Owner-operators believe the costs of EOBRs may outweigh the benefits. (Photo by Teletrac)

The Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association has challenged the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration's electronic onboard recorder rule with a petition filed in the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. Earlier this month, the group submitted the petition, contesting the agency's new rule requiring carriers that violate hours of service 10 percent of the time to use EOBRs to track driver hours, according to published reports.

The rule, which will go into effect June 1, 2012, will impact close to 5,700 interstate carriers after its first year of implementation.

The FMCSA says it will consider a broader EOBR mandate in the future, and the agency is already working on this.

Under the current rule, carriers that violate the standard will have to install recorders on all of their trucks, regardless of when the truck was built, and use the recorders to track driver hours for at least two years. There will be an exception for carriers that install automatic onboard recorders before the compliance review finds them in violation.

The OOIDA is questioning whether the costs of installing EOBRs outweigh the benefits, according to published reports.

Todd Spencer, executive vice president of the OOIDA, said owner-operators don't think the rule is necessary. "We will point out that we've never seen a correlation between onboard recorders and improved highway safety," Spencer said. "I don't think that's going to change."






Government/Regulations: Related News

9/2/2010 - Pennsylvania to Step Up Roadside Inspections of Waste Haulers
Pennsylvania's Department of Environmental Protection and State Police have plans to step up inspections of waste haulers, with increased funding in the year ahead.... More >

9/1/2010 - Safety Advisors Suggest Reducing In-Cab Distractions
Distracted driving is best countered by a wide-ranging effort to instill a culture of safety among all drivers, but in trucking specifically it would be helpful to reduce in-cab distractions, says a committee of safety experts.... More >

9/1/2010 - California Approves Amended Copper Bill
The California Assembly has passed SB 346 this week, which restricts the amount of copper in brake friction material sold in the state.... More >

8/31/2010 - FMCSA Seeks Industry Feedback
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration said it will hold a public listening session to get feedback on key challenges facing the motor carrier industry, issues facing stakeholders and concerns that should be considered by the agency in developing its next five-year strategic plan.... More >

8/30/2010 - White House to Meet with Groups About Truck Buying Incentive
A coalition of trucking groups pushing for a tax break for truckers to buy new trucks are tentatively scheduled to meet with staff members at the White House this week.... More >

8/26/2010 - International Enforcement Effort Cracks Down on Illegal Hazmat Transport
Enforcement agencies across the U.S. and Canada participated in a two-day operation on Aug. 17-18 aimed at cracking down on the illegal transportation of hazardous materials.... More >

8/25/2010 - California Amends Copper Bill Following Negotiations
California has amended a bill that restricts the amount of copper in brake friction material sold in the state, following negotiations between the Motor Equipment Manufacturers Association, environmentalists and automakers.... More >

8/23/2010 - Ohio Governor Proposes Higher Truck Weight Limit
Ohio Gov. Ted Strickland has proposed to increase truck weights on the state's highways to increase exports... More >

8/23/2010 - Nine Charged in CDL Scam in Pennsylvania
A U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania charged nine defendants with knowingly producing, attempting to produce, conspiring to produce and aiding and abetting the production of false Pennsylvania commercial driver's licenses.... More >

8/20/2010 - CARB Pushes Back Hearing on Proposed Amendments; Workshops Added
The California Air Resources Board has postponed the hearing to consider the proposed amendments to the Tractor-Trailer (aerodynamics) Greenhouse Gas Regulation, Truck and Bus (engine) Regulation, and Drayage Truck (engine) Regulation until November 2010.... More >

8/20/2010 - ATA Urges PHMSA to Reconsider Proposed Hazmat Carrier Fitness Rules
In a testimony before the Department of Transportation Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration, American Trucking Associations Vice President Rich Moskowitz told the agency that proposed standards for hazardous material carrier fitness were unacceptable... More >

8/18/2010 - ATA Pushes FMCSA on CSA 2010 Crash Accountability
While the American Trucking Associations has had a positive reaction to the changes the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration made to its CSA 2010 methodology, the group is still pushing the FMCSA to address the issue of crash accountability.... More >

8/17/2010 - A Fifth of Carriers at Risk of Intervention Under CSA 2010
One in five carriers are at risk of an intervention under the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration's new methodology for calculating safety measures under CSA 2010, according to an analysis of safety performance by Rair Technologies.... More >

8/16/2010 - Non-Idaho Carriers See the Benefits of Idaho's Special Trailer Plate
The Idaho Transportation Department says one year after its launch, the North America Permanent Trailer Plate is being well received among non-Idaho customers.... More >

8/16/2010 - Now's the Time to Be Proactive, Not Reactive on CSA 2010
With about four months left until the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration's Comprehensive Safety Analysis 2010 is set to take effect, carriers should take the opportunity to be proactive, not reactive to the new safety plan, said Jim Angel, PeopleNet's safety and compliance product manager. Angel gave fleets tips on how to be more proactive on CSA 2010 during two presentations at PeopleNet's User Conference 2010, held last week in Boca Raton, Fla.... More >

8/16/2010 - DOT to Post Changes in Drug Testing
The Department of Transportation plans to amend some of its rules covering drug and alcohol testing, and training requirements for Medical Review Officers.... More >

8/12/2010 - CSA 2010 Changes Look Promising, Carriers Say
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration appears to have made a good start at correcting shortcomings in its CSA 2010 Safety Measurement System, according to trucking companies that are testing the program.

Preliminary reports from carriers in the states where CSA 2010 is being pilot-tested indicate that safety scores are changing "somewhat dramatically" under revised system, said David Osiecki, senior vice president of Policy and Regulatory Affairs at American Trucking Associations.... More >

8/6/2010 - Congress Joins Fight Over Control of Port Truck Drivers
The fight over control of port truck drivers spilled out of the courtroom into Congress last week when Rep. Jerrold Nadler, D-N.Y., offered a bill that would give ports more authority over drayage operations.

Under current law, states and local authorities such as ports are barred from regulating truck prices, routes or service. Nadler's Clean Ports Act would create an exemption to let these entities set requirements... More >

8/6/2010 - New Legislation Would Allow States to Raise Truck Weight Limits
New legislation introduced in the Senate would allow state Departments of Transportation to raise interstate weight limits to 97,000 pounds for trucks with six axles instead of five.... More >

8/5/2010 - FMCSA Will Open Next Phase of CSA 2010 on Aug. 16
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration will soon take the next step in its rollout of CSA 2010 by offering carriers a glimpse at where they stand in the pending Safety Measurement System.... More >

8/3/2010 - Right to Repair Bill Stalled in Massachusetts House
Following unanimous passage in the state Senate, the Massachusetts House of Representatives took no action on the Right to Repair bill.... More >

8/3/2010 - PHMSA Proposes New Rule For Explosives Transport
The Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA) has issued a notice of proposed rulemaking to change rules governing safe havens for the transportation of certain explosives.... More >