June 2014, TruckingInfo.com - WebXclusive
The harm from overinflating tires, especially those that run a high percentage of unloaded miles, could outweigh the perceived gains in fuel efficiency.
Underinflation kills not only tires, but fuel economy too. According to Rick Phillips, senior director of sales, commercial and OTR products at Yokohama Tire, a tire underinflated by 10% can result in 20% increase in rolling resistance, and a corresponding drop in fuel economy.
For as hard as fleets work for a 1% gain in fuel efficiency, it's hard to imagine giving up something like 2-4% in fuel efficiency to something as simple as maintaining correct inflation pressure, especially today when almost every inflation or monitoring system on the market offers payback in less than a year.
Improper inflation bites you in two ways: it reduces the ability of the tire sidewall to support the load on the tire which increases the degree to which the sidewall will flex, and it changes the footprint or contact patch of the tire.
"It is not the tire, but the air inside it that supports the load," says Guy Walenga, Bridgestone director of engineering, commercial products and technologies. "And it is the air inside the casing that keeps that casing the right shape."
The energy needed to make the sidewall flex consumes extra fuel, and that partially explains why wide-base single tires can be more fuel-efficient. Since a single wide-base tire replaces a dual assembly, there are half as many sidewalls flexing.
Additionally, as the contact patch changes, more or less rubber will be in contact with the pavement, and that could generate higher than normal drag at the tread area. This will eventually reveal itself as irregular wear, but in the meantime, you're consuming more fuel pulling the softer tire through its rotation.
According to Al Cohn of Pressure Systems International, it's all about the footprint of the tire.
"When you over-inflate, the footprint changes and it gets a little smaller," he says. "But the biggest impact is -- and this is what people don’t normally talk about -- the loaded vs. unloaded condition, especially on trailers. Because you’re spec'ing the pressure based on the loaded worst-case scenario, but in many cases, they’re empty, or at least a lot lighter than fully loaded. So when you’re empty -- I mean it’s great for rolling resistance and fuel economy -- but the tire is going to develop all kinds of issues like uneven wear because it is bouncing along the highway."
Several things happen to a tire that's over-inflated for its load.
"The tread tends to crown, leaving the shoulders of the tire scrubbing along the road as it tries to keep pace with the larger circumference of the center of the tread," says Walenga. "That causes all kinds of wear along the edges of the tire."
Even though the "industry standard" pressure for drive and trailer tires seems to be 100 psi, is that the correct pressure?
Yokohama's Phillips seems to be the outlier on this issue. He suggests fleets should be running dual tires in a fully loaded tandem axle (34,000 pounds) at 80 psi, not 100.
"The higher number might be easier to remember, or provide a hedge against underinflation, but it could be compromising traction and tire performance," he says. "I've seen very little evidence of quantifiable fuel economy gains from running at 100 psi rather than 80, but I can show lots of tires that were scrapped prematurely because of irregular wear arising from overinflation."
Looking forward, Phillips says tires could become very sensitive to inflation pressure.
"We're looking very hard at the footprint of the tire, and if we can manage that contact patch exactly as we want it to be, we think it will do a lot for the performance of the tire," he says. "If you run the tire at its design pressure, you run it the way it was designed to run, which gives you optimum traction, mileage and minimizes inflation-related irregular wear, so you get best performance over the life of the tire."
In other words, running tires under-inflated – below the recommended pressure found on the tire makers' load and inflation tables – will hurt tire performance and fuel economy, but overinflating tires may compromise tread life with few if any gains in fuel consumption.