximum 2000 characters)  
Leave this field empty:
* Please note that every comment is moderated.


We offer e-newsletters that deliver targeted news and information for the entire fleet industry.


ELDs and Telematics

sponsored by
sponsor logo

Scott Sutarik from Geotab will answer your questions and challenges

View All

Sleeper Cab Power

Steve Carlson from Xantrex will answer your questions and challenges

View All