Another Owner-Operator Suit Filed Against Pilot Flying J

June 4, 2013

By Evan Lockridge

SHARING TOOLS        | Print Subscribe

Another lawsuit has been filed against truckstop chain Pilot Flying J in the wake of two guilty pleas in an apparent scheme to cheat customers out of fuel rebates, this one coming from an owner-operator trucker.

Attorneys for Nebraska-based trucker Paul Otto have filed a federal class action in Nashville charging that Pilot Flying J fraudulently withheld tens of millions of dollars in diesel fuel price rebates and discounts from customers over the past eight years. This is believed to be the second lawsuit coming from a truck driver.

The suit alleges that in order to increase the company's profits and the sales commission of Pilot Flying J employees, company employees intentionally defrauded customers by withholding diesel fuel price rebates and discounts, which resulted in customers paying higher diesel fuel prices. Pilot Flying J salespersons allegedly took advantage of customers whom they deemed unsophisticated and unlikely to catch fuel rebate and discount errors.

The complaint further alleges that Pilot Flying J secretly conducted the diesel fuel rebate scheme for years. Managers and executives at the highest level of the company were aware of the diesel fuel rebate scheme, the complaint charges.

Otto is described by the Cleveland Plain Dealer newspaper as being leased to W.N. Morehouse Truckline, based in Omaha. The carrier was one of those named in an FBI affidavit as having been cheated, allegedly by around $140,000.

The suit is nearly identical to many of the around one-dozen that have been filed since FBI and IRS raided the Knoxville-headquarters of Pilot Flying J in mid-April as part of its investigation into these allegations. CEO Jimmy Haslam has denied any wrongdoing. Two employees last week pleaded guilty to charges over their involvement, but have yet to be sentenced.

The Knoxville News Sentinel newspaper reports prosecutors are looking one of those who pleaded guilty, account representative Ashley Judd, as a “star witness” in its pursuit of company higher-ups.

Judd reportedly worked for the company since 2009 after serving as an intern while in high school and college. She is said to have provided written information to investigators about the alleged scheme and helped show agents around company headquarters when it was raided as part of their evidentiary search.


  1. 1. John Diamondidis [ June 05, 2013 @ 04:03AM ]

    This is a crime that not only happens to truckers but anywhere you may have a corporate account that does not require a credit card. There are still gas stations that have a system where you fill your tank and they put it on your account and you settle at the end of the month.. There are quite a few that overcharge the quantity of gas you pump. Suggestion: Be as diligent as possible in getting reciepts - ensuring the proper amount is on the reciept and that the recorded price is what you are supposed to pay per gallon. GOOD LUCK, by the way - if the gas receipt is hand written and you cannot read it - tell them to write you another receipt and YOU destroy both copies of the illegible one.


Comment On This Story

Comment: (Maximum 2000 characters)  
Leave this field empty:
* Please note that every comment is moderated.


We offer e-newsletters that deliver targeted news and information for the entire fleet industry.


ELDs and Telematics

sponsored by
sponsor logo

Scott Sutarik from Geotab will answer your questions and challenges

View All

Sleeper Cab Power

Steve Carlson from Xantrex will answer your questions and challenges

View All