Auto Focus

Addressing the Problem of Unsecured Loads

If you don’t think unsecured loads in pickups and trailers are a national problem, some new data from NHTSA, Maria Federici’s story and a disturbing video will make you think otherwise.

April 2, 2013

SHARING TOOLS        | Print Subscribe

We’ve all been there – the truck or trailer in front of us looks like it’s about to lose its load all over the roadway. We switch lanes, shake our heads at the potential safety hazard and move along. But Maria Federici never had that chance. Close to midnight on Feb. 22, 2004, a piece of furniture flew off of a U-Haul trailer in front of her and crashed through her windshield, striking her face. The injury left her blind, without the ability to smell or taste and facing years of reconstructive surgeries and physical therapy.

The driver was issued a traffic citation and nothing more. Because failing to secure a load wasn’t breaking the law, Federici was not officially a victim and therefore not eligible for crime victims’ assistance. Thus began the crusade of Federici’s mother, Robin Abel, to change the law and raise awareness of the problem of unsecured loads.

As a result of Abel’s efforts, under Washington state’s “Maria’s Law,” a person who caused an injury or death by failing to secure a load could be charged with a gross misdemeanor, face a year in jail and a $5,000 fine. And the victim is eligible for the state's Crime Victims Compensation Program. Concurrently, a lawsuit was filed against U-Haul and the driver, and a civil jury awarded Federici a multi-million dollar judgment.

ADVERTISEMENT

Abel hasn’t stopped there. She successfully pushed to get funding for a national study on unsecured loads. The outcome was a report released late last year that was commissioned by the Government Accountability Office (GAO) with data from NHTSA.

The study found that about 440 deaths in 2010 could be attributed to roadway debris. The number could be greater, but proper reporting is an issue. Every state has a statute regarding unsecured loads. Though most exempt commercial activities, nine states have statutes that apply to all vehicles. Fines range from $10 to $5,000, while 15 states add the possibility of imprisonment.

Abel is also looking to testify in front of the U.S. Senate Commerce Committee to gain support for national legislation and for state bills to be modeled after Maria’s Law.

Abel has spearheaded awareness campaigns through the Washington State Patrol, among other organizations. The efforts have worked: From 2005 to 2010, total reported incidents in Washington state regarding unsecured loads that resulted in an injury or death have dropped from 432 to 287, or 34%.

Most awareness campaigns and legislative efforts concentrate on non-commercial loads. For commercial vehicles under the jurisdiction of the Department of Transportation (DOT), the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) already has strict guidelines regarding load securement.

“Most commercial drivers fully embrace their responsibilities and are in tune with the laws set by Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards,” says Captain Rob Huss of the Washington State Patrol.

Legislation of a commercial nature is generally directed at load securement for dirt, sand, rocks and gravel, specifically whether those loads should be required to be covered or not. One such bill is pending in Washington state. Huss hasn’t encountered significant pushback from those targeted industries. “It’s in their best interests to conduct their businesses safely and professionally,” he says. “They don’t want problems or liability associated with the work they want to do.”

A gray area arises, however, regarding the many fleets operating locally that don’t fall under DOT rules and may not have gotten the proper education. Huss agrees, and has seen it all – including the utility trailer that lost wood and metal roofing material onto the highway and windshield of his patrol car.

“It’s those types that you need to reach, too,” he says. “It is just as important to give them their due attention as anyone else.”

For small fleet managers that need more ammo to reinforce load securement with their drivers, consider:

  • A 20-pound object traveling at 55 mph hits with the force of 1,000 pounds at the time of impact. “You literally have weapons in your vehicle when aerodynamics takes over,” Abel says.
  • Maria Federici’s initial prognosis was terminal, and her mother had carried out her daughter’s directive to donate her organs. Instead of pulling the plug, the doctors kept her on life support to keep the organs functioning. The next day Federici miraculously pulled through. Robin Abel (425-430-8204) would consider speaking about her daughter’s incredible story and her legislative and educational efforts.
  • Stay tuned for an article in the May/June issue of Business Fleet Magazine on how to properly secure your load (you can click here to get email notifications when our digital magazine issues come out). 
  • This video is a good visual wakeup call to show what can happen with road debris. I’m warning you, it will make you jump. 

Indeed, while fines sting and a civil judgment could sink a company, “The key thing is education, because no one sets out to harm people, they just don’t think about it,” Abel says.

Huss adds, “Someone who lost debris which struck and hurt or killed someone weighs much heavier than any potential fine that can be received. Securing a load properly is a small request to ensure the overall safety of everyone else.”

Comments

  1. 1. Ex-Fleetmanager [ April 03, 2013 @ 03:40PM ]

    Hello Chris,
    I am an ex-fleet manager from the auto rental industry, I want to take a moment here to express the exposure and liability for the car rental companies. Over the last 9 years I have seen GRS De-Fueling Services working at the car rental lots using oil totes and stationary fuel tanks bolted down onto a trailer hooked up to the back of a pick-up truck being trailered around the car rental premises while in the process of vehicle de-fueling and said company is moving these tanks onto public road ways with gasoline inside. Talk about a problem of unsecured loads. Not only is it a problem but it is an explosion waiting to happen; I feel that this has been a very big oversight from the Department of Highway and Safety, Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration and the DOT Administration.

  2. 2. Kevin Wuollet [ April 03, 2013 @ 05:51PM ]

    I am a retired DOT officer and former contract auditor with Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration. I currently work as a DOT consultant and private DOT Inspector. The ex Fleet manager is correct on his concern on the GRS De Fueling. I have looked at these tanks and they are bombs waiting to go off. The tanks are single walled tanks designed for being a stationary tank. They do not have rollover protection and are not DOT Spec tanks that are double walled. they are not meant to used on the road. I am currently filing a complaint with a Fl. State DOT Major in charge of Hazardous materials and with James Gregg of FMCSA of Fl after this i am going to file a complaint with PHMSA Pipeline Hazardous Materials Safety Administration. If People think they are immune to the liability of these bombs in their car rental lots they should rethink their idea of what their liability will be.

  3. 3. Mark [ February 25, 2014 @ 06:11AM ]

    Just yesterday, on my motorcycle, I had to avoid objects flying out of a pickup truck due to an unsecured load. I ended up running over most of it due to it being styrofoam sheeting. There is a video of a horrible motorcycle wreck on YouTube involving an unsecured box of styrofoam sheeting flying out of a pickup truck near McAllen, TX. Thankfully the riders were released from the hospital the next day with only bruises and road rash. It can be found at http://youtu.be/w8Yu7U-ulIg

Comment On This Story

Name:  
Email: (Email will not be displayed.)  
Comment: (Maximum 2000 characters)  
Leave this field empty:
* Please note that every comment is moderated.

Author Bio

Chris Brown

Executive Editor

Chris Brown is the executive editor of Business Fleet Magazine and Auto Rental News. Through these publications, online newsletters, trade events and associations, Chris covers all aspects of the fleet world, including fleet management, manufacturer fleet activities, the fleet leasing industry, vehicle remarketing, rental industry news, car rental taxation and legislation.

Sponsored by

Newsletter

We offer e-newsletters that deliver targeted news and information for the entire fleet industry.



GotQuestions?

LUBRICANTS

The expert, Mark Betner from Citgo will answer your questions
Ask a question

Sponsored by


WHEEL ENDS SOLUTIONS

Wheel end expert Jeff Geist from STEMCO will answer your questions
Ask a question

Sponsored by

Magazine