Freight Volume Should Grow 5.5% This Year
March 13, 2000
According to our data, freight volume should expand 5.5% this year. Because last year's big 7% gain came at the end of the year, the 5.5% annual forecast will be hit if the four quarters this year have an average annual growth rate of only 4.6% compared to 6.6% last year. The current outlook for 2000 is actually 25% higher than the predictions were at the beginning of the year.
The 5.5% growth rate assumes a 3.8% growth in annual GDP for the whole economy. GDP growth has been underestimated at the beginning of each of the last three years by 25%. If it happens again, the pace of growth in freight volume will push close to last years' pace. Capacity will be strained even more, the driver shortage will worsen and diesel prices will keep rising.
With hindsight, we now know that buyer confidence and labor productivity gains have been underestimated over the past three years. And the aggressiveness of the Fed in fighting inflation has been overestimated.
The consensus outlook is for consumer and business confidence to drop from 1999's record high levels. But there is no evidence of this yet, except among homebuilders. The sluggishness in overall stock prices and the extra $40 billion we have to pay for oil products this year have not yet had any negative impact on confidence.
Labor productivity increased 3.1% last year after a 2% gain the previous year and increases closer to 1% earlier in the decade. Here is the arithmetic: as long as demand is sufficient with high buyer confidence, the GDP growth rate approximately equals the sum of labor productivity growth plus the percentage increase in employment minus 1%. For 1999, 3.1% productivity gains plus 2.2% growth in employment minus 1% equal 4.3%. GDP grew 4.0%.
The outlook is for either labor productivity growth to be slightly lower or for job gains to be slightly lower as the fed tightens credit and reduces demand. If neither happens, freight volume will expand one percentage point higher - 5.6% instead of 4.6%. Productivity gains in the last quarter of 1999 were at a 6.1% annual rate, double the average for the year. If you believe productivity is still rising, add 0.3 percentage points to freight volume growth for every 0.2 percentage point in productivity growth beyond 3.1%.
How plausible is this? The productivity report for the last quarter showed a 10% annual rate gain in durable manufacturing. Productivity in this sector has been running at about a 7% pace for several years as manufacturers incorporated electronic technology into their products. The surprising news is that the larger non-durable manufacturing sector also had 10% productivity growth after averaging 3-4% in recent years.
Food, apparel and chemical manufacturers cannot design semiconductors into their products but now they can use the Internet to cut planning, transactions and distribution costs. Cost savings as high as 20% are being realized.
Finally, the Fed has been very timid raising interest rates to make a preemptive strike against inflation because they have not yet seen the enemy. None of the various indexes available to measure inflation has shown a sustained rise in inflation. All of the precursors of inflation have appeared but so far their impact has been offset by soaring productivity.