Trailer Talk

Stronger Impact Guards Are Already Here

Canadian-spec "bumpers" have been standard on vans and reefers for a decade or more, so the feds' upcoming mandate for stronger equipment is not a big deal.

March 2, 2016

SHARING TOOLS        | Print Subscribe
Is that bumper a Canadian- or American-spec? It could be either. Photo: Tom Berg
Is that bumper a Canadian- or American-spec? It could be either. Photo: Tom Berg

Stronger rear impact guards will soon be required by federal government regulators, but it’s not a big deal to trailer makers or users because they're already out there. These are Canadian-sped guards, or “bumpers,” which a lot of people still call them.

Trailer manufacturers have made Canadian-style bumpers standard on vans and reefers for quite a while because many of them travel into Canada, where they’re required. They’re also safer, and folks in trucking care about that.

Canadian guards are designed to absorb impacts of up to 35 mph, while American-style guards are engineered to withstand 30-mph impacts. Thirty-five miles per hour is what the feds want.

You might think 5 mph is not much of a difference, but the static-test forces involved in that 5-mph increment are almost double — a little over 78,000 pounds for the Canadian bumper vs. 44,000 pounds for the American spec,  says Charlie Fetz, Great Dane Trailers’ chief engineer.

He was among the active participants in a task force meeting discussing a recommended practice for repairing rear underride guards. Led by Gary Fenton of Stoughton Trailers, it was one of many sessions during this week’s Technology & Maintenance Council meeting in Nashville, Tenn.

Until this session I thought that Canadian bumpers were easy to spot. They have two extra vertical posts, one at each end, right? Wrong, Fetz and Fenton told me. Those posts are there primarily to keep a guy’s foot from slipping sideways and off the horizontal member as he’s climbing into a trailer.

The horizontal bar – the actual bumper, in most people’s eyes – is also a handy step, and most are made with non-slip surfaces on their upper face. And usually there’s a grab handle on the trailer’s rear door sill to aid the climber. Canadian bumpers are stronger because their supporting braces and the rear of the trailer’s structure are beefier.

There’s nothing simple about the impact guards, the two engineers said. Every trailer builder must design them to absorb specified impact forces in certain types of rear-end collisions. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration allows manufacturers to self-certify their testing results, while Canadian authorities require proof of satisfactory testing.

Although considerably stronger, the Canadian bumpers don’t cost much more to build and buy, which is one reason fleet managers haven’t complained like their predecessors did when NHTSA demanded stronger bumpers back in the 1990s.

As I recall, some big-fleet managers howled at the prospect of spending several hundred dollars per trailer vs. the cost of the simple types then in use.  They each had 1,000 or more trailers and a few bucks added up to big bucks. Now that kind of money is not much because overall prices have climbed a great deal.

Also, people today seem more sympathetic to the injuries and deaths suffered by motorists who rear-end trailers, even if they are to blame. And law suits by the errant motorists and their survivors are far more expensive than what the equipment costs.

As I’ve written in past articles, my best buddy in college was killed when he rear-ended a trailer on a dark, rainy night, so I’m one who takes this bumper business seriously.

Comments

  1. 1. Steve P [ March 03, 2016 @ 05:08AM ]

    Someone needs to start adding up the cost as I did everything that they want to add to you or your equipment . in the name of safety is outrageous.It would be better to teach the Motoring Public what to and not do around Trucks. Put down all the cell phones to start and then pay attention to what and where you are Going. Why has it became Truckings job to make everyone safe what ever happens to keeping the person responsible for what they dIn a few more years we will be required to install guard rails all the way around the trucks. Go ahead Laugh. Bottom line is people are not responsible for themselves. And it is always someone else's fault. Welcome to the Nanny America.

  2. 2. Michael Galorath [ March 03, 2016 @ 07:29AM ]

    Excellent point. Here's an addition the GHG keeps trying to find way to get better fuel efficiency! So what will the weight of these bumpers cost in fuel. Where is the trad off.

 

Comment On This Story

Name:  
Email:  
Comment: (Maximum 2000 characters)  
Leave this field empty:
* Please note that every comment is moderated.

Author Bio

Tom Berg

sponsored by

Senior Contributing Editor

Journalist since 1965, truck writer and editor since 1978. CDL-qualified; conducts road tests on new heavy-, medium- and light-duty tractors and trucks. Specializes in vocational and hybrid vehicles.

Newsletter

We offer e-newsletters that deliver targeted news and information for the entire fleet industry.

GotQuestions?

ELDs and Telematics

sponsored by
sponsor logo

Scott Sutarik from Geotab will answer your questions and challenges

View All

Sleeper Cab Power

Steve Carlson from Xantrex will answer your questions and challenges

View All