Survey: Electronic Logs Don't Lead to More Driver Harassment

November 13, 2014

By Oliver Patton

SHARING TOOLS        | Print Subscribe

Few truck drivers feel they are harassed by their employers or shippers, and drivers who use electronic logs experience no more harassment than those who use paper logs.

Those are the key findings of a survey by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration in response to concerns that harassment will increase under the pending electronic logging device mandate.

“The evidence in this survey research does not support concluding that harassment occurs due to being in a situation where [hours of service] are logged using ELDs,” the agency said.

The agency conducted the survey as part of its preparation for an ELD mandate that is expected next year. The rule will require most drivers to eventually switch from paper to electronic logs. It will set standards for the devices and the supporting documents that regulators need to confirm compliance, as well as protect drivers from harassment.

The research was triggered specifically by a 2011 court ruling that said the agency needed to consider the possibility of harassment under the ELD mandate.

The agency surveyed and interviewed drivers and carriers, asking about the type and frequency of their interactions. The drivers were given a list of 14 kinds of interactions that could be considered harassment, and were asked how they viewed them.

Fewer than 30% of the drivers considered any of the interactions to be harassment, and 42% said none of them were.

The interactions most likely to be considered harassment were interruption during off-duty time (28%), asking the driver to work when he felt tired (28%) and asking the driver to falsify his logs in order to work longer or delay a break (26%).

“Few drivers experience regular interactions with their carriers that they consider to be harassment,” the agency said.

For instance, 7% of the drivers had their off-duty time interrupted two or more times a month, and 1% reported being asked to change their log in order to work longer.

The carrier interviews backed up the drivers’ perception that harassment is not widespread, the agency said.

For instance, 5% of the carriers said that on average they ask a fatigued driver to work once a month, and 2% said they do it twice a month.

Perceptions of harassment were generally the same no matter which logging method the driver used. There were differences in perceived harassment between paper logs and ELDs, but they were not statistically significant, the agency said.

“Two percent of drivers experienced an interaction that they considered to be harassment and that they associated with the HOS-logging capabilities of the ELD.”

The agency found that drivers on electronic logs do have different experiences in some respects. They are more likely to be paid for customer delays, and to have management ask customers to adjust schedules for the driver’s sake.

But the ELD drivers also were more likely to be required to wait between loads for more than two hours without pay, and to be interrupted when off-duty.

The survey found drivers generally are positive about the way ELDs can cut their paperwork, but some believe the devices reduce their independence and give management too much information about how they spend their time.


  1. 1. Roger wessels [ November 14, 2014 @ 04:17AM ]

    You will see a lot of drivers quite driving if the e logs go into effect.the only drivers you ask are new drivers that only been in trucking for a short time start asking the old truck drivers

  2. 2. Ken Moon [ November 14, 2014 @ 04:34AM ]

    I agree Roger, They only ask the retards that have been taught to like them. That is the way our profession is being ruined!

  3. 3. Shawn [ November 14, 2014 @ 09:14AM ]

    I am the director of Safety for a trucking company and have heard several discussions on this subject and I have attend most DOT/ FMCSA council meetings on this subject. The one think that is apparent in all of the meetings is this, they are going to incorporate electronic logging into the industry weather it is liked or not. Just like the switch to the CDL back in 1992, it is designed to get the "rogue" drivers off the road and was quite effective in doing so. We have many drivers in our fleet and even the "old School' drivers here have seen the benefit of the ELD. They are no longer able to run over HOS due to the fact that the dispatcher before dispatching a load with the driver can check how many HOS they have left for the week and the day. My driver's did push back a little in the beginning but have found that the technology that has been implemented is beneficial to them as-well. I was a driver for 27 years and then moved into the safety realm of the industry, this gives me a unique perspective and I can see the pros and cons on both sides clearly.

  4. 4. chris [ November 15, 2014 @ 05:46AM ]

    I have been driving for 22 years and been using electronic logs for the last 2 years and i love them. I get plenty of sleep and dispatch can no longer give me a thousand mile overnight run and then expect me to legally log it. As far as the dot at weigh stations i havent had my logs examined since I got that little sticker on the side of the truck

  5. 5. Thomas Duncan [ December 11, 2014 @ 03:41AM ]

    Harrassment is not the issue.The real issue is that when you put inexperienced people in a truck and put them on a clock that is unforgiving it creates a problem,major safety problem.This is not a factory 9-5 job damn it!Right now you have this going on.Drivers are racing the clock....driving tired and trying to go without stopping no matter what or what the traffic situation is.It is stupid all of it.And for these fools who say they like e logs,Let us see how you like it when all the controls are connected together....GPS non tamper abilities ect...It makes no sense to truckers!


Comment On This Story

Comment: (Maximum 2000 characters)  
Leave this field empty:
* Please note that every comment is moderated.


We offer e-newsletters that deliver targeted news and information for the entire fleet industry.


ELDs and Telematics

sponsored by
sponsor logo

Scott Sutarik from Geotab will answer your questions and challenges

View All

Sleeper Cab Power

Steve Carlson from Xantrex will answer your questions and challenges

View All