Heavy Duty Trucking Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Economic Watch: Trucking Employment Sinks, Manufacturing Gains

Trucking employment in the U.S. slipped in September despite overall non-farm job growth moving higher for the 72nd straight month, according to a new Labor Department report. But other reports indicate manufacturing is regaining some steam, fueling speculation over an interest rate hike.

Evan Lockridge
Evan LockridgeFormer Business Contributing Editor
October 7, 2016
Economic Watch: Trucking Employment Sinks, Manufacturing Gains

 

6 min to read


Trucking employment in the U.S. slipped in September despite overall non-farm job growth moving higher for the 72nd straight month, according to a new Labor Department report. But other reports indicate manufacturing in the country is regaining some steam, fueling speculation over an interest rate hike.

For-hire trucking lost 3,600 jobs following an upwardly revised gain of 4,000 in August, while the wider transportation and warehousing sector saw a loss of 9,000 jobs last month. This follows job losses in March through June.

Ad Loading...

Overall, the economy added 156,000 jobs in September, fewer than many analysts were expecting and the smallest number since May. The six-month average slowed from 174,000 to 169,000, the weakest since November 2012.

Despite the September increase, the nation’s unemployment rate moved higher by a tenth of a point from August to 5% in September as the overall pool of available workers increased.

As labor markets move closer to full employment, the availability of workers will increasingly limit the monthly increase in hiring, according to Paul Ferley, assistant chief economist at Royal Bank of Canada Economics.

Ad Loading...

“The rise in the unemployment rate might argue against this tightening – though, given that it resulted from a surge in the labor force, it suggests increasing optimism among those currently unemployed to find work," he said. “The steady rise in wage growth also points to strengthening labor markets.”

Assuming continued stability in financial markets, Ferley said tightening labor markets would argue in favor of the Federal Reserve’s Open Market Committee hiking interest rates again soon. RBC believes that is more likely to happen next year, “as the central bank awaits greater confirmation that this labor market strength is fueling above-average, and sustained, gross domestic product growth.”

Others have a slightly different perspective, noting continued improvement in the labor market was at the forefront of the Fed’s latest talking points, suggesting the possibility of a year-end rate hike. Analyst Diane Swonk, speaking earlier this week at the American Trucking Associations' Management Conference & Exhibition, said she expects an increase at the end of the year.

The central bank committee has two more meetings scheduled for this year, in early November and mid-December.

Manufacturing and more

The jobs report followed other important economic news from earlier in the week, including a Commerce Department report showing new orders for manufactured goods rose 0.2% in August. That marks the second straight monthly hike after two consecutive months of weakness. The level of such shipments was nearly unchanged, but is up five out of the last six months.

Ad Loading...

Despite these gains, new orders and shipments are down 2.6% and 2.7%, respectively, from the same time a year earlier, which has likely resulted in part of the decline seen in truck freight levels and consequently pricing.

On a more upbeat note, a proxy of business investment, orders for new nondefense capital goods minus aircraft, increased 0.9% in August. Analysts hope this is a sign that businesses are beginning to spend again to expand and modernize their facilities, according to AP.

It reports one of the strongest categories in August was oil field and mining equipment, which climbed 6.1% after surging 48.4% in July and 223% in June. The sector has been struggling as energy companies cut exploration and drilling in response to the steep decline in oil prices over the past two years, resulting in some big negative effects for some trucking companies involved in the energy sector.

Oil prices moved past the $50 per barrel mark in the first week of October for the first time since June (although Hurricane Matthew could have something to do with that), as the U.S. oil rig count also moved higher for the 14th out of the past 15 weeks.

Meantime, two other reports on manufacturing also showed growth in the sector, though one indicated the level was slightly lower in September than it was in August.

Ad Loading...

The seasonally adjusted final IHS Markit U.S. Manufacturing Purchasing Managers’ Index registered 51.5 in September, down slightly from 52 in August, signaling the weakest improvement in overall business conditions since June.

Slower rates of output and new order growth were the main factors weighing on the headline index, which more than offset a stronger contribution from the staff hiring component.

However, a similar but more closely watched survey of the nation’s purchasing managers by the Institute for Supply Management showed not only an increase last month, but also a return of growth following a one-month reduction in August. Its Purchasing Managers Index registered 51.5%, an increase of 2.1 percentage points from the August reading of 49.4%, beating many analysts’ expectations.

In both reports, a number above 50 indicates manufacturing is expanding while below 50 signals contraction.

The ISM New Orders Index registered 55.1%, an increase of 6 percentage points from the August reading. The Production Index registered 52.8, 3.2 percentage points higher the month before.

Ad Loading...

The Employment Index registered 49.7%, an increase of 1.4 percentage points from the August reading of 48.3%. Nine of the 18 industries reported an increase in new orders in September, up from six in August. Ten of the 18 industries reported an increase in production in September, up from eight in August.

Since peaking in mid-2014, U.S. manufacturing has continued to struggle to gain momentum. After months of contraction late last year, month-to-month volatility has increased more recently, with a slight upward bias pushing activity back near-breakeven levels, according to Lindsey Piegza, chief economist at Stifel Fixed Income.

“[The] improvement is a welcome step in the right direction; however, continued minimal growth, both domestic and international, will most likely limit domestic production from contributing much, if anything, to second-half [of the year] growth,” she said. “Nevertheless, a better-than-expected report, even one month, helps alleviate fears of economic contraction and furthermore, bolsters the argument for the Fed to raise [interest rates] sooner than later.”

Commenting on the IHS Markit PMI report, Chris Williamson, chief business economist there, said the economy is stuck in a soft patch amid widespread uncertainty in the lead up to the presidential election.

“The survey saw firms pulling back on expanding production and focusing instead on cost-cutting, as inflows of new business slowed to the weakest seen so far this year,” he said. “Any growth is largely being driven by the consumer, in turn helped by tail-winds of low interest rates, low inflation and a solid labor market.”

Ad Loading...

If all of these reports leave you feeling uncertain, to say the least, you are not alone. Just a few days earlier during the American Trucking Associations annual Management Conference & Exhibtion in Las Vegas, economist Diane Swonk said there is a lot of uncertainty about where the economy is headed. The good news is there is reason for hope that it and business conditions for trucking are slowing improving. 


More Fleet Management

Illustration of a chalkboard with a hand drawing an arrow curving away from a partially erased straight arrow with the words "Embracing Change," the Heavy Duty Trucking Logo and the "cover feature" graphic.
Fleet Managementby Deborah LockridgeAugust 1, 2026

How Innovative Trucking Leaders Turn Change Into an Advantage

As the pace of change accelerates in trucking, the fleets that adapt best have more than the latest technology. They have cultures that embrace improvement.

Read More →
Illustration of past due invoices with red X on top with background of a truck at a loading dock
Fleet ManagementJuly 27, 2026

Freight Broker Bonds Just Got Harder to Get. Here's What That Means for Your Fleet.

When it gets harder for a freight broker to prove they are financially sound, the ones who cannot clear that bar get pushed out of the market. And those are exactly the brokers who used to leave motor carriers holding the bag.

Read More →
Photo of cable bridge crossing Detroit River
Fleet Managementby Deborah LockridgeJuly 23, 2026

Long-Awaited Canadian Border Bridge to Open in Detroit

For trucking, the bridge opening should offer immediate improvements in efficiency and reliability, with new customs facilities, expanded inspection capacity, and direct freeway-to-freeway connections.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Blue International heavy-duty truck with Aurora driverless truck software coming head-on on an interstate highway
Equipmentby Deborah LockridgeJuly 22, 2026

Aurora Rolls Out Next Generation of Driverless Trucks for Commercial Freight

Aurora's latest autonomous trucks it's rolling out with International feature lower-cost hardware designed for a million miles as the company expands commercial driverless freight operations across the U.S. Sun Belt.

Read More →
American Trucking Associations for-hire tonnage graph
Fleet Managementby Deborah LockridgeJuly 21, 2026

Freight Tonnage Down, Rates up, as Lower Capacity Powers Trucking Recovery

The recovery from the freight recession continues to be driven by reduction in capacity rather than by increased demand.

Read More →
Cyberstop column header depicting images of ChatGPT prompt on a smartphone and shadowy hooded figure
Fleet Managementby Ben WilkensJuly 17, 2026

Think Your Trucking Fleet Isn't Using Much AI? Think Again

Shadow AI — the use of unauthorized artificial intelligence tools at work — is becoming increasingly common, putting sensitive company data at risk. Learn how trucking fleets can protect sensitive data while embracing AI.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Photo of semi trucks with Panther, ArcBest, and ABF trailers backed up to docks, with ArcBest logo superimposed on top
Fleet Managementby Deborah LockridgeJuly 17, 2026

ArcBest Consolidates Brands, Cuts Workforce

The company will bring three business units under the ArcBest brand, eliminate about 2% of positions, and expects the changes to generate $40 million in annual savings.

Read More →
Cover of ATRI operational costs study with graph clip art and photo of trucks on highway in the background
Fleet Managementby Deborah LockridgeJuly 15, 2026

Trucking Fleets Faced Record Operating Costs During Third Year of Freight Recession

ATRI's annual operational cost report shows carriers trimmed fleets, delayed equipment purchases, and ran older trucks as expenses continued to outpace freight rates.

Read More →
Micheline AI Assistant.

Michelin Adds AI Assistant to MyConnectedFleet Platform

Michelin’s new generative AI tool delivers instant fleet insights, helping managers analyze fuel use, tire maintenance, vehicle status, and operational performance without manually creating reports.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
LytxOne Platform.

LytxOne Platform Now Features AI, Compliance, and Asset Tracking Tools

New enhancements add AI-powered insights, asset tracking, compliance automation, and configurable privacy controls to Lytx's all-in-one fleet management platform.

Read More →