Heavy Duty Trucking Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Analysis: Look Deeper Into GDP Numbers for Better Trucking Insight

GDP doesn't always tell the whole story of trucking's economic climate. That's why MacKay & Company developed its proprietary measure, Truckable Economic Activity, reflecting the portion of the GDP that spends its time in trucks.

Evan Lockridge
Evan LockridgeFormer Business Contributing Editor
May 11, 2017
Analysis: Look Deeper Into GDP Numbers  for Better Trucking Insight

Photo: istockphoto.com/rimeimages

3 min to read


Photo: istockphoto.com/rimeimages

As you’re reading this, one of first and most closely watched indicators of the overall economic performance of the American economy has been issued. And while it’s the first major reading of how conditions are shaping up for 2017, you are best advised not to read too much into the figures, be it good or bad.

Ad Loading...

The federal government’s reading of the gross domestic product, a measure of the country’s total output of goods and services, had yet to be released at press time, but many analysts were expecting it to reflect an expansion of just a 1% to 2% annual rate. That’s compared to a 2.1% rate in the final quarter of last year and 3.5% in the third quarter of 2016. In other words, the consensus is a less than stellar first quarter performance.

Ad Loading...

However, the first quarter can be a bit “quirky,” says Bob Dieli, chief economist at the commercial trucking market research firm MacKay & Company.

“Weather has increasingly become a factor in [the] first quarter,” he told HDT in an interview. Remember the Polar Vortex in early 2014? The extremely cold weather in much of the country killed GDP for the quarter. And while not as bad, the U.S. did get hit with some powerful weather last month.

“I would not put a whole lot of trust in the first [GDP] number for the first quarter,” Dieli said. Each quarterly GDP performance can be revised two times with more complete data, including foreign trade. And it’s these foreign trade numbers than can play hell with trying to make sense out of the GDP when it comes to trucking.

As Uncle Sam counts it, when goods are imported, they count as a negative to the GDP. In contrast, export goods, because they are made in the U.S., are considered a positive. Problem is, the U.S. consistently has more exports than imports, which can weigh down the GDP to one extent or another.

That’s one reason MacKay & Company developed its proprietary measure, Truckable Economic Activity, reflecting the portion of the GDP that spends its time in trucks. This measure, unlike the GDP, counts half of imports as positive. “We think that an import generates fewer truck moves than a good that has been on our shores the whole time,” Dieli explained — but it’s still considered a positive, unlike how it’s reflected in the GDP.

Ad Loading...

At the end of May, MacKay & Company will release its first quarter Truckable Economic Activity, which relies not only on the government’s initial first quarter GDP performance, but also on the revised and more complete second one of those three reports.

Also unlike the GDP report, the TEA report measures economic activity, not from quarter to quarter, but rather year-over-year, meaning the first quarter of 2017 is compared to the same time in 2016.

Such a different comparison, Dieli said, is done “because of questions of volatility” about quarter-to-quarter GDP numbers, and it’s easier to explain how the economy is doing.

The most recent TEA report showed the nation’s “truckable economy” expanded at a rate of 2.9% in the fourth quarter of 2016 compared to a year earlier, while federal GDP numbers showed just a 2.1% annual increase – a fairly significant difference.

That’s also because TEA measures only goods – not good and services, like the GDP reports. The service sectors of housing and medical care make up the largest two GDP components, Dieli said – but they don’t travel by truck.

Ad Loading...

So, as you’re reading about the first report on GDP performance this month, or anytime in the future for that matter, keep in mind while it’s important, it doesn’t necessarily tell you everything you need to know when it comes to the trucking part of the economy.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Fleet Management

ATA President Chris Spear.
Fleet Managementby Jack RobertsMarch 17, 2026

ATA’s Spear Warns Fuel Prices, Trade Policy, and Global Conflict Could Stall Trucking Recovery

Speaking at the TMC Annual Meeting in Nashville, ATA President Chris Spear said trucking faces mounting pressure from rising fuel prices, geopolitical instability, and uncertainty around trade policy.

Read More →
Illustration of author headshot with black-and-white old-fashioned rig in the background

New Entrants, Chameleon Carriers, and Safety: Is It Too Easy to Start a Trucking Company?

More than 100,000 new trucking companies enter the industry each year, but regulators manage to audit only a fraction of them. That churn creates opportunities for inexperienced startups — and for “chameleon carriers” that shut down after safety violations and reappear under new identities. Read more from Deborah Lockridge in this commentary.

Read More →
Panel discussion
Fleet Managementby Deborah LockridgeMarch 12, 2026

Fleet Managers Invited to Apply for Exclusive HDT Exchange Event

HDTX is an intimate event that connects heavy-duty trucking fleet managers with industry suppliers through small-group discussions, educational sessions, and structured one-on-one meetings.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
DAT iPhone Widget.
Fleet Managementby News/Media ReleaseMarch 12, 2026

DAT Launches iPhone Widget to Help Owner-Operators Find Loads Faster

New DAT One feature shows top-paying loads directly on an iPhone’s home screen, helping carriers react faster to spot-market opportunities.

Read More →
Optimal Dynamics Scale screen shot
Fleet Managementby News/Media ReleaseMarch 12, 2026

Optimal Dynamics Launches AI System to Help Carriers Choose Better Freight

Optimal Dynamics says its new Scale platform uses AI agents and optimization to help carriers find and secure freight that improves network balance and profitability.

Read More →
DAT March 2026 trucking conditions.
Fleet Managementby Jack RobertsMarch 12, 2026

DAT: Flatbed Demand Climbs as Van and Reefer Rates Soften

DAT Freight & Analytics data shows tightening flatbed capacity, easing produce markets, and softening van and reefer rates.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
YouTube thumbnail with Mike Roeth of NACFE saying "NACFE's Messy Middle: Which Fuel Wins?"
Fuel Smartsby Deborah LockridgeMarch 11, 2026

Run on Less “Messy Middle” Data Shows Multiple Paths Forward for Truck Powertrains [Watch]

NACFE's Run on Less - Messy Middle project demonstrates the power of data in helping to guide the future of alternative fuels and powertrains for heavy-duty trucks.

Read More →
Illustration of crowded New York street overlaid with dollar signs
Fleet Managementby Deborah LockridgeMarch 11, 2026

Federal Court Lets NYC Congestion Pricing Continue

A federal court ruling allows New York City’s congestion pricing program to continue, leaving truck tolls in place for fleets delivering into Manhattan.

Read More →
Fontaine Modification Access365
Fleet Managementby News/Media ReleaseMarch 10, 2026

Fontaine Modification Launches Real-Time Truck Modification Tracking Portal

Fontaine Modification has introduced a new customer portal designed to give fleets real-time visibility into the truck modification process, addressing one of the most common questions fleet managers face: “Where’s my truck?”

Read More →
Ad Loading...
FTR Tucking Conditions March 2026.
Fleet Managementby Jack RobertsMarch 10, 2026

FTR: Trucking Conditions Index Climbs to Highest Level Since 2022

Strong freight rates, rising volumes and tighter capacity push trucking conditions higher, though diesel prices could temper gains in the near term, FTR cautions.

Read More →